Falling, Floating, Flickering: Disability and Differential Movement in African Diasporic Performance by Hershini Bhana Young explores the intersection of disability, Blackness, and performance through the concept of differential movement. This concept includes embodied gestures such as falling, floating, and spasming that challenge conventional norms of time, space, and identity. By reinterpreting these movements, the author addresses how they disrupt colonial histories, racialized oppression, and ableist frameworks by offering alternative modes of sociality and embodiment, resonating with the nonhuman turn in the humanities field. Through vivid case studies, such as African diaspora students reclaiming breath or hip-hop’s vocal aesthetics, the book highlights how disability is central to creativity and relationality. Furthermore, the work offers methods for critiquing commodified performances of disability that reinforce ableism, advocating instead for practices that reimagine Black disabled sociality. Young additionally argues that acts by nondisabled performers embodying disability, when thoughtfully framed, can resist self-mastery and foster collective insurgency. Falling, Floating, Flickering successfully weaves personal narrative, cultural analysis, and historical critique to propose new possibilities for identity, connection, and artistic expression in a world shaped by differential embodiment.
An outline of the author’s theoretical landscape and discussion of the compelling verbs animating the book’s arguments stand in for a chapter-by-chapter summary here. In the Introduction, the author describes how the vibrations of a spoken word—intabi—resonate through the air, allowing a student to breathe again (2). This moment symbolizes a “redistributed sensorium” (3) in which survival becomes a shared, collective act. Young frames this narrative to show how disability reconfigures human connections, creating new forms of relationality and “being with and for one another” by “holding another person’s breath” (3). Citing performance artist Cristin Ellis, who characterizes stuttering as a dual fugitivity, Young highlights how disability escapes control yet also liberates individuals from normative speech structures. This reframing creates an alternative listening that reshapes embodiment and expands temporal and sensory dimensions of interaction. Disability’s capacity to disrupt norms playfully also appears in hip-hop, where stutters, rasps, and breaks are not limitations but aesthetic and cultural vernaculars. These vocal interruptions embody a distinctive cultural voice, challenging ableist notions of disability as lack and instead revealing its enrichment of artistic expression.
Chapters 1 and 4 explore the choreography of falling, crawling, and spasming, movements laden with colonial histories and racialized experiences. Horizontal gestures like falling contrast with the verticality of progress and survival, showing how colonized bodies were marked by downward trajectories. Yet, reframing these movements reveals alternative temporalities that resist normative structures. Similarly, floating emerges as a liminal state between life and death, as seen in Mediterranean migrant crises. Migrant bodies, reduced to data points or material symbols, lose their humanity in dehumanizing abstractions. Artistic interventions like Berni Searle’s multimedia works reclaim these bodies’ sensory and emotional dimensions, restoring their presence in collective memory. Young also discusses “floaters” (103)—both as the vitreous debris in the eye and as a metaphor for fragmented perception. This tactile knowledge resists dominant narratives that erase marginalized perspectives, particularly those of racialized bodies often rendered invisible. The analysis of mermaid figures and conjoined twins in Chapter 3 illustrates how bodies defy categorization, fostering a shared vulnerability that challenges anthropocentric and species ethics. Drawing on scholars like Sylvia Wynter, Denise Ferreira da Silva, and Patricia Williams, this chapter critiques liberal humanism as a historical tool of Black dispossession rather than empowerment. Instead of relying on binary narratives such as animals–human rights, the author employs human–animal hybrids as an analytical tool to emphasize how “flickering” destabilizes rigid boundaries between human and animal (107).
Throughout the book, the author extends critical inquiries from critical race studies and crip theory, continuing their profound questioning of what it means to be human. At the same time, Young endeavors to redefine the very notion of performativity by asking, How can we transcend the binary of survival and death to understand performativity? How do we reckon with the others neglected by Foucault’s biopolitical framework of “make live, let die”? While the author’s theoretical originality is remarkable, the book could benefit from a stronger connection between its abstract concepts and lived/embodied experiences. For instance, the discussion of physiological phenomena like floaters is fascinating, but without anchoring these ideas in everyday experiences, readers might find it difficult to relate. Similarly, while the book incorporates performances by artists like Cristin Ellis, Berni Searle, Die Antwoord, and Spoek Mathambo, a more vivid depiction of actions, movement analysis, emotions, and settings could better convey the layered meanings of concepts like “floating.” These additions would enhance the reader’s ability to grasp the interplay between theory and embodiment. Nevertheless, this book excels in its ambitious theoretical framework, offering a timely contribution to the intersecting fields of performance studies, the nonhuman turn, and crip theory. It provides a groundbreaking exploration of how performance can dismantle ableist and racist structures, creating spaces where differential movement fosters new possibilities for Black and disabled socialities. By challenging essentialist and commodified views, Young calls for a more inclusive and imaginative approach to identity, aesthetics, geography, and embodiment.
Finally, this book takes performativity to a deeper level. Young is not just analyzing performance art but reading, excavating, and activating the archive through actions—falling, crawling, spasming, flickering—reconstructing history through a dynamic, embodied lens rather than merely describing it. This approach resonates with Uri McMillan’s Embodied Avatars (2015), which stresses that performance is not just a representation of history but an active force in making it. From an ontological and postcolonial perspective, Young does not frame the African diaspora as passive subjects of colonial history but instead positions their presence as an integral part of global society—centering their actions, voices, and bodies as the starting point of discussion. This approach is somewhat reminiscent of Saidiya Hartman’s Wayward Lives, Beautiful Experiments (2019)—highlighting how Black communities create life on their own terms rather than being passively defined by historical surveillance. Young’s entire book pulses with actions, its prose is intricate and alive, moving away from an anthropological lens. Writing itself becomes a process of composition—as if bringing dancing experience into textual resonance, generating images, senses, and affect, theorizing choreography in a way that pushes against the static, text-centered paradigm of traditional dance studies.
