Historia económica general de México was conceived as a general survey of the evolution of the Mexico's economy from the colonial period to the present. This book presents the current status of the debates around the most widely studied topics in Mexican economic history by some of the better known scholars in the field in Mexico and abroad. This compilation is organized in four sections corresponding to a period. Each section starts with an introductory chapter that presents the main trends and features of each period and is followed by thematic chapters. This book does not follow the chronology of traditional historiography but rather one that follows the processes and timing of economic development which do not always coincide with political processes. Methodologically, this general survey builds on the insights of the New Institutional Economics. The institutional framework analysis is deemed appropriate to study the long-term evolution of economies, such as Mexico, that have not followed in full the development path of economic development leading nations.
The first section surveys the colonial period, from the arrival of the Spaniards to the mid-eighteenth century. Despite their efforts to reproduce the lifestyle they had back in their old country, Spaniards were forced to preserve certain aspects of the indigenous economy in order to guarantee their food supply as well as to organize the export sector in a way that they could send resources back to the Crown so they could import all commodities they could not get in New Spain. The monarchy continuously attempted to centralize power but the seventeenth century crises forced a readjustment of the colonial order that ended up granting more autonomy and high ranking positions to local groups than the Crown would have wished for. This trend was not reversed until the launching of the Bourbon reforms during the eighteenth century.
The second section looks at the period 1760 to 1850 which includes the Bourbon regime and the first decades of the national era. During this period there were stark contrasts between the vast wealth from mining and the profound inequality, technological backwardness, wage stagnation, economic decline, and devastating agricultural crises. The Independence War and its aftermath brought drastic changes in the fiscal and financial sector; still, there were other sectors such as mining and agriculture in which there were clear continuities with respect to the late colonial period.
The third section studies the period that covers the launching of the liberal reforms in 1856 to the Great Depression in 1929. Mexican economy was at a low point in 1856: the economy was small, barely integrated and close to the international sphere. The liberal government implemented several significant institutional reforms conducive to the establishment of a private property system, the territorial unification, and the improvement of property rights. The implementation of these reforms was incomplete and unequal; nonetheless the economy was opened to the inflow of foreign capitals and foreign trade. The economy was reactivated by export led growth. The Mexican revolution had a brief and minor effect on the path of economic growth and development. In contrast, the 1929 international economic crisis did place a halt in the development model and forced a change in the model towards one that accelerated the modernization of the economy.
The fourth section examines the economy of the “dilated” twentieth century (1929–2009). There are three stages in this period. The first stage is one of sustained economic growth from 1929 to 1970 based on an import substitution model. The second stage goes from 1970 to the mid-1980s and this is a time of stagnation and crisis due to the exhaustion of the import substitution model; this period worked as a transition into the third stage. The last and ongoing stage is characterized by the launching of economic reforms, albeit incomplete, and to the integration of Mexico into the global economy. Public policies and political factors have influenced economic performance. The balance of this strategy is slow economic growth.
This book effectively brings together the scholarship of the colonial period and the nineteenth century with the most current period all under one coherent analytical framework that enables the reader to get a clear sense of long-term trends of the Mexican economy. It successfully links the past to current problems such as the need for fiscal, energy, and labor reforms (p. 544). It sheds light on the long-term causes of slow development and growth in the Mexican economy and leaves us with valuable lessons for the future of which four are with highlighting: institutional factors are key to foster or hinder economic growth; Mexico has had periods of sustained economic growth with different development models, therefore these models are not a decisive element in Mexico's capacity for economic growth; there is not a single recipe for growth that is universally valid, theories should be adequately adapted to reality of each nation and last, to understand the present status of the Mexican economy it is necessary to have a knowledge and understanding of long term processes and of its economic history (pp. 798–99). It is laudable that both historians and economists participated in this collective effort expressing that, as far as Mexican economic history is concerned, economists and historians can still talk.
It would have been impossible to compile in one book a study of all relevant topics, both chronological and thematic, of Mexico's economic history. This is why this book does not tackle with subjects such as economic history of the preconquest period and does not delve on topics related to human capital development to mention some missing points. The coordinator clearly states the limits in depth and extent of this work posed by its very nature. The voids in this study are expressed as an invitation to young economic historians to pursue new research agendas (p. 17). The contents and organization of this book make it an excellent reading for graduate and undergraduate economic history courses as well as a valuable and highly recommended reference source for economic historians doing comparative work not specializing on Mexico.
