Jacqueline Shea Murphy's new book, Dancing Indigenous Worlds: Choreographies of Relation, is remarkably ambitious in scope: traversing diverse Indigenous communities in North America, Australia, and Aotearoa New Zealand. It is also experimental in its approach to the question of relationality, as throughout the book she tries on different ways of representing her experiences and incorporating the voices of the artists she has encountered on her travels. After she begins by positioning herself as a “settler dance scholar” (xi), the book unfolds as a succession of stories of her travels: watching dance, talking with performers and spectators, taking part in workshops and creating conversations, and thinking about performance and performativity as she bikes to and from campus. In so doing, she works repeatedly both to show us what she means by “choreographies of relation” and to model this relationality.
Her journey begins in Aotearoa, New Zealand, with the Te Matatini—the national kapa haka festival. Much of her attention is directed away from the stage and toward the community, touched by her experience of manākitanga (hospitality). Similarly, while she is alert to the collective artistry in Atamira Dance Company's performance of Mitimiti at Auckland's Q Theatre (2015), what absorbs her is the sense of communion with the people around her. A large part of Chapter 1 is given over to other voices—notably the reflections of Mitimiti's choreographer, Jack Gray. Here, as throughout the book, we can see Shea Murphy, the settler dance scholar in theory and in practice, stepping to one side, giving stage to Māori and Indigenous artists and academics.
The second chapter takes us to a workshop on the UC Riverside campus, hosted by Shea Murphy and led by Rulan Tangen, founder and director of Dancing Earth Creations. Shea Murphy describes the workshop, its place and participants, in detail as, over the course of the chapter, her self-identification shifts from “dance-scholar-in-sweat-tights” (127) to “dance-scholar-in-musing-mode” (135). She foregrounds the voice of the choreographer, Rulan Tangen, who frames the story of the company's founding as a personal search for a more authentic way of dancing: “I had chased the dance from country to country, from ballet stages to modern dance studios to powwow grounds” (130). Shea Murphy's account of the workshop and Tangen's narrative are interwoven with the voices of other Dancing Earth artists and descriptions of works to demonstrate the relationality of the company's practices in rehearsal and in performance. The chapter then takes a (perhaps unavoidable) turn toward a more troubling account of the recent controversy surrounding Rulan Tangen's claims to Native American identity. Tangen's being of Filipino heritage makes the debate regarding the construction of Indigenous identity in the face of colonialism, imperialism, and globalization more complex than it at first appears.
Shea Murphy is at her best when she walks us through her journey to see Tanya Lukin Linklater, an artist-choreographer of Alutiiq descent, perform as part of Mapping Resistances, a series of events staged in Ontario, Canada (2010). The description of her experience is full of details, and the analysis of Lukin Linklater's performance is rich in reflection. To show us what she means by “choreographies of relation,” she weaves her embodied experience—from walking and watching to fending off insects—into an act of witnessing, which is then threaded through a conversation with the artist, who speaks her own truth. It's an exquisite piece of scholarship for the way it invites us, as readers, to become witnesses well after the fact, and as such to craft a place for ourselves in the conversation.
This is the way the book works: from Shea Murphy's thick descriptions of how she saw a performance to the (relatively) unfiltered voices of the performers and watchers, and back again. Her discursive strategy creates irregularities, gaps, and overlaps aimed toward maintaining our awareness of ourselves as readers, challenging us to be conscious of, to construct, and to commit to our own acts of witnessing. She even goes so far, in a textbooklike section, as to invite the reader to turn student, or to turn with our students, to see and think for ourselves: to read additional essays by Indigenous dance artists, to look at images and videos of selected dances that are available on the book's website, and then to respond to a series of Reflection Questions. This approach gives us a sense that we're gaining access to the work in a way that is immediate and transparent—so much so that, near the end of the book, she turns to the tension between her ambitions as a “settler dance scholar” and the realities of what, citing an array of Indigenous scholars, she acknowledges as “Indigenous refusals” (268). She (and we) must learn “to listen to refusal as expansive and generative, respectfully, without freaking out, with an openness to how its teachings might actually change things, including us” (270).
Ultimately, it's fascinating to see what Shea Murphy sees, and it's also disappointing to see what she overlooks—in particular, when it comes to Māori scholarship on kapa haka. In Dancing Indigenous Worlds, Jacqueline Shea Murphy invites us, who are mostly not Indigenous, to join her in bearing witness to the many diverse ways dance (and dance scholarship) can come to embody the kind of radical relationality that might push us through the legacies of colonization and globalization toward a more just world.
