From our reliance on television weather reports to our preoccupation with climate change, there is no getting away from meteorological forecasts these days. Yet we know surprisingly little about the origins of forecasting methods. In this compelling monograph, Kristin Harper shows that a recognizably modern approach to the understanding of meteorological phenomena is very recent indeed. Only after the end of the Second World War did powerful computers allow the solution of complex mathematical equations modelling the weather. Their use transformed meteorology, significantly augmenting its forecasting power.
At the beginning of the century, the discipline was underdeveloped and understaffed. Traditional methods of forecasting were cumbersome, relying essentially on rudimentary statistical techniques. The needs of warfare, however, directed military planners' attentions to meteorology's importance, and they more robustly sponsored it. In the meantime, traditional civilian agencies, such as the Weather Bureau in the US, slowly adjusted to the new priorities, eventually taking the lead in the provision of innovative training and research programmes. Leading the transition to modern meteorology was, however, a small group of émigré scientists from Scandinavian countries whose influx proved extremely beneficial to the establishment of meteorology as a scientific discipline in the US. In particular, from the 1930s the Swedish American Carl-Gustav Rossby played a key role, pioneering mathematical approaches and, eventually, developing a general circulation model.
Here is where computers enter the picture. After the Second World War, the mathematician John von Neumann sought to test the efficiency of his newly designed computer, the ENIAC, in dealing with complex mathematical equations. In the context of the Princeton-based ‘Meteorology Project’, he collaborated with Rossby on the design and test of numerical weather-prediction methods. It was the explosion of mainframe computers in the 1950s that finally enabled the transition to operational forecasting. By then, more sophisticated techniques allowed local meteorological events to be handled with a growing degree of accuracy. Harper's account reaches a close on the disagreements between US civilian and military agencies on the research directions to be taken by numerical prediction centres. The former wanted primarily to serve the government with better forecasts, whereas the latter were interested exclusively in the operational use of these forecasts in war theatres.
The great merit of Harper's study is that it goes beyond the narrow focus of previous accounts on the role of computers and computer experts in pioneering forecasting methods – an approach that has led to the widespread notion that modern meteorological analysis resulted mainly from von Neumann's interests in computing technologies. Harper claims instead that his ‘electronic brain’ could play a role in the Meteorological Project only because weather specialists such as Jule Charney and Arnt Eliassen (of the Scandinavian ‘Tag Team’) retained intellectual leadership in the programme. Indeed, on occasions when the meteorologists' work was completed on time but computers failed to be delivered on schedule, the meteorologists were forced to act as substitutes, transforming themselves into ‘human computers’. Thanks to Harper, we can now see the development of numerical weather-prediction methods as the result of an international and cooperative scientific endeavour rather than as a tangential outcome of the solipsistic quest for testing the ENIAC.
It is worth noting too that in many respects this is a valuable contribution not only to the history of meteorology in the US but also to studies in the history of twentieth-century science more generally. This is because Harper concentrates on the interplay of military and civilian institutions, the dependence on governmental funding, the centralization of decision-making and the attention to prediction and manipulation of natural phenomena. Her analysis of political manoeuvring behind the scenes, and of the different agendas of the scientists and agencies involved, is especially intriguing. And even if she does not fully satisfy the reader's hunger for information on the military implications of modern meteorology, Harper sheds new light on the military legacy of weather forecasts in the civilian field. As such, Weather by the Numbers confirms still further the dramatic impact of the Cold War on the many research disciplines dealing with the Earth and the environment.
