This book examines how the global spread of capitalism has transformed the everyday lives of children in disparate and far flung geographical contexts. In wonderful intricate detail, it draws parallels between the changes occurring in the processes of everyday social reproduction in northern Sudan and those that are at play in the restructuring of the everyday lives of children in New York City in the 1970s and 1980s. Katz's major argument is that global economic restructuring transforms the scale of uneven development producing similar changes in the relationship between economic production and social reproduction in disparate local settings. Focusing on the geographies of everyday life, Katz documents how the systematic devaluation of their children's skills and knowledge and the widening inequalities among them accompanied attempts to integrate both places into global markets. Although much of the book is concerned with documenting the actual work of social reproduction in Howa and the commonalities between the transformations brought by global capitalist restructuring in the global north and south, Katz also seeks to provide the building blocks of a research methodology for political engagement, which she defines as topographical analysis. She argues that by producing thick descriptions of social relations, material social practices, and the construction of meaning within specific historicosocial landscapes, we can begin to produce a countertopography—a political imaginary able to counter the disabling effects of globalized capitalism.
For the first four chapters Katz, takes us on a journey that starts with a thick description of a child's day in Howa and follows with a detailed historiography of the political economy and ecology of Howa village; the entanglement of processes of economic production and social reproduction in children's work and play in Howa and the role of both processes in the creation of particular ways of knowing and being. In chapters 5 and 6, she guides us through the transformations occurring between production and reproduction in Howa and the growing deskilling and commodification of labor that has followed; the parallels between the processes that preempted the deskilling and dislocation of work in Howa and the forms of disinvestment and dislocation experienced by working class children in New York since the 1970s. In the seventh and eighth chapters we are taken back to the village of Howa about ten years after the first ethnographic study was conducted to revisit the lives of the children (now turned adult) who Katz first encountered and the altered topographies created by the passage of time and importantly, oil, ethnic conflict, and the changing formulations of Western development and aid policy. In the final chapter, Katz begins the task of constructing a countertopography by distinguishing between forms of resistance, resilience, and reworking in the face of revanchism in both New York and in Howa.
Katz's chapters on the structures of everyday work and play among children in the village of Howa offer a level of detail that is fascinating. These chapters offer a real insight into how children think about and produce lives that those in the global North often describe as poverty, drudgery, and “backwardness.” In Katz's rich description of the ways that children acquire agricultural and environmental skills and knowledge, we gain an understanding of the agency, hopes, and achievements of children in landscapes that are not inferior, but simply different. By the fifth chapter readers come to recognize the children that she conducted research with as individuals with personalities and capabilities partly molded by the landscapes within which they are embedded but also by the social reproductive networks of which they are a part. The narrative, although at times somewhat “overthick” in description, does the necessary task of documenting how the work of social reproduction actually happens and the indivisibility of economic and social reproduction.
Katz argues that global capitalism constantly produces geographies of uneven development in its wake, reconfigurations that alter the relationship between economic and social reproduction across scales and space. In chapter 5, she documents how the implementation of the Suki Agricultural Project led to the monetization of Howa society and heightened levels of social and economic differentiation among its members. Drawing on Marx's observations on the social transformations that occur when money becomes representative of wealth and exchange value itself, Katz argues that attempts to modernize Howa agricultural practices ultimately transformed them from a people with unique knowledge and skills, into commodified waged labor. By taking us step by step through the complex and unequal ways that Howa labor became deskilled and intensified as money became an instrumental part of the local economy, Katz also draws our attention to the ways that the unwaged work of women, children, and the old also declined in value relative to the waged.
The argument that Katz poses regarding the growing gap between the demands for commodified and disembodied waged labor within global capitalism and the dislocations and displacements wreaked upon systems of social reproduction and children's everyday lives, is convincing and powerful. Her attempt to draw parallels between the consequences of these processes for the lives of children in Howa and New York City, however, is less so. Her description of the economic restructuring of New York City in the 1980s and in particular the rolling back of state commitments to education, did not provide as compelling an account of the mundane ways in which children's lives were being remade as a result. I suspect that the difficulty in making the parallels between these two geographic spaces convincing is largely due to the analytic methods used—the Howa chapter being largely ethnographic and the New York chapter grounded in policy analysis. Rather than highlighting the shared contours of a countertopography, the New York chapter felt more of a diversion, or a tactic to sustain the attention of an audience that might be more interested in places considered less off the beaten track. More compelling would have been an account that utilized a similar ethnographic method to present the voices of children in New York and that explored in similar detail how their lives were both constructed and under transformation.
Throughout the book Katz reminds us that her ultimate aim is to chart a countertopography, a way of countering the disabling effects of global capitalism, a manifesto for political engagement. This is the objective of the final chapter where she begins to tease out the many ways in which people responded to the erosion of the substance and practice of social reproduction. Dividing responses into three categories—resilience, acts that display a certain degree of autonomous initiative; reworking, conscious and pragmatic attempts to alter oppressive relations of power; and resistance, attempts to subvert or disrupt exploitative conditions—Katz argues that each offers the possibility for developing an oppositional consciousness that has the power to ultimately produce a revolutionary imagination. Using Benjamin's concept of mimesis, Katz asks that we open ourselves up to imagining a different world and to seek to do so by continuously drawing contour lines that link the fates of children in disparate geographic locals to the same source. While few would disagree with the need to develop a revolutionary imagination, Katz's final construction of the countertopography feels oddly dissatisfying and abstracted. Perhaps it is too much to ask for more from a book that so carefully details the ways that neoliberal economic restructuring is transforming children's lives, but without a more detailed map of the contours there is a danger that the average reader will remain disoriented. Notwithstanding these concerns, this is a book that I highly recommend; it brings to us an issue, a place, and a people that rarely make it into our political imaginations.
