Michael J. Allen has published what must be considered the definitive historical account of the United States' efforts to account for POWs and MIAs from the Vietnam War. Allen combines extensive archival research with arguments drawn from cultural studies, history, and political science to present a comprehensive and accessible narrative of a subject whose many twists and turns have effectively transformed it into a cultural Rorschach test. For a large variety of reasons, Americans missing in Vietnam have been a little bit of something to very nearly everyone. Thanks to his meticulous research and the clarity of his analysis, Allen is able to parse these reasons and thereby explain the multiple and often conflicting motivations behind the preoccupation with Vietnam War missing. The book's central argument is that “the ordeal of captivity during the war and the inability to recover missing Americans at its end became the dominant means through which millions of Americans addressed their nation's defeat in Vietnam” (3). In the late sixties and early seventies, the missing were for the antiwar movement a reason to get out of Vietnam and for the Nixon regime a reason for staying the course. In the decades since the return of American POWs in the spring of 1973, the missing have been proof of U.S. government duplicity, evidence of the inherent evil of the Vietnamese communists, and much else besides. Allen persuasively situates these competing interpretations within what he calls “the politics of loss” (8). The phrase is shorthand for the unending domestic battles still being fought over the meaning of the loss in Vietnam, public memory of the war, and how to parcel out responsibility for the war's many consequences—battles fought using the absent bodies of POWs and MIAs as ammunition.
The quantity of book-length academic studies specifically dedicated to Vietnam War POWs and MIAs is not vast. By my count, Allen is preceded by just three authors: H. Bruce Franklin, author of M.I.A. or Mythmaking In America: How and Why Belief in Live POWs Has Possessed a Nation (Rutgers University Press, 1992); Craig Howes, author of Voices of the Vietnam War POWs: Witnesses to Their Fight (Oxford University Press, 1993); and myself, author of The Remains of War: Bodies, Politics, and the Search for American Soldiers Unaccounted For in Southeast Asia (Duke University Press, 2005). Other books on the subject can be divided between volumes written by government officials involved in the accounting process and which tend to be good, if undertheorized, sources of information, and those by self-styled POW/MIA activists which are typically taken seriously only by fellow travelers who believe that some number of living Americans were held, or are still being held, against their will in Southeast Asia. Franklin's emphasis on the overt charlatanism of those in this last category often leads him to downplay the very real cultural and political effects of missing servicemen. Howes's book is dedicated to giving voice to the experiences of the POWs who returned from Southeast Asia with relatively little emphasis on the search for the missing, while my book is an explicitly theoretical treatment of the significance of lost bodies within the contentious legacy of the Vietnam War. What sets Allen's book apart, and what makes it such an important contribution to the subject, is the truly enormous quantity of archival research that went into it. Allen is the first researcher to exploit this archival material to its full potential, and it is this research that makes Until the Last Man Comes Home the authoritative historical treatment of the subject of Americans missing in Southeast Asia.
I say this without wishing to prejudice the analytical and argumentative dimensions of the text, which are generally well situated within the wealth of historical data. Allen engages most substantively with questions of public memory. He argues against a view of public memory as “constructed by powerful elites in service of their interests” in favor of “a more participatory process in which seemingly marginal figures played leading roles” (10). Easily the most important of these seemingly marginal figures has been the National League of Families of American Prisoners and Missing in Southeast Asia. Originally composed of a small group of wives of imprisoned airmen, the League ultimately became the most powerful domestic force shaping American policy toward the missing. In the process, the League sparked debate over who gets to do the work of commemorating a lost and divisive war. By foregrounding “the idea that the family trumps the community,” the League succeeded in “recall[ing] the loss of American men in Vietnam as an unforgivable betrayal” (153–54). The missing were their men, and efforts to think of these men as other than betrayed by their country (e.g., as regrettable but inevitable artifacts of mechanized warfare) were simply further evidence of this betrayal. Not only did this representation of the missing help secure the League's influence over government policy, it changed the interpretive parameters of the state's relationship to war dead. Whereas “once the state's commitment to the war dead gave institutional form and ideological substance to the national community, justifying an expansion of government powers and war-making authority, after Vietnam the state's obligations to and responsibility for the war dead were made an indictment of a government grown too powerful for the good of its people” (8–9).
In other places, however, the analytical elements of Allen's book are less compelling. Freighted categories such as race, gender, and justice make occasional but brief appearances in the text and then quickly disappear. Regarding the latter, Allen relates the POW/MIA activists' complaints that government accounting efforts “placed healing before justice” and that “resolution on these terms meant forgetting,” a circumstance which in turn “held no one responsible for the loss of American lives in Vietnam” (171–72). While it is clear that Allen views these allegations skeptically, a more complete elaboration of the concept of justice would help situate them within the politics of loss. Despite what families of the missing may say, it is not obviously true that healing displaces justice or that the quest for responsible agents restores it. Likewise, forgetting can be a form of justice, as when two parties bury the hatchet in the service of future harmony. Yet with loss comes resentment and with resentment the straitened and relentlessly self-serving notion of justice which has characterized POW/MIA activism in the aftermath of the Vietnam War. Allen acknowledges this circumstance, but refrains from exploring the full range of its implications for his analysis.
Thanks to the clarity of his writing, Allen has succeeded in presenting an enormously complex phenomenon in terms accessible to the lay reader. Thanks to his meticulous research, he has also provided a richly detailed account that will be of immense value to other scholars interested in the subject. Combined as these two elements are with moments of truly insightful analysis, the book must be regarded as an unqualified success.
