Part diplomatic history, part exploration into Brazilian racial thought and national identity in an Atlantic context, Hotel Trópico takes the reader on a triangular journey back and forth between Brazil, Portugal and various sub-Saharan African countries during the 1960s and 1970s, ‘a kind of a golden age’ (p. 245) for Brazilian–African relations. Discussing together the vicissitudes of Brazil's self-image as a racial democracy and its foreign policy toward Africa, and effectively connecting these two themes to major Atlantic as well as global trends and events – namely African decolonisation, economic nationalism, authoritarianism, the Cold War and the US civil rights movement – this book is a remarkable scholarly achievement in several respects. First, by focusing the historiographical discussion of race in twentieth-century Brazil less on the well-trodden North–South path of comparisons or interaction with the United States and more on Brazil's ties to Africa and Portugal, it opens a fresh line of inquiry into this familiar topic. Here we are taken to the contact zones between Brazilians and their respectively black and white countries of origin in a period of renewed South–Atlantic crossings; to a space in which relatively equal power relations and shared cultural and historical affinities provide fertile ground for identification. Second, while Dávila focuses on interrelationships between nations, he does not reify them but rather integrates into the narrative an impressive range of mobile individuals and groups, from statesmen, high- and low-ranking diplomats, intellectuals, artists, activists, secret agents, exchange students and revolutionaries to ethnic and immigrant communities, guerrilla organisations, commercial companies, football (soccer) teams and more. He thus charts a dense dynamic web of transatlantic cultural, political and economic exchanges, reconstructed from Brazilian and Portuguese diplomatic sources, newspaper accounts, personal memoirs, photographs, artwork and interviews. The latter, conducted by the author with both state and non-state protagonists and successfully interlaced throughout the text, are especially noteworthy for their careful analysis, which sheds light on individual mindsets and beliefs. Third, these previously mentioned qualities make this book an exemplary study of international relations as intercultural relations, and while some may deplore the lack of explicit engagement with theory, the introduction of this approach to the South–South dimension of Brazil's and other Latin American countries' foreign policy should be unanimously applauded.
The chapters are organised around major political events and individual countries, generally progressing chronologically – a structure which emphasises change over time in the realm of diplomacy, and which cleverly pays attention to national particularities within the African continent. Chapter 1 sets the stage for the story, introducing its main protagonist, sociologist Gilberto Freyre, and his notions of lusotropicalism and racial democracy, which acquired great dominance in Brazil during the 1950s. ‘This set of beliefs was so powerful’, notes the author, ‘that it formed the conceptual framework not only for those Brazilians who supported Portuguese colonialism but even those who shunned Portugal, favoured decolonisation and sought ties with independent African nations’ (p. 21). The next two chapters show how Freyre's ideas acquired new relevance in the context of African independence in the early 1960s and strongly informed the ‘independent foreign policy’ of presidents Quadros and Goulart. The focus is on Brazilians' first direct encounters with independent Ghana and Nigeria upon the creation of embassies there, encounters marked by idealistic expectations of cooperation and grandeur.
The centrality of individual experiences in the early parts of the book gives way to an emphasis on collective mentalities and realpolitik in the remaining sections, which are devoted to Brazil's reaction to the outbreak of liberation wars in the Portuguese colonies and to the twists and turns of its international politics under the post-1964 military dictatorship. Of special interest here is the treatment of Luso-Brazilian affective bonds, which amounts to an important study in itself and invites further examination, especially in view of the strong tradition of Brazilian indifference or antipathy toward Portugal and the Portuguese. The combination of a powerful Portuguese lobby inside Brazil, effective Portuguese diplomacy and strong ethnic attachment to their mother country on the part of Brazilian policy-makers, the book argues, had put these predominantly white males in a constant dilemma: they had to choose between their sentimental connections to Portugal and their aspirations for leadership in the third world. Until 1974, the first choice prevailed. African efforts, led by Senegal, to coax Brazil away from its pro-Portuguese stand on the issue of decolonisation through sentimental appeals and political pressure had limited impact. At first, the right-wing military regime abandoned the African project of its populist predecessors, only to return to it amid changing economic conditions at home and abroad and the fall of the Salazarist regime in Portugal.
On the whole, the author's pattern of argument about Brazilians' views of the black continent and themselves stresses self-projection over self-exploration, continuity over change. In the epilogue, which extends the narrative into the beginning of the twenty-first century, he concludes that ‘Africa remained an abstraction in Brazil, a canvas on which Brazilian national aspirations and racial values were rendered’ (p. 255). This line of interpretation tends to belittle the dynamism and complexity of the attitudes that he himself describes so well. Underlying this tendency is a dichotomous interpretation of real versus imagined Africa, as is attested to by the frequent bracketing of the continent's name and usage of the metaphor of a ‘canvas’ or ‘stage’. The self-ascribed Africanness of influential white Brazilians is painstakingly documented, and its emotional authenticity (alongside its instrumental usage) is acknowledged. Ultimately, though, it is interpreted away as false due to these Brazilians' ignorance of Africa. The point is that collective identities are by nature simultaneously both imagined and real. Moreover, as Tzvetan Todorov has noted, knowledge of the Other operates on a distinct level from love of the Other – they are not mutually dependent. Yet for Dávila, Brazilian love of Africa is problematic also, above all because it had gone hand in hand with racial discrimination at home. Here he stands with those who do not see any corrective potential in the belief in racial democracy, even though his evidence seems to suggest that such potential exists. In this regard Hotel Trópico should be read in tandem with recent scholarship by Paulina L. Alberto and others for their complementary approaches.
These reservations aside, this is a solidly researched and colourfully written study, and its broad geographical and thematic scope should appeal to a wide readership both within and beyond the confines of Afro- and Luso-Brazilian studies.
