This is an insightful, highly theorized but difficult book about a new Islam that, according to Sadia Abbas, emerged in the late 1980s. The goal of this ambitious project is to contextualize within and against its colonial genealogy this Islam that is at once “a name, a discursive site … a geopolitical agon in and around which some of the most pressing aporias of modernity, enlightenment, liberalism, and Reformation are worked out” (p. 1). Abbas draws upon an almost dizzying array of high theory, world literature, films, popular culture (including the Danish cartoons), and art to build her case.
Abbas poses many interesting questions: What kind of Muslim do the former colonizers want? What role does race play in the accommodation of Muslims to the 21st century? How does the exclusion of Muslims from the American nation construct American identity? “Who gets to be an individual in the age of individualism?” (p. 43) What are the “planetary effects of linking injury, blasphemy, religious pain and Muslim identity” (p. 98)? In what ways does cultural relativism hurt Muslim women? “What are the ethics of transnational belonging?” (p. 148) We may not always agree with the answers but the questions are intriguing and they shape the thesis Abbas is promoting: the struggle for freedom is at the heart of the construction of this new Islam at war with its colonial legacy.
Abbas is very critical of theorists of contemporary Islam, but the ones she engages most intensively are Talal Asad and Saba Mahmood. Giving them much airtime, she critiques them for what she considers to be the essentializing of progressive secular neoliberals’ antipathy to religion. For her, their defense of orthodox Islam as a true form of anti-imperialism embraces illiberalism and a reactionary rejection of freedom. According to Abbas, to argue against secular liberalism is to misunderstand key issues, such as moral injury, in a binarized, global context. She critiques Asad for using “tropes from the history of slavery” in a misguided way. In so doing, he has misrepresented the critical role of race, thereby sharing “the discursive assumptions that underpinned slavery and its attendant racial discourses” (p. 24). Among other failings, Abbas accuses him of emphasizing religious texts over the subtleties of literature.
Abbas advocates a literary approach to Islam and she privileges South Asian writers, especially Pakistanis such as Mohammed Hanif and Nadeem Aslam whose works she characterizes as “Cold War Baroque.” This literature provides an overlooked prism on postcolonial Islam. To demonstrate the importance of literary criticism for understanding social and political problems that Muslims face today, she analyzes Muhammad Iqbal's rejection of Ahmadi claims to be Muslims. Declaring them heretics, he called for Muslim solidarity in support of an “eternal Islam” (p. 127). The injury that Iqbal's excommunication caused the Ahmadis traveled in time and shaped Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq's punitive Islamist regime with its imposition of ḥudūd laws.
Abbas deplores the discourse of feminists such as Joan Scott who defend freedom of choice in connection with the antiveiling laws in France. She dismisses Mahmood's justification of conservative Muslim women's arguments for veiling as an expression of their agency in order to refine her own “theories of the subject” (p. 61). Critique sometimes degenerates into condescension: “Mahmood simply underestimates imperial opportunism … Perhaps the claim Mahmood wants to make is that feminism ought not to be progressive at all” (p. 68). She is the champion of progressive Islam and in that capacity dismisses those who write from a perspective other than hers.
But in her analysis of literature, and especially the novels of Sudanese-British Leila Aboulela, she writes sympathetically and in general admiringly. She hails Aboulela's Translator as an important example of the religious novel genre even if the treatment of the religious subject is secular. The novel emblematizes postcolonial literary projects to translate, convert, and “transform the metropole, to change its culture, to make it more equitable” (p. 87). But in the end, Aboulela's novels are judged to be too narrow to examine religion's social effects. Did she expect a different book, perhaps the novel she would like to write, that would examine theological questions rather than tell a good story? She takes Aboulela to task for not extending her reach to the broader question of religion (Islam?) and society. Later, she praises Aslam's “self-consciously poetic” (p. 190) Maps for Lost Lovers for succeeding where Aboulela failed.
Abbas quotes at length television serial and film dialogues and theoretical passages with equal seriousness. Then, at much greater length, she provides excellent close readings that tease out the implications for her argument. The tone of the book is always intense, split between critique for theorists and praise for mostly Pakistani writers.
This is a book that should appeal to scholars and advanced students of contemporary Islam and South Asian literature. The problem, however, is its tortured language. Many paragraphs have to be reread, sometimes several times, in order to follow their logic. The lack of a bibliography is problematic in a book such as this since Abbas is making a case for different sources and approaches to contemporary Islam, but these sources are buried in voluminous footnotes. Nonetheless, At Freedom's Limit: Islam and the Postcolonial Predicament makes a significant contribution to postcolonial literary theory.
