Studies of oil and its influence on the Arabian Peninsula typically address Western readers' concerns with regime stability and prospects for continued productivity. Lacking skills in cultural analysis, analysts routinely emphasize vertiginous ascent from austere tribal fiefdoms to powerful rentier states awash in petro-dollars, titillating readers with portraits of a modern Arab world whose hypertrophied global status comes with a reassuring moral message: however much countries in the region are key trading partners and allies of the West, the sheer pace of their rise to power underscores an essential fragility, volatility, “otherness,” and fundamental need for intervention.
In light of such literature, Limbert's monograph In the Time of Oil: Piety, Memory, and Social Life in an Omani Town is a welcome and unusually patient study of the ways the pace of time for residents in one locale is mediated through durable strains of culture. Signaling the book's innovative approach, time is approached as a function less of Marxian labor value, though tensions over categories of “work” are recurrently touched upon in the book, than of stratified forms of identity. The distinctive Omani contours of this identity are explored in separate chapters on urban space, social visitation, religious learning, water distribution and use, and Arab ethnicity/race in the context of Oman's long diasporic ties with East Africa. Overall, the book's central argument builds from the author's interesting observation that for over four decades, experts in the business of oil production (both Omani and non-Omani) have repeatedly predicted that the country's oil reserves would be exhausted in “twenty years.” Given the anticipated termination of the country's lucrative natural resource, Omanis experience modernity, Limbert suggests, not as linear progress toward prosperity but as a suspension between periods of scarcity. Much of the value of the book lies in exploring how this sense of fleeting prosperity expresses an acutely modern condition that, while deeply Omani, also betrays more cross-cultural strains of global subjectivity.
After a brief introduction, Chapter 2 investigates the ways a sense of transitoriness and apprehension is evoked through nostalgia for place and traditional sociality in the rapidly developing urban space of the author's primary ethnographic setting: the town of Bahla in Oman's most historic interior region. The state-sponsored reconstruction of the town's historic fort looms figuratively throughout the chapter. In familiar ways, the fort's designation as a historical museum serves to institutionalize a deterritorialized and anachronic notion of folk culture that clashes with fort visitors’ own narratives about the fort's significance for local traditions of social authority. Generational conflict proves acute as younger visitors to the fort are deprived of the opportunity to appreciate the wisdom and social heritage of their elders. More fertile are inquiries into the gendered implications of generational tension, a topic recurrently addressed throughout the book. In the context of Chapter 2, modern roads and tumultuous city planning initiatives have in some ways empowered older generations of women by making social visitation and networking even more integral to the business of modern neighborly living. In other ways, however, modern state education appears to undermine such advances. Drilled in the urgency of developing “useful” skills for employment, national progress, and self-discipline, students learn to question the value of traditional socializing and its tendency toward “idle talk.”
Chapter 3 examines an ethics of leisure by attending to the ways notions of time and sociality are mediated by coffee and dates, two of Oman's most historic agricultural products. Coffee drinking is integral to the art of neighborly visitation and exchange; as a pleasurable ritual, it has also long been subject to moralizing discourse about stages of “intoxication,” indolence, and gossip. Helpful historical evidence and poetry are provided to convey the depth of such discourses and to show how memories of the past reflect present worldviews. Although coffee drinking can be dated to at least the 18th century, Omanis emphasize the scarcity of coffee in the past and the leisurely and somewhat morally opprobrious excess that coffee has enabled in the modern era. Their concerns are strikingly parallel to contemporary oil anxieties. Notes on the production, exchange, and consumption of dates and on appropriate verbal interchange complement these observations.
Although topics of piety and religious learning are touched upon throughout the book, Chapter 4 delves into them most explicitly. In keeping with current scholarship on piety movements in other Muslim societies, Limbert shows how the state's expansion of education to wider groups of citizens, women as well as men, does not necessarily result in the production of liberal secular subjects. On the one hand, female students and their teachers support formal schooling outside the home along with the use of modern instructional methods. Employment as a state educator offers women comparatively greater status and mobility than it does men. On the other hand, women who emerge from state schooling convey strong distrust toward state secularization and discourses of “women's freedom” so prominent in Western and “Egyptian” models of neoliberal subjectivity. With fine attention to classroom discourse and teacher-student exchange, Limbert excavates the political and generational tensions inherent in calls to retreat toward domestic spaces for private study and pious self-cultivation. The objectification of religion provides an overarching theme for this chapter. Evidence supporting the author's observations includes helpful insights into the ways Ibadism, Oman's distinctive school of Islam, is conceptualized through cultural memories of Islam's early North African expansions and contemporary retrospection on Ibadism's egalitarian ideals.
Chapters 5 and 6 address the ethics of bodily care and diasporic bodies and are geared to substantiate the book's arguments about piety. Although informant narratives are carefully intertwined and make for enjoyable reading, links with the thesis on piety could have been more thoroughly developed and theorized. Chapter 5 explores the ways in which new patterns of water distribution and ownership have exacerbated generational and status tensions underlying contending notions of Omani citizenship. Much is made of a younger girl's assertions that same-sex mixing at traditional baths is “forbidden” (ḥaram); further details of supporting religious discourse would have been welcome. Absent such details, moral authority seems to devolve to the state, arbiter of “development” and preserver of the country's natural bounty, rather than to more empowering traditions of knowledge and communal solidarity. Chapter 6 examines the legacies of diasporic exchange with Zanzibar and East Africa for various aspects of Omani identity, foremost among them Arab affiliations. Valuable insights are provided into the ways Arabness becomes racialized and masculinized along various junctures of migration. These observations are well integrated into the book's larger discussion of female agency, though their links to Oman's condition of suspended animation could have been better signposted. A final chapter offers a retrospective on principle themes in the book.
The index is generally helpful, although key indigenous Arabic terms (e.g., sabla, khadim), informants, and non-Western authorities (e.g., Sultan Qaboos, Yahya al-Manthari) are often absent. Overall, I recommend this book for those interested in learning more about contemporary Omani culture and struggles for identity, especially gender and youth, in an oil-producing nation–state.
