In the modern world it is no surprise that chemistry has become integral to food consumption. Anyone shopping from Sainsbury's or Fortnum & Mason, or from a Parisian patisserie or a Monoprix, may marvel at the emporium of the exotic, and at the possibilities presented by dyes, flavour-enhancing chemicals, and preservatives. The result, in no small measure, is an economy of the status-conscious, in our time increasingly of the natural, of organic farming and of the health-food co-op. More surprising, however, is that the consequences of food consumption were already central to the political frame of early modern Europe. Emma Spary has revealed a world in which chemistry and consumption merged in a debate that resonated throughout the political economy of the French Enlightenment.
In her astute and wide-ranging book she reflects upon the increasing commerce in exotic foods from the end of the seventeenth century. The most notable, and widely appreciated, phenomenon was the adoption of coffee cultivation and consumption in many European cities. As Spary argues, the coffee habit, as it had been Britain, was a sign in Paris of fashion and of the power of consumption. While British coffee partisans induced the broad levelling of the coffee house tied to a mercantile and intellectual public culture, in Paris the exclusivity of philosophical encounter over the exotic drink was much more pronounced. Thus the ‘epistemological domain’ (p. 66) in Paris tied shopkeepers to academicians in what the encyclopédistes came to regard as ‘manufactories of the mind’ (p. 115). Public consumption was not only a vehicle of status, but also a means of fashioning opinion beyond the established philosophical academies and sophisticated salons.
The palate of the corporeal and sensuous led inevitably to the consideration of intellectual powers that some felt enhanced by exotic foods. This was not simply about the relation between learning and commerce, as might be expected among the merchants of Paris, but much more about the effects of pleasures on the mind. Here was an ideological divide worked out in the debates over délicatesse and the voluptueux. Thus, as a precursor of the ambiance of the public café frequented by philosophers in the twentieth century, debates over how diet enhanced or hindered genius, or complaints about the debilitating or enhancement of liqueurs, were reflected in the political discourse on food, especially in the medical and chemical communities. Hence the pharmacie-chimistes such as Antoine Baumé and Pierre-Joseph Macquer had much to say about the processes of distillation from herbs and spices. The debate involved Denis Diderot, who could champion the benefits of new appetites, while Jean-Jacques Rousseau (closer perhaps to a modern sensibility) lamented the link between consumption, ostentation and political vice. As the chemist Charles-Georges Leroy once asserted, perhaps reflecting Rousseau, our physiology made clear that ‘political evil was the outcome of an unchecked drive to consume’ (p. 238). Spary has produced a sophisticated reflection on ‘corporeal and moral refinement’ (p. 209), on the alimentary and the intellectual.
Disputes over luxury and exoticism were also debates over the uses of nature and the power of improvement, which had important ideological consequences in the Ancien Régime. An important example is given by attacks on the rabid materialism of La Mettrie. Among the philosophes there were those like Diderot who asserted the moral imperatives of healthy eating, as with the chemist Réaumur, who demanded frugality in dining despite his considerable wealth, or like the protégé of the sensuous Voltaire, Jean-François Marmontel, who rejected it all for ‘sobriety and self-control’ (p. 259). Take the case of the patron of Rousseau, Louise-Florence-Pétronille Delalive d'Epinay, whose struggle with ill health was also ultimately about a strategy of controlling appetites. This tied her to a network of medical practitioners like the Swiss physician Théodore Trochin, all the while under an excessive and absolutist regime. Spary's consequent proposition of the state of Enlightened eating as an ideological project is thought-provoking. She has not only pointed to the breadth of epistemological spaces, like academies, laboratories and cafés, in which these controversies evolved. She also rightly, it seems to this reader, places the ideology of consumption in a realm of deliberate choice, where diet and daily practice were closely tied to a growing global pillage and a globalization with little regard to consequence. The seeds of social revolution were not just among the leaves of books.
