In October 2011 the Cultural Heritage Law Committee of the International Law Association, under the chairmanship of Professor James Nafziger, met in Kohunlich, Quintana Roo, Mexico. The purpose of the meeting was to fuse culture with working sessions over a period of four days. The meeting took place amid fascinating Mayan ruins and the Kalakmul biosphere reserve near the Belizean border. It proved to be a great and successful venture.
The chair opened a discussion of 14 national reports and one global report on export and import controls over trade in cultural material. These reports were prepared by committee members. Together with several others in preparation, they will form the core of a book on trade in cultural material, to be published in 2013. The committee reviewed reports on control systems in Australia, Canada, China, Germany, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Japan, New Zealand, South Africa, Sweden, Switzerland, United Kingdom, and the United States. Several other national reports are expected. In addition, the committee reviewed a global report appealingly titled, “What Do Export Controls Accomplish?” and expects to receive others related to human rights, the European Union, and export controls over third state-of-origin material. The entire collection of reports will form a substantial addition to the literature, because they focus on administrative processes, issues, and problems of implementation.
Also at the Mexico meeting, Avocat Marc-André Renold, of the University of Geneva, and I presented the UNESCO-UNIDROIT Draft Model Provisions on State Ownership of Undiscovered Cultural Objects, which we had helped prepare as members of the drafting committee. Lively discussion followed.
The committee will next meet in Sofia, Bulgaria, during the August 2012 biennial conference of the International Law Association. It is expected that the committee will complete its work on export and import controls by the fall of 2012.
