Biography is not a terribly fashionable endeavor among musicologists these days, yet for most of us such scholarship remains an absolutely essential resource. American music scholars have been the beneficiaries of sophisticated and comprehensively researched biographies of leading composers, produced by some of the finest scholars in our field. With Orpheus in Manhattan: William Schuman and the Shaping of America's Musical Life, Steve Swayne joins colleagues such as Vivian Perlis and Howard Pollack in this esteemed group. Following his successful first book on Sondheim, Swayne's new biography is a compelling and richly detailed examination of one the United States’ most important but understudied musical leaders.
William Schuman's bombastic musical Americanism occupies only a very small place in today's concert repertoires, even as the popularity of his friend Aaron Copland's nationalist works continues to grow. As Swayne convincingly demonstrates, this situation would likely not have been predicted in the middle of the twentieth century, when many considered Schuman one of the most important composers of his day. Swayne seeks to bring Schuman back to our attention with a study that provides a comprehensive assessment of both his compelling compositional oeuvre and his legacy to the musical community as an educator and administrator.
Schuman's résumé is an impressive one. After shaking up the music department as a professor at Sarah Lawrence College (1935–45), he was appointed president of the Juilliard School of Music. Here he revolutionized the curriculum, created the world-famous Juilliard String Quartet, and founded a dance division, while consistently placing a strong emphasis on contemporary American composition. His success at Juilliard attracted the attention of the directors of Lincoln Center, an institution then in the planning stages. They appointed him president, a position he held from 1962–68. Charged with shaping this game-changing institution on the New York scene, Schuman was granted far-reaching power to influence cultural life in the United States. He used this power to continue his advocacy of American music, to diversify the artistic activities of Lincoln Center, and to influence United Nations and U.S. government cultural programming at home and abroad. Swayne's Schuman is no ivory tower-inhabiting artist-recluse. Rather, Swayne shows that Schuman sought to make a significant and permanent impression on the world around him, both in sound and in deed, as a man profoundly committed to advancing the U.S. classical music scene.
Given his many professional commitments, the size of Schuman's compositional output is also striking. Swayne's descriptions of Schuman's musical works are not set apart, but rather are woven seamlessly into the biographical narrative. Although each work is carefully considered and analyzed, Swayne does not make the mistake of privileging Schuman's life as a composer over his significant career as an educator and administrator. This choice feels true to the man himself, who, as Swayne repeatedly notes, preferred a daily routine that combined solitary compositional activity with a more public professional life. By the end of the book the reader is quite convinced that Schuman's day job was at least as important to the history of American musical life as his compositions—and perhaps more so.
Swayne's lengthy study manages to strike the right balance between an intimate, almost affectionate portrait and careful scholarly analysis. These features are enhanced by Swayne's frequent use of quotations, both entertaining and illuminating, from a diverse array of archival sources. Schuman scholars are probably among the best served in our community when it comes to primary source material. Because of his administrative career, Schuman enjoyed high-quality secretarial assistance, resulting in a huge collection of documents now preserved at New York Public Library. But Swayne's archival work also extends to the papers of many of Schuman's composer contemporaries, administrative records from the institutions where he worked, government documents, and the archives of major foundations with which he was involved.
Orpheus in Manhattan also provides new insights into the community of composers and other musicians in which Schuman operated. What is revealed is a group of men (and they were all men) who worked together to create opportunities for commissions, publications, and performances, thereby realizing a much more ambitious objective: the establishment and promotion of a national tradition. Schuman's circle included fellow Americanist composers such as Roy Harris, Aaron Copland, and Leonard Bernstein, and conductors Serge Koussevitzky and Eugene Ormandy, both important advocates for his music. Swayne's careful assessment of this community makes an important contribution to our understanding of American musical nationalism, especially his examination of composers’ reactions when this aesthetic fell out of vogue during the fifties and sixties. In this way, Orpheus in Manhattan complements and extends multi-composer studies of nationalism in earlier decades by scholars such as Carol Oja, Melissa de Graaf, and Beth Levy.Footnote 1
Swayne also gives detailed consideration to another outcome of Schuman's commitment to promoting American classical music: his work with a wide array of national and international institutions. As Swayne documents in fascinating detail, Schuman assisted various branches of the U.S. government and UNESCO in adapting American music to serve social and political ends. Schuman also produced a significant number of works intended for use as nationalist propaganda. By contextualizing these works historically, Swayne helps us understand why they are less popular with today's audiences, for whom their nationalism might seem brash and overblown.
Indeed, what becomes quickly apparent from Swayne's narrative is that Schuman's musical nationalism was not rooted in a leftist political attitude—unlike that of Copland and Bernstein, for example. Swayne shows that Schuman realized early in his career that making public proclamations on non-musical matters could thwart his ambitions. What glimpses we do get of his political views—through his work with government, his approach to musical nationalism, and even his musical style—suggest that although socially progressive in some regards, for example in the realm of civil rights, Schuman mostly hewed close to the political center.
Yet although Swayne repeatedly demonstrates these centrist attitudes through his narrative, he nevertheless attempts on several occasions to suggest a quiet political progressivism on Schuman's part. His evidence for such claims, to this reader at least, appears rather tenuous. In examining Schuman's music of the 1930s, for example, Swayne understands Schuman's collaboration with the Socialist poet Genevieve Taggard, with whom he created choral works for amateurs, as one indication of an interest in progressive politics during this period. He also suggests that Schuman's decision to leave works like the Second Symphony out of his promotional materials in later years indicates a growing nervousness about the leftist sentiments that underpinned them. Certainly Swayne is right to understand Schuman's commitment to writing choral music for young people in the 1930s as “progressive,” but the word is appropriate here primarily in the educational sense. Schuman was committed to new models of education. He was also dedicated to patriotic nation-building during World War II. There is no evidence at all that in combining these two interests to create accessible music “for the masses” he hoped to help bring about social and political change, as some of his colleagues did.
Similarly, looking at a later period, Swayne speculates that the 1968 orchestral work To Thee Old Cause may have been an anti-Vietnam statement. He cites circumstantial evidence for his claim but provides no conclusive proof of Schuman's attitudes toward the conflict. A few pages later he quotes Schuman's 1974 description of himself as “an unabashed patriot,” uncomfortable when others spoke out against the United States government and committed to producing a Bicentennial work that would encourage the listener “to experience a renewal of his belief in the American Dream” (449). Although it is certainly tempting to interpret Schuman's close friendships with politically progressive composer-colleagues as an indication that he quietly shared their views, Swayne presented little evidence to justify such a reading—and much that contradicts it.
I found great balance and subtlety, however, in Swayne's assessment of Schuman's strengths and weaknesses as an administrator. Despite his evident affection for his subject, Swayne is not afraid to examine career-changing moments when Schuman's confidence and ambition led him into problematic territory. Swayne portrays a decisive leader who was willing to make unpopular decisions for what he believed was the greater good. His boldness had outcomes that many have considered positive—a radical new syllabus for Juilliard, for example, and the hugely influential, multi-institutional cultural powerhouse that is Lincoln Center. Yet sometimes, in his desire to innovate on the cultural scene, Schuman lost sight of both the importance of maintaining personal relationships and the awkward realities of a limited budget. This high-achieving all-rounder was only human, after all.
Orpheus in Manhattan is a remarkable achievement: a much-needed, well-researched, and beautifully crafted examination of an influential educator, administrator, and composer. At the same time, it encourages its reader to reflect on the complexities and challenges of creating and promoting an “American music” and being an “American composer” beyond the heyday of musical Americanism in the 1930s. It will certainly prove an indispensable resource to all those interested in the American music scene in the middle decades of the twentieth century.
