This book is about the transformation of the Indonesian island of Java under late Dutch colonialism into an “oriental Cuba,” a reference to the rise of industrially manufactured sugar. Divided into three parts, the first explores the global nature of the industrial revolution in sugar manufacture; a second, at the core of the book, elucidates the rise of sugar barons; while a third summarizes the state of the sugar industry in Java up to the international “sugar crisis” of 1886. Dense footnotes—many linking with Dutch archival sources—reveal that this is an academic text, just as its author, G. Roger Knight, engages in many academic conversations, as, for example, in critiquing Clifford Geertz's classic study on “agricultural involution” in Java.
True to the book's title and focus, chapter 1 announces the age of steam, industrialization, and globalization of markets as a distinctive feature. Knight explains the West-East dissemination of new technologies relating to sugar refining, including the introduction of the so-called vacuum pan used to “cook” sugar at a lower temperature. It is certainly striking, as the author relates, how the new technologies spread unevenly to such places as the Philippines and Mauritius, though most systematic in their introduction to Java.
Chapter 2 examines the Promethean impact of the new technologies upon Holland's distant colony. Steamships, railroads, and sugar mills were all part of this technological transition and local innovation. The times were certainly transitional, and the technology hybrid. This chapter also discusses the new managerial class who ran the show, with a number of these rascals and professionals creatively profiled.
By the 1860s, as discussed in chapter 3, Java had practically caught up with Cuba in sugar-refining technology, just as the introduction of technology levered Cuba up ahead of Brazil in production. It is pertinent, as described, that mill managers were actually part of an international “network of knowledge” (p. 80). The picture that emerges of the new mills introduced into Java is of the triumph of industrialism over the archaic Chinese-style milling that had preceded it. Still, labor was based upon corvée, not free wage labor, notwithstanding the military-like organization of the plants.
Chapter 4 moves to a discussion of how land and labor were harnessed to the industrial sugar project. The hegemonic role of sugar within the colonial state cultivation system, involving enforced planting of export crops, makes up the bulk of this chapter. In contrast to the New World experience, Knight views labor on Java as outside of slavery and plantation conditions, especially as peasant producers worked the land. On densely populated Java, sugarcane was not a monoculture but grown alongside other crops, rice included. Much of this chapter is a learned discussion on how labor fitted into this system. Further, the “state” was not the sole beneficiary of labor coercion; Chinese, some Arabs, and native princes, alongside Dutch officials, all took their share as they greased the wheels of commerce.
Undoubtedly business historians will be most attracted to chapter 5, which links sugar with the rise of a local colonial bourgeoisie—described as “empire families.” Virtual CEOs in modern parlance, these included merchants, speculators, and rent seekers, organically connected to the metropolis. Ranging over fifty pages, this chapter includes a discussion of “capital formation,” or business contractors (Dutch and some Chinese) with connections to the local bureaucratic state. Unlike in Cuba, state subsidies were long necessary for the industry's survival on Java. With the progressive fading of state subsidies in the 1850s, and the demise of “culture system” by the 1870s, private capital stepped in. Pen portraits of some of the barons illuminate this chapter. Knight's commentary on the state-business relations of that dark colonial age has a contemporary ring to it, especially in noting the importance of connections (sometimes marriage alliances) and the practice of corruption—a resilient practice, as it turns out, if we consider Indonesia today.
A final chapter brings the story up to a crisis in the mid-1880s, namely, a dramatic fall in the world price of sugar. Here the author seeks to challenge a prevailing thesis in which “backwardness” beset the industry prior to the crisis, in terms of the introduction of state-of-the-art technology and application of science. Still, the transition from water power to steam was slow, even relative to Cuba. As Knight continues to explain in the conclusion, industry expansion actually continued with the help of metropolitan capital until the interwar depression of the 1930s, by which time the Japanese sugar empire on Taiwan had triumphed. Virtually wrecked during the Japanese occupation, the sugar industry on Java was nationalized by the Republic in the 1950s and never regained its former luster.
Building upon a specialization in late-colonial Indonesian history, and some mastery over Dutch archives, Knight has undoubtedly produced the most authoritative work yet on this broad subject. For this author, and perhaps many readers, more background on the pioneering and (proto-industrial) role of the Chinese in the earlier centuries could have been a salutary inclusion, a reference to the “revolutionary” roller technology that the Fujianese introduced in parts of Southeast Asia in an earlier epoch (p. 200). The Cuba analogy announced on the first page works, but again, some regional context could also have offered a broader perspective, as in the case of the rise of the sugar industry in the Philippines under late Spanish colonialism. Actually, the author is hooked on his own Promethean theme of progress. We wonder what really happened to handicraft sugar, organic sugar, and traditional technologies as well. The question of profits and “colonial drain” are hardly covered. (Lacking an index, the book is, however, available in a fully searchable e-book format.)
