Ronald Mize and Alicia Swords have penned a tour de force of Mexican labour, capitalism and consumers, marshalling an impressive array of evidence drawn from a variety of bibliographic and archival resources and spiced with data from interviews and personal experiences. The authors posit that we live in a ‘consumer-driven economy ’, that ‘consumption is built upon the backs of those who produce goods and services’ (p. xxvi) and that ‘the central thesis of Consuming Mexican Labor is that the current consumption level of the North American population rests squarely, though clearly not exclusively, on the backs of Mexican labor’ (p. xxxii).
Much of what follows goes to substantiate this thesis, though in the process the authors accomplish a great deal more. For instance, in the first part of the book they present a lengthy historical introduction to recent Mexican immigration, tracing its roots to the Bracero Program. This is a standard procedure for any broad treatment of Mexican immigration, yet Mize and Swords develop a finely detailed account of the period that chronicles the broken contracts, discriminatory treatment, and sub-standard food and housing through carefully selected archival materials as well as interviews with former braceros. The second part of Consuming Mexican Labor is entitled ‘Mounting Resistance’. Three successive chapters follow immigrant workers' organisation from the farm-worker civil rights movement to the period of ‘backlash and retrenchment’ in the 1980s and 1990s. This was, for me, the highlight of the book. Systematic treatment of the entire panoply of Mexican labour protest and organisation, from the wildcat strikes of the Bracero Program to the 1992 Southern California Drywallers' strike, the UNITE Garment Workers' Justice Centers and the 2006 May Day rallies, is hard to come by.
Part III entails a regional appreciation of the role of Mexican labour in the reproduction of North American consumer capitalism. Many of the six chapters in this, the book's lengthiest part, are largely descriptive, intended, it would seem, to drive home the point concerning the prominence of Mexican labour in key industries across the land. As useful as these chapters are for scoring points about the number of Mexicans and their incorporation into a variety of important industries, from meat-packing in the Midwest to agriculture in the south-east, I found them generally less engaging than earlier ones in which the information was integrated into a historical and sociological narrative about work, daily life, exploitation and resistance. However, separate chapters treating Mexican labour in Mexico and in Canada avoid some of these problems. Indeed, the former (chapter 10) analyses the domestic (Mexican) impact of the Mexican state preference for the neoliberal political economic model, while the latter (chapter 11) details the precarious forms of legalised incorporation of Mexican labour through the Canadian Seasonal Agricultural Workers Program (SAWP) and other low-wage programmes. The authors observe how ‘Temporary migration to Canada, as formalized in the SAWP, is increasingly becoming the norm in the NAFTA era’ (p. 224). The book's conclusion focuses on political organisation for the future and the importance of blasting open ‘the discursive closure’ that limits discussion to narrowly framed bipolar alternatives: the ‘rights vs. numbers’ argument around temporary foreign worker programmes comes to mind here. The authors consider liberal, social democratic and transformative responses and the conditions under which the first two might morph into the third in order to end the exploitation of Mexican workers.
I found Consuming Mexican Labor extremely passionate, well researched and readable, for which reasons it would serve as an excellent text in a variety of undergraduate courses. It can function as an excellent antidote for those persons who enter a classroom or public forum under the impression that Mexican migrant workers make no fundamental contribution to their survival and that the workers' forced deportation would have no noticeable impact on the domestic economy.
That said, I found that the precision of the historical and demographic materials was not matched by the book's theoretical underpinning, a concern that should not diminish its important contribution to current social science and, more importantly, political debate. For instance, I question whether consumption ‘drives’ capitalist economies. Whereas the authors acknowledge the dialectical relationship of consumption and production in order to revisualise the role of labour – ‘Those who build this country must be seen when they have often been invisible’ (p. 244) – their suggestion that contemporary capitalist economies are consumer-driven would seem to represent a major revision of the Marxist approach that informs their approach in this book. Moreover, I am sceptical regarding the transformative potential of a change in consumer preferences. To take one example, there exists a growing literature to the effect that fair trade is anything but fair, and that one of the main effects of fair trade discourse and practice has been to reinforce liberal Western consumers' belief that the exploitation of third world producers can be mitigated, or eradicated, through market choice. Second, I think that a slightly more nuanced approach to Mexican immigrant labour might have strengthened this book. Stronger recognition of Mexican immigrant labour as a key immigrant faction, dominant in many, but not all, areas of immigrant labour, would avoid the multiculturalism that can creep in when one carves out one ethnic-national labour force for special treatment. The problem that Mexicans confront is shared by Salvadoreans, Guatemalans, Hondurans and many other Latino and non-Latino immigrants, even if the small size of those countries compared to Mexico determines that immigrants originating from them make a smaller demographic contribution to the US labour force, and if those immigrant workers, when noticed at all, are routinely mistaken for Mexicans.
Disagreements aside, this is a wonderful contribution to the literature, an excellent combination of historical and sociological analysis that includes a perceptive and challenging political assessment of immigrant exploitation, struggles and resistances, and how and why Mexican immigrants can play key roles in bringing about more just societies in North America. I recommend it highly.
