In her new book on grand corruption, Naomi Roht-Arriaza, an emerita distinguished professor of law at UC San Francisco, offers a wide-ranging review of the current state of the fight against grand corruption. As the title itself signals, the book covers human rights-based approaches to corruption, as well as “transnational” approaches, a broad term that aptly encompasses the book’s comparative analysis of domestic laws and procedures, as well as international and regional anti-corruption law. The book’s broad scope is linked to what seems to be its central premise, that anti-corruption activists and scholars ought to be pursuing all possible legal approaches to combating corruption and repairing the socioeconomic damage that it causes. Geographically speaking, the book centers on Latin America, a region that the author knows best, where corruption is “at the top of national agendas” and where the corruption and human rights agendas have long been “intertwined” (p. 10). Yet, the book’s geographical scope extends beyond Latin America, to countries in Africa and Asia, including South Africa, Tunisia, and Uzbekistan. In addition, countries in the Global North also feature in the book’s analysis of topics such as sanctions and asset recovery.
Thematically, this book focuses on grand as opposed to petty corruption. Roht-Arriaza references and appears to adopt Transparency International’s definition of grand corruption as “a systematic or well-organized plan of action involving high-ranking public officials that causes serious harm, such as serious human rights violations” (p. 7).Footnote 1 By contrast, Transparency International defines “petty corruption” (or what Roht-Arriaza terms “administrative” corruption) as “everyday abuse of entrusted power by public officials in their interactions with ordinary citizens, who often are trying to access basic goods and services in places like hospitals, schools, police departments and other agencies” (p. 6).Footnote 2 The introduction also explains that the book focuses, at least in part, on an extreme form of grand corruption, namely “state capture.” Roht-Arriaza defines this phenomenon as “using political mechanisms to favor the economic interests of a small group of people while creating impunity for their actions” (p. 8). In her view, “state capture” through large-scale corruption can occur in countries with dysfunctional but democratic regimes, whereas “kleptocracy” refers to the “total capture” of a dictatorial regime where the leaders themselves are involved in plundering the state (id.).
The first section of this review reflects on the book’s coverage of a significant range of legal approaches to grand corruption, and whether this book reveals any particular insights into the transnational fight against grand corruption. The second section considers whether the book’s references to and analysis of state capture should prompt readers to reflect on whether this term should also be used to describe current developments in the United States. Finally, the third section offers some concluding observations and remarks upon the book’s potential appeal to a general readership.
A Grand Tour of Legal Approaches to Fighting Grand Corruption
Transnational corruption may be studied from various legal and non-legal perspectives and can be addressed through many different bodies of law. In Fighting Grand Corruption, Roht-Arriaza very much embraces the diversity of legal approaches to corruption, much to the book’s credit. The book canvasses a range of legal approaches to this phenomenon, including not only international and regional human rights law, but also domestic and international criminal law, domestic private law, and unilateral “smart” sanctions. Moreover, in exploring domestic legal approaches to grand corruption, the book delves into the legislation and court procedures of states around the world, especially in Latin America. This book is therefore clearly the product of extensive, wide-ranging research, which is all the more impressive because of the inherent challenges involved in researching domestic legislation and court proceedings outside of one’s home jurisdiction. This is not to say that the book exhaustively covers all legal approaches to corruption, nor would such an approach have been especially coherent. The legal issues and approaches selected for examination for the most part relate in some way to the victims of corruption—the harm they experience, their role in judicial procedures, the reparations owed to them, etc.
The book begins with what Roht-Arriaza categorizes as “transnational approaches” to fighting corruption, in particular, Guatemala’s Commission against Impunity (CICIG) (Ch. 3) and targeted sanctions, in particular Magnitsky sanctions (Ch. 4). CICIG was a UN-backed initiative created in 2006 for the purpose of dismantling networks, including corrupt networks, that were threatening human rights and accountability in the aftermath of the 1996 peace accords in Guatemala. CICIG may be categorized as a “transnational approach” because it involved international assistance for domestic investigations and prosecutions in Guatemala. In Roht-Arriaza’s telling, “[t]he results of CICIG’s work, while it lasted, were spectacular. CICIG investigated 124 cases, leading to more than 400 criminal convictions over 11 years” (p. 53). CICIG not only helped to dismantle criminal networks, including corrupt networks, but it also helped to change and modernize investigative techniques in Guatemala.
Yet, CICIG ultimately produced a backlash that contributed to its demise. CICIG’s basic prosecutorial strategy, which involved targeting elite, powerful public and private actors, arguably made a backlash inevitable—it was simply a matter of time. In addition, Roht-Arriaza touches on a number of other factors—both internal and external to CICIG—that may have contributed to its downfall (pp. 54–56). Internal factors included questionable or “politically tone-deaf” decisions regarding the selection or prioritization of cases; inadequate efforts to support policy and legislative reform that was needed to facilitate its investigations and prosecutions; and a failure to bring about change by mobilizing its considerable support among the population of Guatemala. External factors included “slow and byzantine” courts and procedural rules; the absence of reforms to campaign financing, electoral law, and judicial selection; and a fragile relationship with the United Nations, which left CICIG without steady financing and its personnel without UN diplomatic immunity. Eventually, corrupt private actors, which had been targeted by CICIG, funded a lobbying campaign in Washington that undermined political and financial support from the United States, which was essential for CICIG’s continued operation. The then-president of Guatemala was also receptive to this lobbying campaign, and in 2019, Guatemala unilaterally terminated its agreement with the United Nations, at which point CICIG ceased to exist.
For a time, CICIG was held out as a potential model for other countries in Latin America, but Roht-Arriaza’s account of its downfall should be taken as a cautionary tale. Roht-Arriaza does not draw firm conclusions from this story, but her depiction of CICIG’s demise suggests that in the future, the designers of other CICIG-like bodies could take certain steps to prevent history from repeating itself. A certain degree of backlash is perhaps inevitable when prosecutors pursue elite, powerful public and private sector actors, but more could be done to protect and facilitate the work of bodies like this. The story of CICIG shows that a powerful investigative and prosecutorial mandate is insufficient if unaccompanied by much needed policy and legislative reforms in domains like electoral law, campaign financing, and judicial selection. In addition, any institution that relies heavily on the United States for funding is inherently vulnerable, as the United States can no longer be regarded as a reliable supporter of anti-corruption efforts.
In the following chapters, Roht-Arriaza explores other “transnational approaches” to fighting corruption, including unilateral sanctions against individuals allegedly involved in corruption and human rights abuses (Ch. 4). The “Magnitsky” sanctions imposed by the United States are the earliest and most prominent example of such sanctions, but many other countries have followed suit with their own sanction regimes that permit governments to block or freeze assets of listed individuals and to deny them entry or leave to remain in the jurisdiction imposing sanctions (pp. 61–67). Roht-Arriaza’s assessment of such sanction regimes is ultimately somewhat ambivalent and underdeveloped. Without explicitly assessing the effectiveness of Magnitsky sanctions, she notes that “visa sanctions” have “diminishing returns” as targeted individuals can simply shift their personal and business activities to other jurisdictions (p. 63). While “financial sanctions do have bite,” they come with an administrative burden and costs for domestic financial institutions, which generate reluctance on the part of sanctioning states (id.). She ultimately concedes that it is difficult to draw conclusions, as “the detailed bases for imposing sanctions (or removing them) are not published” (p. 67). In the end, these sanctions are “imposed or removed by states according to their interests, not just according to the severity of the underlying behavior” (id.).
This discussion would have benefited from a deeper examination of what could be called the “dark side” of Magnitsky sanctions, which have the potential to violate human rights, even though states have explicitly designed them, in part, for the purpose of promoting human rights. Roht-Arriaza notes that it can be unclear exactly what behavior motivates a listing and what procedure, if any, is available to seek a delisting (p. 63). This important observation raises questions about the lack of transparency surrounding listing decisions and the evidence that supports them. In addition, while Roht-Arriaza seems to approve of the imposition of sanctions by the United States based on evidence provided by non-governmental organizations (NGOs), this too raises normative questions that go unexplored. Should investigations of corruption and human rights abuses be outsourced to private actors in this manner; what risks does this practice bring with it? Finally, the omission of sufficiently clear (or any) procedures for delisting in various Magnitsky sanctions regimes suggests that legislatures have not headed the lessons that were (or should have been) learned from counter-terrorism sanctions. Magnitsky sanctions regimes would seem to be ripe for a detailed analysis of whether their delisting procedures sufficiently safeguard the right to an effective remedy.
Chapters 5–7 of this book make the most distinctive contribution due to their focus on the victims of grand corruption, in particular their access to corruption proceedings (Ch. 5), the recovery and repurposing of assets for the benefit of victims (Ch. 6), and reparations for damage caused to victims (Ch. 7). Chapter 5, on victims’ access to corruption proceedings, begins by exploring the challenges involved in coherently defining “victim” in this context, especially as the United Nations Convention Against Corruption (UNCAC) essentially leaves this to domestic jurisdictions (p. 80).Footnote 3 The UNCAC Working Group on Asset Recovery has, however, enumerated various possible types of victims, including “employers, shareholders, unsuccessful bidders, foreign states and society as a whole” (p. 81).Footnote 4 Roht-Arriaza also looks for definitions in other bodies of law, including international and regional human rights law and a small selection of domestic jurisdictions, including France and the United Kingdom. She further traces two emerging trends pertaining to the participation of victims in corruption-related proceedings (both civil and criminal) in Latin American states. She demonstrates that where victims have gained access they have either done so by directly linking their harm to the case at hand, or indirectly through a public interest group that represents “diffuse” or “collective” interests (p. 88). She appears to conclude that “courts are slowly opening the door to claims by victims, based on human rights considerations, but are obviously concerned about opening the door too wide and are searching for limiting factors” (p. 101). As she acknowledges, domestic climate change litigation should serve as inspiration for such cases, especially with respect to questions of standing and causation (p. 94).
Chapter 6 explores the key role that anti-corruption law can play in ensuring that proceeds of corruption are not only recovered but repurposed for the benefit of victims of corruption. The chapter’s most original contribution consists of a systematization of the interstate agreements that have been concluded to date for the purpose of returning assets and ensuring that the assets are not “re-corrupted” following their return (pp. 117–26). She describes four models of asset return: (1) a “purpose-built entity” in the receiving country that receives, administers, and monitors returned funds; (2) a government agency in the receiving country that receives funds and benefits from “outside” monitoring by international organizations and/or civil society; (3) an established international organization, such as the United Nations, which receives and distributes funds; and (4) a multilateral fund that receives and distributes funds.
This chapter provides rich, detailed descriptions of the first three models, with interesting factual details and nuanced discussions of the benefits and drawbacks of each of these options. The fourth model, involving a multilateral fund, is aspirational at this point in time, as it represents a possible model for asset return, but not one that has been employed to return the proceeds of corruption. Roht-Arriaza’s analysis of the first three models can be taken as suggesting that states and other actors have not yet found an ideal way to return assets, while at the same time ensuring that the returned funds actually benefit the victims of corruption, or society more generally. States, international organizations, and civil society organizations are still experimenting with various key features of asset return, including the recipients of transferred funds, the disposal of returned funds, and the monitoring of disposal.
International anti-corruption law leaves much to the discretion of states, as the United Nations Convention Against Corruption, the only anti-corruption treaty that extensively covers asset return, imposes no firm obligations on states parties with respect to these issues. The decisions that states take with respect to asset return are therefore guided mostly by policies and best practices, and also potentially by human rights law. While Roht-Arriaza’s distillation of existing practice into these three (or potentially four) models is persuasive, it can also be seen as premature. The collection of publicly available agreements on asset return is limited, and practice is very much still evolving. Without doubt, other permutations—other creative solutions to the dilemmas of asset return—are yet to come. Finally, on a geographical note, this section focuses on Uzbekistan and Nigeria, and to a lesser extent Venezuela. While the book’s geographical focus is admittedly not limited to Latin America, this particular combination of examples nevertheless raises methodological questions about what led Roht-Arriaza to focus on predominantly non-Latin American examples in this chapter, especially as assets have recently been returned to Peru.Footnote 5
The book’s examination of victims concludes with a chapter on reparations for victims of grand corruption, namely restitution, compensation, and satisfaction (Ch. 7). The chapter most notably wrestles with difficult questions concerning causation and the quantification of damages. Roht-Arriaza concisely puts forward various possible arguments regarding personal or property damage, loss of opportunity, and situations involving more “indirect” or “diffuse” harm (pp. 141–50). This chapter again shows that environmental litigation may serve as inspiration in this context, as anti-corruption activists appear to be at an earlier stage in terms of testing and refining various arguments before domestic judges (p. 146). While this chapter succeeds in putting forward various, creative arguments and approaches, many of them remain untested in actual litigation (see, e.g., pp. 150–52).
The book’s final chapters examine the links between corruption and atrocities, with a focus on the relationship between anti-corruption law and transitional justice (Ch. 8) and international criminal law (Ch. 9). The chapter on transitional justice argues that we ought to “flip[] the telescope to look at how areas of human rights law could benefit from an anti-corruption lens” (p. 161). By reference to the examples of South Africa, Tunisia, and Colombia, Roht-Arriaza contends that anti-corruption considerations ought to play a (much) more significant role in countries transitioning out of periods of mass atrocities and human rights violations. As Roht-Arriaza rightly points out, the field of transitional justice has historically focused on “a small subset of human rights violations,” with insufficient consideration of how deterring corruption could also help to prevent the recurrence of such violations (pp. 161–62).
Chapter 9 pursues the link between corruption and atrocities even further by examining at length whether corruption could be considered a crime against humanity, in particular the crime of “other inhumane acts.” Roht-Arriaza repeatedly emphasizes that “looking at atrocity crimes through a corruption lens … can improve the fight against both” (p. 183). She demonstrates that grand corruption could potentially be squeezed into the offense of “other inhumane acts” as found in the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (ICC). Somewhat unsatisfactorily, this chapter does not dwell on the question of whether this is likely to be a winning approach in practice—not only whether judges would be persuaded, but also whether prosecutors could be persuaded to even take such a legal risk, especially given the limited resources and politically exposed position of the ICC at present.
The book’s conclusion clarifies that Roht-Arriaza has pursued an approach of “everything, everywhere, all at once” (p. 215). In other words, she justifiably considers that fighting grand corruption requires “the use and combination of different types of laws and forums together with media, political mobilization, and economic strategies” (id.). An “everything, everywhere, all at once” strategy involves “the ability to go to UN and regional bodies, to use environmental, constitutional, and private law, and to bring evidence to anti-money laundering and anti-corruption prosecutors in multiple countries, in a sequence and combination that will vary” (id.). Roht-Arriaza is undoubtedly correct—fighting grand corruption requires multifaceted and creative approaches that span legal fields.
What this conclusion misses, however, is the possible value of prioritizing and of learning lessons from defeats and mishaps. This book, perhaps deliberately, does not offer an assessment of which approaches are preferable or more promising, and in which circumstances. Roht-Arriaza’s rich descriptions of domestic court procedures are replete with examples of civil and criminal litigation that seemed promising, only to run up against sometimes insurmountable obstacles, whether legal or political in character. Ultimately, the book may leave readers with a sense that we are very much still grasping, as a field, for some orientation and a clear strategy. Perhaps we ought to consider abandoning certain arguments, like corruption as a crime against humanity, and focus instead on issues like standing and causation, so that a robust body of domestic jurisprudence will eventually emerge. Perhaps a more discriminating legal strategy, involving more prioritization and lessons learned, would be more productive than pursuing everything, all at once.
State Capture and the Trump Administration
This book predominantly focuses on corruption in the Global South, and in particular Latin America, as the title suggests. Roht-Arriaza’s detailed discussions of laws and litigation in Global South countries make a significant, novel contribution to anti-corruption scholarship, which has often focused on litigation in developed countries, in particular the United States. Her accounts of corruption scandals, and the legal procedures that they have generated, should be of great interest to scholars and practitioners based in the Global North, in jurisdictions with lower (perceived) levels of corruption. The book’s account of state capture in South Africa, for example, should resonate with scholars and practitioners in the United States.
While the book’s introduction appears to foreground a focus on grand corruption involving state capture, an explicit analysis of state capture appears only toward the end of the book, when Roht-Arriaza turns to the example of South Africa. She focuses in particular on state capture in the context of post-apartheid South Africa, during the presidency of Jacob Zuma (2009–2018). She describes state capture by the Gupta family (brothers Ajay, Atul, and Rajesh) in the following terms: “Not only did the Guptas get rigged contracts for state-owned mines, trains, energy generation, media and computer companies, they got ministers and officials hired and fired, laws changed, and investigations into their doings quashed. It was a classic example of state capture” (p. 165). The Commission on State Capture (also known as the Zondo Commission) eventually engaged in extensive fact-finding and issued multiple, lengthy reports in 2022.
According to Roht-Arriaza, the commission’s work revealed the “two-pronged nature of state capture” in South Africa, meaning that instances of grand corruption were coupled with another distinct phenomenon: “the institutions charged with ensuring probity and accountability were attacked and weakened” (id.). The state weakened the National Prosecution Authority, the investigative police, and the tax agency, and outsourced the state’s auditing function to the private sector (pp. 165, 167). This set the stage for impunity: “[t]hose who investigated grand corruption cases found themselves the subject of leaked allegations of wrongdoing, spurious investigations, and pressure to resign, while the results of their investigations languished or were derailed.” Roht-Arriaza describes how the history of apartheid South Africa and the particularities of its transition to democracy help to explain the extreme level of impunity that prevailed for acts of grand corruption during and after the Zuma regime (pp. 165–66).
Roht-Arriaza’s analysis of state capture and impunity holds lessons for observers of and participants in American politics at this moment in time. As Roht-Arriaza acknowledges in a brief epilogue to her book, written after President Trump took office in 2025, “the new Trump administration in the United States has made the fight against grand corruption—at home and abroad—much more difficult” (p. 219). She adds: “following the playbook for state capture almost perfectly, it has, in short order, fired 18 Inspectors General (in charge of dealing with fraud in the US federal government), imposed loyalty tests on remaining Department of Justice lawyers and FBI agents, intimidated the press, and tried to dismantle the professional civil service, USAID … and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau” (id.). In addition, the Trump administration first suspended and then reprioritized the enforcement of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and pressured Department of Justice lawyers to drop major grand corruption cases, including the bribery case brought against Eric Adams, the former mayor of New York City.Footnote 6 We are witnessing a profound dismantling of the institutions and mechanisms designed to prevent corruption in the United States and to investigate and punish such conduct once it has allegedly occurred. When the United States eventually transitions out of the Trump administration and begins what will inevitably be a long path toward reconstructing government institutions and mechanisms of accountability, a fact-finding commission ought to detail this destruction, and whatever corruption it will have facilitated. The example of South Africa is more relevant for the United States than many might realize.
The question remains: what sorts of acts of grand corruption would such a fact-finding commission likely detail? This question might strike some as rhetorical, as media outlets have been reporting on “corruption” in the Trump administration for more than a year as of this writing.Footnote 7 Yet, these reports tend to use the word “corruption” in a colloquial sense to refer broadly to grossly unethical, fraudulent, or legally questionable behavior on the part of President Trump and the close associates and family members who surround him. Rules governing conflicts of interest and fraud are important legal tools for preventing acts of corruption, such as bribery and embezzlement, but they should not be conflated with anti-corruption law. The alleged violations of conflict-of-interest norms by Trump and his associates and family members could very well be opening the door to corrupt transactions, but they are not, in themselves, necessarily acts of corruption. The term “corruption” in a legal context is therefore narrower than widely appreciated or reported in the popular press, as it refers in essence to public and private sector bribery and embezzlement, and variants on these two offenses (abuse of functions, trading in influence, and illicit enrichment). The narrowness of anti-corruption law means that grossly unethical conduct by government officials and problematic forms of campaign financing may facilitate or be associated with corruption, but they do not necessarily fall within the scope of criminal prohibitions on bribery and embezzlement. These phenomena should therefore be described using other legal terminology and must be addressed through other legal tools. In other words, anti-corruption law can only play a limited role in combating state capture.
It is simply too soon to say whether acts of grand corruption have occurred in the Trump administration, as this would involve proving allegations that domestic public officials had accepted bribes or stolen public funds. Thus far, the Trump family’s business schemes in cryptocurrency markets have involved extreme self-enrichment and, in some instances, appear to have involved an exchange of advantages, which seem to amount to bribery in plain view. For example, after Trump’s election in 2024, the crypto asset entrepreneur, Justin Sun, reportedly purchased $30 million in crypto tokens from Trump’s World Liberty Financial. Soon thereafter, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) suspended an investigation into cryptocurrency fraud by Mr. Sun and his companies. Similarly, after the cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase donated millions to a pro-Trump super PAC, Trump’s inauguration fund, and the White House ballroom renovation, the SEC announced that it would drop a lawsuit against Coinbase. The visibility of such transnational relationships between Trump and powerful, private actors contrasts starkly with most grand corruption scandals, in which both parties normally go to great lengths to conceal such exchanges from public awareness.
Whether these schemes and incidents could be characterized as a form of corruption in the narrow, legal sense should be investigated by current and future prosecutors. One challenge would involve demonstrating the requisite mental element for the criminal offence of bribery. In order to prove that a public official has committed passive bribery (the solicitation or acceptance of a bribe), for example, prosecutors must be able to produce evidence of an intention to obtain an undue advantage in exchange for the misuse of a public office. Another problem is that we can no longer depend on prosecutors being sufficiently resourced and independent to be able to conduct such investigations, precisely because the process of state capture is well underway in the United States—not at the level of state capture in South Africa, but heading in that direction. Conditions in the United States at this moment are not only ripe for acts of grand corruption, but the levers of accountability are proving to be more vulnerable and easier to attack than many may have imagined. Roht-Arriaza’s book serves as a reminder that the experience of the United States is not unique but rather follows a pattern familiar in fragile democracies and autocracies around the world.
Concluding Remarks
Roht-Arriaza’s new book on Fighting Grand Corruption significantly advances our understanding of how lawyers and activists in Latin America are seeking to combat corruption and repair the harm that it causes. For researchers and practitioners working in the anti-corruption field, this book represents a rich source of information about criminal and civil litigation in a region that may not be especially accessible for “outsiders” based elsewhere. The book’s value also lies in its extensive survey of a range of legal approaches to grand corruption. Although Roht-Arriaza does not herself argue for prioritizing or discarding certain approaches, her book can help others to reach their own conclusions about the best paths forward.
Finally, Fighting Grand Corruption contributes to the limited but important collection of international law books intended not only for specialized scholars and practitioners, but also for a general audience.Footnote 8 The book’s style and form make it readable by members of the general public, as well as academics and students. The book’s general appeal also stems from its portraits of anti-corruption activists, lawyers, and judges in countries around the world. This book has evidently benefited from personal interactions between the author and individuals deeply involved in legal procedures related to cases of grand corruption. In some cases, we learn that these individuals were motivated to become activists, lawyers, or judges because of their personal experiences as victims of corruption and human rights violations. These brief portraits, which Roht-Arriaza consistently sprinkles throughout the book, add important, personal touches and ensure that the book’s insights are grounded in some empirical research. Ultimately, this book is a reminder of the great potential of books for a general audience—a reminder that they are potentially vehicles for character development and storytelling that leaves readers with enduring memories and impressions.
Funding Statement
Open access funding provided by Leiden University.
