By examining problems of lunacy in the home from 1820 to 1860, Akihito Suzuki aims to bridge two historical fields previously treated separately by specialists: the mid-nineteenth-century reforms in lunacy and the formation of new domestic ideals. Since his principal source is the records of the Court of Commission of Lunacy, which was charged with determining whether an individual was in fact a lunatic, his fascinating case studies are strongly biased towards the social elite. Rather like eighteenth-century visitors to Bedlam, the public a century later took a keen interest in the legal performance and journalistic representation of the court's proceedings. Suzuki uses this source material to excellent effect in this elegantly written and original analysis.
He follows David Wright in arguing that the family's testimony was vital in the medical profession's diagnosis, and that what was presented to the court was a negotiation between lay and professional observation. Building on this insight he also suggests – through a dissection of the collapse of the flourishing career of George Man Burrows in 1829 and 1830 – that the involvement of doctors in the court exposed the differences between what they wrote about the theory of practice and what they actually did with their patients. Practitioners such as Burrows neglected this at their professional peril. The use of case studies such as Burrows to illuminate more general trends (in this instance the epistemological structure of psychiatric practice) is very skilfully and convincingly done throughout the volume.
Madness at Home investigates both the need to protect society from the harm that an insane individual could do and the need to protect the property and finances of the family of the lunatic. Suzuki therefore extends previous historical work on the protection of the individual lunatic to a more central focus on the family and its economic interests. It is in this second sphere that Suzuki locates the second of his two themes – emerging domestic ideology and distinctive family values – and the role that these played in measuring, arbitrating, managing and controlling madness. He also indicates the legal and social ambiguity in which such domestic management took place.
On the basis of a nuanced and convincing interpretation of mid-nineteenth-century familial cases, Suzuki asserts the continued primacy and independence of a lay or domestic psychiatric culture that intimately understood and treated family members. He therefore departs from the earlier interpretations of Michael MacDonald and Mary Fissell, who saw such lay medical culture declining in the nineteenth century. Such continuing domestic psychiatry, Suzuki argues, was flexible, unsystematic and framed by personal relationships within the context of evangelical belief in the central role of a family in understanding and supporting its members through its emotional solidarity with them. However, evangelicalism, although pervasive in the middle classes, was not ubiquitous, so the extent to which Suzuki's thesis can be extended is problematical. And the author's suggestion that the concept of moral treatment crossed from the domestic realm to the institution is an insight already familiar to students of the progressive York Retreat.
Whilst Suzuki uses only qualitative analysis, Jo Melling and Bill Forsythe also use very substantial quantification in a local study of Devon. They aim to reappraise more general debates on insanity by examining four asylums there: the large Devon County Asylum that opened in 1845 at Exminster, two later pauper lunatic asylums at Exeter and Moorhaven, and the small, private Wonford House Asylum. These establishments are set within the complex politics of power relationships with Poor Law institutions more generally, together with the local magistracy and national bodies such as the Poor Law Board and the Lunacy Commission. Broadly agreeing with Peter Bartlett's thesis about the shaping of the asylum by the Poor Law, Melling and Forsythe offer an analysis stressing diversity and complexity within a single county, as well as the growing power of the Lunacy Commission during the later nineteenth century.
‘Our emphasis’, they write, ‘is upon the role of the asylum not only as a reference point for the boundaries of acceptable behaviour but also as an institution for the disposal of those for whom other forms of provision had failed’ (p. 22). For purposes of understanding processes of admission, treatment and discharge of patients, the authors have compiled very detailed and valuable sets of statistics. From these they argue that gender and marital status showed interesting variation, with the unmarried disproportionately likely to be admitted to the asylum and, in addition, staying for longer periods. Within the asylum, married men had a smaller chance of recovering than married women, whilst both married and unmarried men were more likely to die there than were women. As in studies of Buckinghamshire by David Wright and Hampshire by Susan Burt, this Devon case study shows the significance of relatives in the admission and discharge of patients. And differences as well as similarities were apparent between private and public (pauper) asylums in the careers of their patients, although more discussion of this potentially important dimension would have helped make these clearer. Usefully, this study links variables such as gender to the ‘social resource endowment’ of individuals, in terms of class or marital status, and hence to their ability to sustain an independent life outside an institution.
The Politics of Madness departs significantly from earlier work by Andrew Scull and others in indicating that it was not the poorest individuals in society who overwhelmingly went into the public asylum but members of a broader social spectrum, drawn from labourers, those working in handicrafts and those engaged in small commercial activity or in petty office-holding. And at the private Wonford House not just affluent groups but those with only modest respectability or even in genteel poverty were admitted. Interestingly, Melling and Forsythe's study also reveals more generally that it was the more settled members of local communities who were most likely to be sent to the asylum – a point emerging as well in recent studies of the Irish asylum.
Both of the volumes under review are characteristic of recent historical interpretation in concentrating not only on the asylum but on the moral, political and legal contexts within which it operated, and particularly on the important role of the families from which it drew patients. Each offers very valuable new insights to current scholarship.
