Sunday 26 February (London)
I received a note from Northcote asking me to attend a small ex-cabinet meeting. I went to his house by mistake and was summoned as from there to Salisbury's where the meeting was. Present Salisbury, Northcote, Cross, Smith, J. Manners and Gibson.
We had before us a letter from Gladstone to Northcote proposing to give him an idea of what he, Gladstone, intended to say, that he should express great anxiety to avoid dissension between the Houses and hinting though in a very tortuous manner that if the Committee of the House of Lords would exclude all enquiry into the “judicial administration” of the Land Act he (Gladstone) would drop his vote of censure.Footnote 756 Northcote's answer saying that the Committee was now appointed and that he was sure that anything which the Government desired to have avoided would be avoided was also shown. After some discussion the matter was left there. It appeared that Salisbury had had some communications with Granville, but not in writing, and that they had come to nothing owing to the fact that Granville would not or could not define “judicial administration”. It is obvious that these words might be made to cover about everything comprised in the Land Act.Footnote 757
So it ended. At the close when the others had gone I had some conversation with Salisbury and suggested my idea of some kind of Literary Committee as part of our party organisation.
Monday 27 February (London)
House hunting all the morning and very tiring work.
In the evening at the House. There is evidently a good deal of dissatisfaction and apprehension at the chance of a collision between the two Houses. But there always are a great many who are very timid whenever there is a risk of any trouble.Footnote 758 It was so last year in the Irish difficulty. Lamington, Alington,Footnote 759 Shaftesbury (who is always very anxious) and several others began to talk to me in this strain. I drove home with Salisbury who does not seem to be at all alarmed. Gladstone had a meeting of the Liberal Party this afternoon and it does not seem to have been altogether unanimous, but one or two men of weight, like Whitbread, urged a support of the Government.
Cairns in the House.
Wednesday 15 March (London)
In the afternoon an important meeting at Northcote's. Present Salisbury, Cairns, Gibson, R. Winn,Footnote 760 Smith, Cross. Questions discussed:
1. Course to be pursued as to the Clôture resolutions,Footnote 761 generally understood to close debate if possible on Monday week 27th.
2. Serious discussion as to course to be pursued with regard to revival of the Coercion Act.Footnote 762 Salisbury very strong on the anomaly and impropriety of keeping men shut up indefinitely without trial. Most of us however very indisposed to take any step to enable Government to say that we had made their system of coercion impossible, which they would immediately do.
3. Smith to give notice of a resolution to extend the purchase clauses in the Land Act of last year in such a way as to enable occupiers to become owners and to be just to landlords.
Afterwards attended Grand Lodge where the Prince of Wales made his motion as to the recent attempt on the Queen's life.Footnote 763 He did it extremely well, in a very crowded and enthusiastic Lodge. I seconded the motion. My speech was very well received.Footnote 764
We afterwards dined at the Loyd Lindsays.Footnote 765 Old Lord OverstoneFootnote 766 was there, feeble in walking power but as fresh as possible in mind.
Tuesday 25 April (London)
A very busy day beginning with a meeting of the ex-cabinet at Northcote's. Present, Northcote, Smith, J. Manners, Stanley, Cross, Cairns, Cranbrook, Salisbury, Gibson. The discussion was confined entirely to Smith's motion on the Purchase Clauses of the Land Act, and Smith gave us a general notion of what he proposed to say. Cranbrook was opposed to the whole thing. Whether any agreed with him I do not know, for no one said so: perhaps some doubted.
Friday 5 May (London)
A meeting of our old Cabinet at the Carlton to decide as to what should be done.Footnote 767 The motion originally drafted by Beach and revised by Cairns agreed to [. . .]. Advised Salisbury (who consulted me) against a debate at present on Irish policy.
Sunday 7 May (London)
Horrible news this morning – poor Fred Cavendish cruelly murdered in the Phoenix Park close to the Lodge.Footnote 768 I got at breakfast a note from Salisbury asking me to meet him and others at Northcote's at 2.30. On arriving there we heard first for consideration a letter from Gladstone offering to accept Gibson's amendment of a ⅔ majority in the case of the Clôture, which after discussion was agreed to. Cross was the only one who was not favourable – all the others I think considered it a good bargain. Then we talked a good deal of this horrible murder. It was decided that Beach should not go on with his motion but that it should be accompanied by an intimation that we withdraw only on the understanding that the Government would act with vigour, and that we should instruct also that we are ready to give the Government every possible support in legitimate objects.
I walked away with Salisbury and thought him out of spirits and very much depressed, perhaps physically. He talked more than he has ever done in his old manner, community of danger strengthening the bonds between those who are acting together. I said to him what I said indeed to the others, that in my point of view this is rebellion, and I can see practically only two alternatives, either Irish Independence or very stern repression.
Later I called at the Phillimores. He was much shaken, and even he evidently condemns the Government, though he makes the best case he can for Gladstone. Later some talk with Froude and Lowe, interesting but very few details are known.
Thursday 15 June (London)
A meeting at Northcote's. Most of us, except Sandon, Beach, Duke of Northumberland present. We discussed little except the Arrears bill.Footnote 769 On the whole a general disposition to fight it, and an equally general belief that it will not do to put much trust in the Irish landlords.
In the House Salisbury made a very vigorous attack on the Egyptian policy of the Government.Footnote 770
Thursday 13 July (London)
A heavy day at the Commission but we are now very near to the end of our work. Meanwhile very terrible telegrams have come in from Alexandria. The town is in flames, the convicts are released and the Christians and Europeans have been massacred almost to a man. There has been no such picture of horror since the burning of Paris.Footnote 771
In the afternoon a Garden Party at Marlborough House. Every one was talking of these horrors, which seem to multiply upon us and (not unnaturally) we go on in the usual course marrying and giving in marriage and eating and drinking whilst the flood is rising round us.
Friday 14 July (London)
Our last formal meeting of the Defence Commission. It has lasted nearly three years, has often been very hard work, sometimes a matter of a good deal of anxiety, often of much difficulty. But we have completed it and I think the work will on the whole stand the test of examination.
Friday 21 July (London)
A meeting of the Peers at Salisbury's as to the Arrears bill. He made an able and very clear speech, saying that between the two views, against the Second Reading and for the bill, he advised amending it in committee in order (a) to make the application a joint one from landlord and tenant (b) to include in the “aspects” the tenant right.Footnote 772 The meeting was unanimous in agreeing to this except LeitrimFootnote 773 who made a dissentient and not very wise speech.
Thursday 27 July (London)
A long discussion over the Arrears bill.Footnote 774 I sat all the evening expecting to have to speak and taking notes: but the debate grew thinner and thinner and finally expired, so that any speech from me was unnecessary. I was the only one besides Salisbury on the Front Bench of the old Cabinet. Richmond and Cairns both absent – not quite right I think.
Friday 4 August (London – Highclere)
Two important conversations with Cairns and Salisbury [. . .]. My conversations with Salisbury and Cairns were on the subject of our amendments on the Arrears bill.Footnote 775 When I came into the writing room first AbergavennyFootnote 776 drew me aside in great excitement and told me he feared a split in the party if Salisbury persevered in insisting on the amendments. Then Barrington spoke to me in much the same line. On going into the House the first words I heard Salisbury say to LathomFootnote 777 were “I will not eat dirt,” so I knew pretty well what was going on. I talked a good deal to him and found him very determined – then he left the House and I had some conversation with Cairns, who said that he from the first had disliked the course taken, that he was in favour of compromise, that he “had a delicacy” in saying all this to Salisbury but that I could do well to use any influence I might have by representing all this to him. I said I thought he had much better talk it over with Salisbury: but on S. coming in again I told him all that had passed, and the two had some talk afterwards but not I imagine to much purpose. I understood from Cairns that he would not take any open part in dissenting but I doubt if he will vote for the amendments.Footnote 778
It was finally settled that there should be a Peers’ meeting on Thursday morning before we consider the amendments in the House.
All this is very unsatisfactory. Salisbury's notion is that the House of Lords had best fight both to show themselves a formidable power and to arrest the habit of compromise which is sapping their moral courage: my doubt is, and it is only a doubt, whether the field of battle is well chosen.Footnote 779
Thursday 10 August (London)
Two very busy and anxious days. Came up to London with Elsie and first saw Northcote.Footnote 780 I questioned him as to his opinion on the course we ought to take upon insisting on our amendments. He was very divided in mind as to the policy of the matter but he was quite clear that as regards the House of Commons our men there would not vote again in support of our amendments. Smith he said was of much the same opinion and this in his mind was the great difficulty of the situation.
From him I went to Salisbury who seemed in a very reasonable mood, but his mind evidently made up to fight. I told him that Cairns was leaving London, and I mentioned one or two other depletions and I said that I anticipated a very small majority if any in support. He admitted the risk of this but seemed more sanguine than I quite understood.
The next day, Thursday, we had a meeting of Peers in Arlington Street, nearly 100. A large number spoke after Salisbury but except InchiquinFootnote 781 not one was in favour of insisting on the Amendments. I indeed spoke very strongly in support of Salisbury himself, said that I thought that on the whole it would be safer to fight than to retreat and that I should certainly vote with him and Cranbrook, whilst indisposed to insist, also spoke strongly for Salisbury. Richmond on the other hand headed an attack on the amendments and Salisbury went out of his way to inform them that Cairns differed from him. The sense of the meeting was so strong that Salisbury at last asked them to divide and it then appeared that about three fourths were against him.Footnote 782 He was evidently very much annoyed and later in the afternoon in the House announced that he had been beaten by an overwhelming majority of his own friends, giving an unfortunate appearance of temper.Footnote 783 He had no doubt great cause to complain of the change of the opinion on the part of the peers, but he also need never have nailed his colours to the mast in the earlier stages and even now might have retreated without the appearance of a quarrel with his friends. It was a bad business and will damage him and all of us, in the future.
Sunday 13 August (London)
Much interesting talk with Northcote particularly on recent events, which he much deplores. He said to me that he had greatly regretted Salisbury's great disinclination to meet in private conference to talk over matters and ascertain the views of each other. He seems to have founded this disinclination on the fear that we should be known to meet; but what did or does this matter? No one knows what we say or decide on.
The real reason is doubtless a different one, and is to be found in Salisbury's belief that he is more independent by avoiding consultation: but I do not myself think that this is the result.
