Bruce Masters has made important contributions to the study of the Ottoman Arab provinces with his monographs The Origins of Western Economic Dominance in the Middle East: Mercantilism and the Islamic Economy in Aleppo, 1600–1750 (New York: New York University Press, 1988), and Christians and Jews in the Ottoman Arab World: The Roots of Sectarianism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2001). The present book is more of a general survey. It treats a number of themes central to the study of the Arab provinces, notably the nature of provincial administration, local notables, intellectual life and its relationship to trends in the imperial capital, and transformations in the 19th century. In the final analysis, however, I am not sure that it entirely fills the bill as an accessible introductory survey, a ruminative synthesis of current scholarship, or an exercise in cutting-edge approaches.
This is not a history of the Arab lands but a history of the Arabs. The author rightly warns against anachronistic and essentializing uses of this label while stressing the centrality of religion, on the one hand, and regionalism, on the other, to self-identification. All the same, his discussion tends to give the sense of an Arab identity that somehow transcends vagaries of time, space, and imperium. In an interesting experiment in “theorizing” the Arab experience under Ottoman rule, Masters draws on several revisionist studies of empire, such as Niall Ferguson's landmark reexamination of the British Empire and a general study of empires by Timothy Parsons; in this context, he refers to the Arabs in his introduction and conclusion as “collaborators” in an imperial project. This term perhaps carries a bit too much imperialist baggage to be wholly successful. For some readers, it will probably call to mind the “collaborative structure” of Ronald Robinson and John Gallagher's classic Africa and the Victorians: The Official Mind of Imperialism (London: Macmillan, 1961); for others, it may even raise the shade of Rudyard Kipling. Masters might more profitably have compared the Ottoman Empire with other land-based empires that took shape in the premodern era.
Wisely avoiding a strictly chronological approach to his subject in the core of his book, Masters adheres to a thematic exposition, even at the risk of occasionally uneven coverage. Whereas the first three core chapters cover Greater Syria, Egypt, Iraq, and even North Africa, the remaining four are decidedly Syria-centric, even where the Napoleonic invasion and the reforms of Mehmed (a.k.a. Muhammad) ʿAli Pasha are concerned. Presentation of the very complex situation in pre-19th-century Ottoman Egypt is sometimes problematic, in particular where the relationship among factions, households, and regiments of soldiery is concerned. Opinions may vary as to Masters’ assertion that “the case for a mamluk cultural continuity in Egypt is strong” (p. 30). I personally believe that it can be demonstrated that the Ottomans in the late 16th century deliberately channeled palace-trained personnel into Egypt's beylicate, with the result that several generations of devşirme recruits separated the Mamluk sultanate holdovers from a new wave of Circassians and other Caucasians in the 17th century. I would also contend that the 18th-century Georgian mamluk regime had undeniable connections to the contemporary Georgian regime in Iraq.
While the book's thematically organized chapters quite laudably strive for breadth and inclusiveness, some of them end up seeming rather diffuse. Chapter 3, “Economy and Society in the Early Modern Era,” for example, starts off with the crisis of the late 16th century, then goes on to discuss guilds, the aʿyān (urban notables), peasants, and tribal migrations. Moreover, some Ottomanists may disagree with the author's emphases in this particular chapter. He seems to portray the Ottoman economy as a largely provisionist system in which the central authority tried to ensure a uniform supply of commodities while limiting competition and exports in order to prevent social unrest; in recent years, however, the very existence of such a system has come into question. His discussion of the a‘yān, focused on Syria, could take fuller account of the arguments of Ehud Toledano and the present reviewer for localization as a link between exclusively “local” notables and transplants from the imperial center. I would also reconsider the claim that aʿyān in the Arab provinces were fundamentally different from their Anatolian and Balkan counterparts.
Chapter 4, “A World of Scholars and Saints,” reflects the fact that Ottoman intellectual history is currently undergoing a long-needed revitalization, although the chapter could take greater advantage of recent trends in this field. Here, the ulema are treated as a separate category from Sufis, even though a hallmark of Ottoman religious life was the rapprochement between the ulema and “mainstream” Sufi orders; indeed, the great Damascene scholar, Sufi, and chronicler ʿAbd al-Ghani al-Nabulusi (1641–1731), who receives quite a bit of space in this chapter, is a prime example of this phenomenon. Discussion of Sufism is dominated by attitudes toward Ibn ʿArabi's doctrines. The influential and multifarious Naqshbandi Sufi order, to which al-Nabulusi belonged, is presented, alongside the Wahhabis, as a “challenge to extreme Sufism,” while the Khalwati order, one of the most widespread and influential in the entire empire, is not mentioned. Masters rightly cites Khaled El-Rouayheb's revisionist findings on intellectual production in the Arab lands during the 17th century, yet curiously, he describes a lack of intellectual creativity and innovation during the Ottoman period—exactly the sort of lapse that El-Rouayheb seeks to disprove. The chapter ends with a section on “nonelite” culture and the coffeehouse that is something of a non sequitur.
The last three chapters, on the 19th and early 20th centuries, are quite solid, even if the author's account of the Westernizing Tanzimat reforms is heavily Syria-centric. Rather surprisingly, there is virtually no mention of Mehmed ʿAli Pasha's reforms within Egypt; even his destruction of Egypt's remaining mamluks in 1811 goes unmentioned. (Perhaps the thinking is that Egypt at this point was no longer part of the Ottoman Empire proper.) The author's deep familiarity with Arab Christians allows him to address the neglected topic of Syrian Christian reaction to the 1821 Greek uprising. At the same time, however, he does not mention the Syrian Catholics who played a critical role in trade with western Europe during the late 18th century, or the disproportionate role of Orthodox Christians in early Arab nationalism, although he does make the valid point that Arab nationalism was more inclusive than Turkish nationalism or the various Balkan nationalisms. He provides succinct yet cogent and informative coverage of Ottomanism as a unifying political ideology, the roots of salafism, reformist turn-of-the-20th-century ulema, early Zionism, and Ottoman mobilization for World War I.
One drawback to the book's utility as a textbook is the absence of photographs, maps, timelines, and other visual aids. While footnotes are helpfully placed at the bottom of the page, the format is rather haphazard, with errant punctuation and capitalization. Likewise, transliteration is occasionally inconsistent (qanun is used in some places, kanun in others) or eccentric (Ibn Ayas instead of Ibn Iyas, Çağalzade instead of Cigalazade; Kızıl Baş as two words), and some Ottoman names are misrendered. There is occasional misnumbering of kings and sultans (Louis XIV for Louis XV, p. 199; Mehmed IV for Mehmed V, p. 214), and occasional factual errors creep in, for example, the notion (p. 13) that the term rūmī can encompass people from the Caucasus, that Sultan Mehmed I (r. 1413–21) claimed to be the caliph (p. 54), that Zohar is another word for Jewish mysticism (p. 106), and that the Habsburg Empire was ruled by a kaiser (p. 223).
Writing a book on such a chronologically and geographically sweeping topic is no easy task, and certainly no one would claim that Bruce Masters lacks the expertise to undertake it. We might hope for a second edition of The Arabs of the Ottoman Empire, with more uniform coverage, better copyediting, and judicious use of visual aids.
