JoEllen McNergney Vinyard is a professor of history at Eastern Michigan University, and her new book examines the succession of “extreme” right-wing political groups and their supporters that have appeared in Michigan during the twentieth century: the Ku Klux Klan in the 1920s, the followers of the “radio priest” Father Charles Coughlin in the 1930s, the anticommunist John Birch Society of the 1960s and 1970s, and the various militia groups that began to emerge in the 1990s. Perhaps the first question to ask, then, is whether the book will be of interest to those of us outside the Great Lake state. The answer is yes. Not only does Vinyard make it clear how the particularities of Michigan's story relate to the wider national story relentlessly unfolding during the periods she examines, she also emphasizes the essential ordinariness of the people who were attracted to these various movements – patriotic “citizens … who feared that their country was straying from its historical moorings as they understood them to be” (4).
The latter is an important point. As Vinyard shows, the tendency to dismiss, mock or ridicule the “aberrant” supporters of groups like the Klan or the Birchers is a common one, but it is also highly misleading. As she points out with respect to the Klan, for example, from “origin to withering” it was a movement
propelled by unexceptional Americans, albeit sometimes “solid citizens.” They were white, Protestant, and commonly American-born of American-born parents. Apart from that, there was no typical Klan supporter in Michigan. They came from all communities, all manner of occupations, and all levels of education. (95)
Vinyard utilizes much interesting and useful primary source material, including interviews with Birch and militia leaders, as she draws her more complex picture of the activities of these grassroots activists. One wishes, though, that she had immersed herself more deeply in the rich secondary literature that exists for each of the movements she considers. It is surprising, for example, that her account of Coughlin and his National Union of Social Justice makes no mention of Alan Brinkley's National Book Award-winning Voices of Protest: Huey Long, Father Coughlin and the Great Depression (1982), and similar omissions are also especially evident in her two chapters on the militia movement.
That all the groups Vinyard writes about are engaged in a long-standing argument about the nature of democracy and democratic governance in the United States is also something that is not pursued as fully as one might wish. Vinyard notes in her conclusion, for instance, that the “grand promises of American democracy trickle down slowly, unevenly, unfairly – too often deliberately so” (310), but this is not a theme that she pursues consistently in the pages preceding her insight. Overall, though, Right in Michigan's Grassroots is a book that should be of real interest to specialists both in the history of American political and social movements and in the history of Michigan, as well as to instructors looking to engage students in these subjects.
