In 1965–66, in the wake of a still poorly understood coup attempt by military officers calling themselves the September 30th Movement, Indonesia saw the killing of an estimated 500,000 people labeled as “communists,” and the imprisonment of hundreds of thousands more, at the hands of the military and civilian organizations. Despite democratization in 1998, there has been limited progress in reforming the official history of the killings, bringing perpetrators to justice, or establishing mechanisms for reconciliation. There have, however, been recent signs of a shift in the public discourse around the killings. These two new volumes document the dynamic field of research around these events and will be useful not only to researchers and teachers of the killings in Indonesia, but also scholars interested in the dynamics of political violence and the role of history in political reconciliation.
The Contours of Mass Violence in Indonesia, 1965–68 is a ten-chapter edited collection that offers one of the most comprehensive pictures of Indonesia's mass killings since Robert Cribb's oft-cited collection, The Indonesian Killings of 1965–1966: Studies From Java and Bali (Clayton, Victoria: Centre of Southeast Asian Studies, Monash University, 1990). Kammen and McGregor's introduction sets the agenda for the volume and future studies of the killings. They argue that while much of the previous literature focuses either on the circumstances of the initial coup attempt, the attacks on the Indonesian Communist Party (Partai Komunis Indonesia—PKI), or the emergence of the New Order regime, scholars should instead view these events as a multi-phased counterrevolutionary process, in which the three years of violence beginning in October 1965 is considered a single attack on not only the Indonesian Communist Party but also the supporters of Sukarno and his Guided Democracy. They offer a four-phase periodization of the New Order counterrevolution, around which the book is organized, beginning with the events of September 30 and the subsequent massacre of PKI members and sympathizers by an anti-communist alliance of the army and religious groups, followed by the struggle between anti-communist actors over how the counterrevolution should proceed, Suharto's consolidation of power through the purging of Sukarno loyalists and sidelining of religious forces, and finally the long-term imprisonment of hundreds of thousands and the destruction of the last vestiges of the PKI organization.
Thanks to logical sequencing based on this framework and consistent quality across chapters, the compilation provides a surprisingly coherent historical narrative for an edited volume. Furthermore, each chapter is effective in providing an overview of its topic, while also contributing new research findings. For example, in chapter 4 Jenkins and Kammen succinctly chronicle the role of the Indonesian Army's elite para-commando regiment in organizing the purge of communist sympathizers and the training of anti-communist death-squads in Central Java, while their detailed study of troop movements reveals new insights regarding the role of the military in East Java and Bali.
An additional strength is the volume's attention to internal group dynamics. Broad histories of the period may speak of the Army, Islamic organizations, nationalists, or the PKI, but the volume's contributors take seriously internal dynamics and use these dynamics to explain outcomes. For instance, in chapter 5 Fealy and McGregor's exploration of the active role played by the Islamic organization Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) in the killings in East Java shows the importance of group dynamics, including the rise of militant anti-communists in NU, the anti-communist interests shared by NU and the military, and eventual tensions between NU and the military over goals and strategies. Other chapters consider other group dynamics, such as tensions within the anti-communist alliance regarding the goals of the purges (Tsai and Kammen, chapter 6), the confusion among PKI sympathizers over how to respond to the terror (Hearman, chapter 8), or the divided loyalties to Sukarno within the military (Jenkins and Kammen, chapter 4). This common thematic focus nuances our understandings of the killings and provides a sophisticated analysis of the era's defining social forces.
Truth Will Out: Indonesian Accounts of the 1965 Mass Violence, on the other hand, uses an oral history approach to studying the killings. While not the first collection of oral histories on the killings, it is one of the few translated for an English-reading audience. The volume is organized into three sections: five accounts from witnesses, nine accounts from survivors, and a short case study of the reaction of the Catholic Church in Yogyakarta to the violence. The accounts are the product of an oral history project conducted from 2008 to 2011, and the chapters are edited personal narratives based on direct interviews, handwritten accounts, written interviews, and other supplementary material.
The collection contains accounts from an impressive cross-section of Indonesian society, with informants from various class backgrounds, religions, and political affiliations, and narratives that effectively capture the spectrum of historical interpretation of events. While the focus is mass violence, the narratives present a much broader social portrait, describing the conditions in the years before the killings and the enduring effects of poverty and stigmatization for survivors.
The volume was originally intended for an Indonesian audience, and its editor, Baskara T. Wardaya, is careful to emphasize that the book does not adjudicate a “correct” history of events, but rather attempts to democratize history through the recognition of multiple narratives. Thus, the book is both an academic study based on oral history and an attempt to promote reconciliation by “open[ing] the space for dialogue so that there will also be space to learn together about the history of this nation” (p. xli). While some readers may feel the volume lacks sufficient contextual information and an interpretative framework, the book can be read simultaneously as a powerful documentation of historical memory and an example of contemporary attempts at social dialogue aimed at reconciliation.
Lacking in both volumes, with the exception of McGregor's chapter 10 in The Contours of Mass Violence in Indonesia, 1965–68, on the exhumation of mass graves, is much of an attempt to locate Indonesia's killings in a wider comparative or historical perspective. It is understandable, given the obstacles faced by researchers, including lack of documentation, years of state censorship, and lack of willing informants (The Contours of Mass Violence in Indonesia, 1965–68, p. 6), that scholarly attention is at this juncture focused on establishing the historical record within Indonesia. However, as our knowledge of the killings is enriched by the kind of quality historical research found in these two volumes, future works should look to use Indonesia's killings to draw historical lessons regarding the dynamics of political violence and mass killings more generally.
Like Cribb's aforementioned volume before it, The Contours of Mass Violence in Indonesia, 1965–68 will likely become a key reference on the killings, providing a picture of the killings that is approachable enough for use in teaching, while sufficiently detailed and original to move our knowledge of the killings forward. Truth Will Out: Indonesian Accounts of the 1965 Mass Violence, on the other hand, may be of use to educators as supplementary material, but will be of more interest to researchers as an invaluable source of firsthand accounts from a highly sensitive historical period.
