Following in the wake of a frenzy for substance-focused food histories, scholars are shifting serious attention to food as an idea. What goes on in the mind or in the press are understood to be at least as important as what goes onto the plate.
Until recently, the only “isms” associated with cooking and eating were vegetarianism and veganism. More recently, food activists advocate locavorism and Michael Pollan despises “nutritionism.” Ideologies of food and eating are fore-grounded in the contemporary discourse of consumption.
The two books reviewed here are about food ideologies, rather than meals. One is a history of the vegetarian movement from 1817 to 1921, and the other traces the larger concern with food as a moral issue beyond the ethics of eating meat as it emerged in the era just before and after the First World War. Both perform important work in contextualizing food in the social imaginary, serving as a kind of popular intellectual history of what we eat. Both also help us to understand the histories of the contemporary foodisms we embrace or struggle with today.
Anglo Americans who eschewed meat have been recognized as having a philosophy about food since the early nineteenth century, while the rest of the West's eaters were individuals with personal proclivities. Some were defined as epicures, but this was a matter of behaviors, rather than ideologies. David Shprintzen provides a history of organized vegetarians, those who worked together for an explicit common goal.
Shprintzen argues that although vegetarians are often portrayed as outsiders to American culture, many were directly involved in a collective movement that has a long history and were also active in the construction of the public persona of the vegetarian. Shprintzen draws on sources that vegetarian organizations produced as well as writings about vegetarians. The journals and books written by vegetarians constructed the internal and public discourses of vegetarianism. Shprintzen's sources reflect a collective sense of purpose in eating no meat that is distinct from, though related to, the philosophical approach to vegetarianism. He focuses both on how vegetarians defined themselves and on how they were perceived by others: as social actors rather than simply as those who negated a norm.
The idea of a vegetarian movement was imported to the United States from England. American vegetarian movement activists, then, were originally offshoots of an international movement adapted to a new nation. Shprintzen argues that the American movement “diverged significantly from its British counterpart in its demographics, goals, and methods” (3). While British vegetarianism was rooted in philosophy, particularly the writings of Swedenborg, American vegetarianism took shape from a lingering belief in the humoral system of physiology. By 1850, a number of small movements, including Bible Christians who believed that the Christian Bible prohibited meat eating, Grahamites who followed the famous diet reformer Sylvester Graham, and Water Curists who believed in frequent bathing and water drinking to cleanse spiritual and physical impurities, joined together to form the American Vegetarian Society.
Shprintzen traces the history of the American Vegetarian Society through its dissolution in the midst of the Civil War and the rise of the new Vegetarian Society of America in 1886, which lasted into the twentieth century. Along the way, we encounter famous food reformers Sylvester Graham and the Kelloggs, dynamic figures in this national movement.
In the antebellum era, vegetarians advocated their practice as an essential element in a more morally healthful American nation, a “catalyst for total social reform, including the emancipation of slaves, the extension of suffrage to women, and the end of oppressive economics” (4). Later in the nineteenth century, the focus shifted from society to the individual, as vegetarian activists fought stereotypes that portrayed them as weak and unmanly.
Shprintzen helpfully locates the rise of “movement vegetarianism” at the same historical moment that red meat became a regular part of the American diet (107). It is useful to see vegetarians as participants in the larger culture, not just as on the fringe or refuseniks. Despite the absence of a science of nutrition to explain calories or protein, Americans in the nineteenth century believed inherently in the power of beef to sustain human effort. If vegetarians were going to skip this most vital of foods, then they must therefore be weaklings. It was up to the vegetarians to prove otherwise.
Employing the same language and values as their critics, vegetarians argued that their way of life promoted virility and health. This they did through public feats of strength and testimonials of miraculous physical transformations. Vegetarians of the late nineteenth century, Shprintzen argues, entirely bought into the cult of rugged masculinity that also produced the physical culture and gymnasium movements. To this we can add the eugenics and better baby movements discussed in Veit's book. Rather than questioning this culture's fundamental assumptions about health and fitness, vegetarian advocates such as the fascinating Bernarr MacFadden (also creator of True Story, Photoplay, and True Detective magazines) insisted that they were even stronger and more physically fit than meat eaters.
Vegetarians of the nineteenth century also allowed carnivores to define the terms of health and cuisine when they sought out meat substitutes. The commitment to offering fake meats, to which Shprintzen dedicates a very informative chapter, allowed vegetarians to stay mostly within mainstream American foodways, even as they challenged some of the basic rules of national cuisine.
This discourse of health—that it could be measured in physical strength and endurance, was a modern conceit. While Shprintzen focuses on the vegetarians in this moment, Veit provides the broader context for the turn toward health as a quantifiable property. Veit argues convincingly for the First World War as a watershed moment in American food discourse. During this era, the rhetoric of conservation was paired with notions of patriotism and sacrifice to fundamentally alter the way Americans thought about food. Eating would henceforth be a moral act. While wartime conservation efforts framed this morality as collective, in the years since the war, Americans took a more personal approach to the morality of food, testing their own willpower against every passing calorie.
The First World War introduced what Veit usefully terms “rational food”: the idea that eating choices must be justified according to standards other than preference, “whether in the interest of health, economy, or patriotism, or—more nebulously but no less powerfully—in the interest of self-control as a moral virtue in its own right” (38). In essence, this is the moment when Americans began to use the phrase “oh, I shouldn't …” when offered all manner of food treats.
The first decade of the twentieth century was the time, Veit argues, of a crucial shift from thinking that human activity was powered be a “vital force” in the body to understanding that it was instead fueled by food intake. The popularization of the calorie as a concept related to food helped in this rapid transformation, as did the scientific establishment that fruits and vegetables were sources of vital elements—vitamins—and so essential to the healthy diet. The concept of health itself was thus modernized as it became quantifiable.
Rather than dismissing nineteenth-century food “fads,” such as vegetarianism as delusions, Veit argues that they helped to establish a grounding for the later acceptance of nutritional science. Further, she shows sensitivity in urging readers to understand Americans of the past on their own terms: “People may have cottoned onto a fad that seems silly or nutritionally inadequate today. But if people felt better following a certain regime, who can blame them for placing some faith in its particularities[?]” Veit admirably avoids the presentist palate that sometimes troubles food history.
Veit's sources are newspaper articles, government bulletins, reports of nongovernmental agencies, and cookbooks that comment on American food habits during the era of the First World War. She uses these sources skillfully to portray multiple perspectives on many issues. We see not only the official advice but also the popular reaction and often rejection of new rationales for eating one way or another.
Veit argues that the popularization of rational eating supported Americans of the 1910s and ‘20 s in two significant alterations to the national diet—the embrace of “foreign” foods and the rejection of food altogether, that is, the diet for weight loss. Because nutritionists introduced the concept of equivalencies in food, Americans were able to think about foreign foods such as spaghetti as more edible than previous generations might have. Simultaneously, thinking about eating as an act with moral imperative—conserve at home to feed troops abroad—enabled postwar dieters to use the trope of willpower in their own personal struggle to limit intake for aesthetic reasons. Shprintzen might add here that vegetarians had helped to popularize a foodway of selective abstinence before the advent of reducing diets.
Veit's discussion of the emergence of slimming as a mindset toward food includes fascinating propaganda from the First World War that castigated “fat” people, especially women, as “hoarders” of materials needed for the war effort (164). This discussion seems to have interesting parallels in contemporary discourse when obesity is cited as a major drain on national health spending. In both cases, individual choices are perceived as antisocial.
Both Shprintzen and Veit reveal a shift from collective action around food to an individual-focused rhetoric. Where vegetarians had once situated their food choices as part of a larger moral program—reforming American society—they came to present vegetarianism as a personal choice for individual improvement. Likewise, the patriotism of First World War food programs morphed into the moral responsibility of mothers for their family meals and individuals for their own fitness, their best selves. Each author, then, contributes to a larger history of American culture's transformation from collectivist to individualist. These books reveal how transforming popular imaginations of roughly a century in American life shaped our contemporary food discourses.
