The Media Players: Shakespeare, Middleton, Jonson, and the Idea of News makes a persuasive case for the centrality of the commercial theatre to the burgeoning news culture of early modern England. Rather than following a Habermasian long view of media change, in which news eventually displaces the stage, Stephen Wittek shifts attention to the intensely formative period between 1590 and 1630 when theatre and news flourished together. This concentrated focus is crucial in that it invites us to think about theatre and news in dynamic relation to one other, as collaborators as much as competitors in the push to retail current affairs for public consumption. Wittek defines England's news culture broadly, drawing on a diverse set of materials that includes rumor, gossip, ballads, cheap pamphlets, private correspondence, newsletters, newsbooks, and translations of foreign newssheets. At the same time, he retains a certain privilege for the theatre, which, he claims, constituted a “unique discursive space” that “helped to foster the conceptual framework that made news possible” (1). As the subtitle announces, the book's concern is less with news itself, in its various material forms, than it is with theatre's role in fostering the concept or idea of news, as a category of thought and feeling foundational to the plurality of publics in which newspapers would later flourish.
The book's opening chapter offers a lucid account of the theatre's multiple engagements in news culture, both at the level of representation and within the collective experience of performance and playgoing. As is commonly observed, theatre in this period offered playgoers a sought-after proximity to news along with the chance to participate in current conversations and controversies; moreover, it allowed them to be part of the fashionable scene of newsmakers—“to see and to be seen,” as Ben Jonson puts it in The Staple of News. The stage's fascination with news culture also fostered a new sense of contemporaneity, encouraging playgoers to see themselves as part of a “continuous, public present” (11) separate from the past and future. The effect of theatre's interaction with news, Wittek contends, is to generate a protopublic sphere, a discursive space characterized by increased awareness and debate about questions of credibility and truth, belief and interpretation, and the power and modes of media.
The book's central chapters explore this discursive space in plays by Shakespeare, Middleton, and Jonson. Chapter 2 examines the scenes of Autolycus's ballad peddling in The Winter's Tale, reading the play as “an early exercise in media criticism” (27). Wittek traces a network of historical references, extending from Autolycus's links to Mercury to current debates about ballads, a popular medium that, if not precisely news, nonetheless contributed to an incipient news culture, circulating opinions and commentary with mass appeal. Shakespeare's interrogation of ballads, Wittek suggests, connects to the play's larger conversations about truth, belief, and skepticism. Chapter 3 reviews the complicated politics at work in A Game at Chess, a play notorious for capitalizing on the explosion of news surrounding the Spanish Match, the potential marriage between the future Charles I and the Infanta Maria, sister of King Felipe IV of Spain. Not surprisingly, the play's performance provoked a range of responses, and the strength of this chapter lies in its compelling exploration of Middleton's public making in relation to an unusually rich archive of contemporary news and commentary. Countering critics who see the play taking sides in affairs of state, Wittek suggests that Middleton instead puts the burden on the audience to sort conflicting information circulating as news. The final chapter turns to Jonson's The Staple of News, the locus classicus of early modern news criticism. Freighted with metatheatrical commentary, the play's critique of news culture sets up a “feedback loop” with audiences at the Blackfriars Theatre (95). This, Wittek argues, enables “a comprehensive meditation on the protocols and conventions of the theatrical public that also attempts to engage, and influence, the public created by printed news” (100).
An accessible introduction to recent work on early modern news, The Media Players is valuable in its focus on the productive interplay between theatre and news culture. What resolves the commonplace opposition between competing forms of media in this account is the idea of publicity or public making, broadly conceived as operating across various forms of public discourse. This is a powerful claim about the processes of media change, one that individual chapters might do more to investigate. But what's left uncharted is also an invitation, and The Media Players offers a useful guide for further explorations of early modern media.
