The year after the 1961 publication of Robert Dahl's Who Governs?, “Two Faces of Power” criticized the treatment of power in this about-to-become classic work. Offering a third way neither elitist nor pluralist, Bachrach and Baratz made no defense of Floyd Hunter's reputational approach and they largely by-passed the literature on social stratification. Instead of revisiting past controversy, they sought to identify a fundamental feature of the political process, offering the second face of power as a wide view of how the game of politics is played.
Consider an analogy. Economists study markets in which businesses compete, subject to the axial constraint of supply and demand. From Adam Smith on, they have supposed a largely benign process. Antitrust advocates see a more complex game in which players seek to rig the rules and squeeze out competition. Who Governs? treats electoral competition as the political counterpart to the free market of classical economics. The process is open and above board, with power observable in the give-and-take of initiatives and vetoes. In “Two Faces of Power,” Bachrach and Baratz assume an antitrust perspective and ask what might not be revealed in immediately observable transactions. Rather than follow the action on contested issues, they urge scholars to step back and assess the flow of the decision process in order to fathom the constraints within which decisions are made. How did these constraints take shape? What political edge do they provide, for whom, and how are they maintained? Actors not only expend energy promoting and opposing discrete policy decisions (the first face of power) but also invest resources in arrangements through which strategic advantages are secured (the second face of power).
Bachrach and Baratz reject the notion that conflict is a neutral arena in which power is exercised. Instead, standing on the shoulders of Schattschneider, they argue that the contours of conflict are themselves a manifestation of power—at least partially the results of efforts to protect privileges and head off unwanted challenges. “Two Faces of Power” forms an important link between the notion of the mobilization of bias and current interest in the new institutionalism. Bachrach and Baratz treat politics as a drama in which no foregone conclusion is played out and a rich mixture of elements is manipulated by the players. Issue framing, investment of effort to create or protect procedures for governing, and strategic alliances provide building blocks from which durable political arrangements are constructed. Yet, although seeing politics as tending toward bias, Bachrach and Baratz stay clear of determinism in its various forms. In their treatment, political systems are not easily penetrable by the disaffected, but political fixes can be overturned or at least modified with the right set of countermoves.
Writing when the behavioral “revolution” had newly gained ascendancy and universal laws of causality were the pot of gold at the end of the research rainbow, Bachrach and Baratz neither embraced the new science of politics nor sought to dismiss it (even though their article was included in the 1967 antibehavioral collection edited by McCoy and Playford [1967]). “Two Faces of Power” and its follow-up study of antipoverty politics in Baltimore took seriously the need for empirical findings, but also acknowledged a guiding interest in social justice. By treating inequality as a central problem, Bachrach and Baratz asked not only “who gets what and how” but also “who gets left out and how” (1980, p. 105). Thus they resisted a narrow treatment of politics and instead suggested scenarios showing why a broad conception is important.
Although bowing to the precept of observability, Bachrach and Baratz expanded the ground rules for the study of political power so as to allow freely for qualitative assessments, informed by normative concerns. They were less concerned with measuring power precisely than with understanding how strategic disadvantage is perpetuated, but might nevertheless be overcome. Were they to enter the discourse today, they would face the continuing challenge of how to differentiate the creative part that political agency can play in a context heavily structured with uneven advantages. The genius of Bachrach and Baratz was to open a line of inquiry so vital to the study of politics that the quest remains, even as partial and important insights accumulate.
Peter Bachrach is Emeritus Professor of Political Science at Temple University. He joined the Temple faculty after leaving Bryn Mawr College, where he first collaborated with Morton Baratz.
Morton Baratz was a long-time faculty member at Bryn Mawr College, where he served as Chair of the Department of Economics. He subsequently joined the faculty at Boston University where he was director of the Urban Institute, and later served as Vice Chancellor of the University of Maryland, Baltimore County.

Comments
No Comments have been published for this article.