This book is as much about the Kharijites as it is about today's jihadi groups. The Kharijites were a 7th-century ce movement committed to a literalist interpretation of the Qurʾan's insistence that true belief manifests itself in righteous actions. Actions judged by the Kharijites to be less than righteous, then, revealed to them weak or false belief. Because the Kharijites believed that righteous actions were essential to the survival of the Muslim community, they held that the perpetrators of unrighteous actions must be shunned, at the very least, or killed. So insistent were the Kharijites on this point that they placed anyone who disagreed with them in the same category as the unrighteous; they, too, had to be shunned or killed. Lahoud argues that today's “jihadis”—the radical Sunni militants who call themselves mujahidin (those who wage military jihad)—share these views with the Kharijites. Her thesis is that “because of the rigidity of their religious worldview,” the Kharijites “ultimately—and perhaps inevitably—disintegrated” (p. xvii), and so will today's jihadis.
The focal point of comparison is takfīr, the practice of declaring an avowed believer to be a kāfir, or nonbeliever. In the view of Kharijites and jihadis, being recognized as a believer is essential for, at the very least, being able to fraternize with other believers and, in some interpretations, immunity from death at the hands of zealous believers. As the author explains, due to the chaos caused by Kharijites’ efforts to purge the community of those they had declared nonbelievers, Islamic authorities prohibited takfīr and proclaimed that war can only be declared by the duly authorized ruler and that noncombatants are immune from harm. The Kharijites rejected these claims and continued to declare Muslims who disagreed with them to be nonbelievers and to launch attacks on them. The central government was forced to launch counterattacks and, with its far superior resources, effectively obliterated the Kharijites within the first two centuries of Islamic history. But even without these counterattacks, Lahoud claims, the Kharijites would have imploded because their inability to compromise led them to attack each other. Lahoud is careful to note that the Kharijites and jihadis are not identical, and, indeed, contemporary jihads reject the comparison to Kharijites (see, e.g., p. 43). Nevertheless, the jihadis’ use of takfīr and its belligerent corollary has led to infighting that will relegate them, Lahoud predicts repeatedly, to the dustbin of history, just as it did the Kharijites.
Lahoud's presentation of the factional disputes that divide jihadis is among the chief contributions of this book. Going beyond Montasser al-Zayat's excellent portrayal of disputes over whether jihadis should begin their struggle with the “near enemy” or the “far enemy” (in The Road to al-Qaeda [London: Pluto Press, 2004], to which Lahoud refers), Lahoud describes jihadi critiques of the Taliban's “idol worship” and conflicts between al-Qaʿida leaders and Iraqi jihadis over the latter's attacks on the Shiʿa. These disputes support Lahoud's thesis that “jihadism may well be on the path of self-destruction” (p. 24).
Another of Lahoud's contributions is her clear distinction between mainstream Islamists and jihadis. She notes that although early Islamist rhetoric idealizes the unification of Muslims under a caliphate, in reality Islamist movements are nationalist, focusing on reform within their own countries. Islamists are pragmatic, populist organizers who have embraced democracy and compromise. Jihadism remains internationalist, antidemocratic, and uncompromising. Islamists also teach that society must be reformed from within and that efforts at self-improvement through study are essential aspects of “greater jihad” and a prerequisite of military jihad. Jihadis teach that such efforts are needless delays. Further, while Islamists generally valorize communal solidarity under the guidance of a leader, jihadists stress individual initiative to the point of anarchy. “[J]ihadism,” therefore, “signals a complete rupture from Islamism” (p. 14).
The Arabic sources that Lahoud draws on to discuss the Kharijites and jihadis are meticulously documented. Regarding the Kharijites, her use of historians Ibn al-Athir, al-Tabari, and al-Shahrastani is effective. Regarding jihadis, she identifies a number of key ideologues and their writings. Of particular interest is her detailed treatment of the views of Muhammad ʿAbd al-Salam Faraj, ʿAbdallah ʿAzzam, ʿAbd al-Qadir b. ʿAbd al-ʿAziz (aka Dr. Fadl), and Isam Muhammad Tahir al-Barqawi (aka Abu Muhammad al-Maqdisi).
This book is not for beginners. Its thesis is simple and the author writes clearly, but she fails to provide background information on a number of topics. Terms (such as sharaf and naṣab), events (such as “the London bombing,” the battle of the Camel, and the second civil war in Basra), and people (such as al-Razi, the Qays, and Tamim) are mentioned without explanation. Dates are often overlooked, which could lead to confusion among novices to the field, especially in a work based on a comparison of movements of the 7th century and 20th and 21st centuries. And titles of important sources are inconsistently translated. The work is also marred by careless editing, including repetition (particularly noticeable when it is verbatim, as on pp. 92 and 247; see also pp. 26, 89, 195, and 247), instances of improper syntax and punctuation, and simple misspellings and typos (e.g., Fanon's first name is misspelled “Franz” on pp. 14 and 15, and SUNY Press is referred to as DUNY Press on pp. 139 and 198). She also misuses the terms “scholasticism” and “humanism” and inexplicably refers to “the Westphalian model that divided Muslims into nation-states” (pp. 117–18). On a more serious level, the author assumes a modern Western viewpoint in which religion is considered a private matter, which leads her to misinterpret the relationship between belief and practice as well as between the private and public spheres in Islam. Still, for advanced students, The Jihadis’ Path to Self-Destruction provides important insights into the dynamics of politicized Islam, both in its mainstream (“Islamist”) and radical (“jihadi”) forms.
