On Friday the 14th of May, BARNA met for their yearly conference, exhibition and general meeting in the vibrant city of Manchester. This year’s conference was dedicated to Florence Nightingale entitled ‘Illuminating the way’ and featured an excellent tribute by way of a closing speech by our own Pat Smedley. This was the first time that the conference had been held in Manchester, and our first visit to the North in 7 years. It was fantastic to see some new delegates there, who really were an enthusiastic bunch. The conference is always a friendly affair and everyone felt that this year was once again an excellent opportunity to network and learn, remembering that BARNA is the only UK Professional Association specialising exclusively in Anaesthetic and Recovery Nursing. This article will take a brief look at why Florence Nightingale took centre stage at this conference, as well as some of the sessions attended this year.
Florence Nightingale
12/5/1820–13/8/1910
Pat Smedley, Barna’s Education Lead and new President; led a fascinating and enthusiastic tribute to Florence Nightingale and the lesser-known achievements and periods of her life. I, for one, left feeling inspired to find out more about this individual and astonished at how much of her work is resonant today. This was no doubt helped by Pat Smedley who delivered her closing speech dressed in full period costume.
Florence Nightingale was a pioneer in the visual presentation of information. Among other things, she used the pie chart, which had first been developed by William Playfair in 1801. After the Crimean War, Nightingale used the polar area chart, equivalent to a modern circular histogram or ‘rose’ diagram, to illustrate seasonal sources of patient mortality in the military field hospital she managed. Nightingale called the compilation of such diagrams a ‘coxcomb’, but later that term has frequently been used to refer to individual diagrams. She made extensive use of coxcombs to present reports on the nature and magnitude of the conditions of medical care in the Crimean War to members of Parliament and civil servants who would have been unlikely to read or understand traditional statistical reports.
Terry Clifford, Immediate Past President of the American Society of Peri-Anesthesia Nurses; Pat Smedley; Barna Education Lead; and Manda Dunne, Barna Chair.
In her later life, Florence made a comprehensive statistical study of sanitation in Indian rural life and was the leading figure in the introduction of improved medical care and public health service in India. In 1858, she was elected the first female member of the Royal Statistical Society and later became an honorary member of the American Statistical Association.
Although better known for her contributions in the medical and mathematical fields, Florence is also an important link in the study of English Feminism. During 1850 and 1852, she was struggling with her self-definition and the expectations of an upper-class marriage from her family. As she sorted out her thoughts, she wrote Suggestions for Thought to Searchers after Religious Truth. The three-volume book has never been printed in its entirety, but a section, called Cassandra, was published by Ray Strachey in 1928. Strachey included it in The Cause, a history of the women’s movement. Apparently, the writing served the original purpose of ‘sorting’ thoughts; Nightingale left soon after to train at the Institute for Deaconesses at Kaiserwerth. Cassandra protests the over-feminisation of women into near helplessness, such as Nightingale saw in her mother and older sister’s lethargic lifestyle, despite their education. She rejected their life of thoughtless comfort for the world of social service. The work also reflects her fear of her ideas being ineffective, as were Cassandra’s. Cassandra is a virgin-priestess of Apollo who receives a divinely inspired prophecy, but her prophetic warnings go unheeded. Elaine Showalter called Nightingale’s writing ‘a major text of English feminism, a link between Wollstonecraft and Woolf’.
Opening the conference this year was keynote speaker Captain Philip Higton. Captain Higton has been a commercial pilot for 34 years with British Airways, and as part of Terema for the last 7 years has had extensive experience in transferring learning between his former and current worlds. He was instrumental in introducing ‘Lean’ techniques into the process of pilot conversion training within British Airways. He is Director of Training for Terma and has been responsible for the preparation and delivery of programmes for more than 7000 Healthcare professionals. Current projects include the challenge of maintaining patient safety while incorporating the latest advances in systems improvement. He also works with the National Clinical Assessment Service (NCAS) in the field of behavioural markers in clinical assessment with particular reference to ‘team working’ and contributes to several International studies where safety is the focus. Captain Higton talked of managing areas of the human condition: fatigue, misinterpretation and miscommunication. He reminded us that error is a normal part of the human condition and that trial and error is gene deep; it is how we learn. No one individual is perfect, but the art of recognising this and doing something about it is perfect.
Keynote speaker Captain Philip Higton.
Below are some of the abstracts of the lectures featured in this year’s conference. If you attended, I am sure you took home with you some new ideas; if you were unable to, then I hope these will inspire you to attend next year.
The Bispectral Index (BIS) is a processed EEG parameter with extensive validation that demonstrated clinical utility. It is based on a combination of measures derived from the EEG signal processing techniques, including bispectral analysis, power spectral analysis and time domain analysis. These measures were combined via an algorithm, not well known to the public, to optimise the correlation between the EEG and the clinical effects of anaesthesia, quantified by using the BIS. The BIS is a number between 0 and 100 scaled to correlate with important clinical end points and EEG states during administration of anaesthetic agents. BIS values near 100 represent an ‘awake’ clinical state, whereas 0 denotes an isoelectric EEG. Today, BIS remains the most reliable form of consciousness or brain function monitoring used in the clinical context of anaesthesia and sedation care.
In relation to the increased interest developed for the use of the BIS, we have attempted to use it as a guide to anaesthetic administration during endoscopic procedures. Thus, we have designed a study to validate the efficacy of BIS used by unsupervised nurses as a reliable index to attend the safe anaesthetic administration in patients undergoing colonoscopy. The purpose of this study is to prove the safety and efficacy of this index to allow nurses to provide anaesthesia in patients undergoing colonoscopy.
In this study, the 100 participant patients will be divided into 2 groups of 50: group A and group B. Group A will receive Midazolam in concentrations titrated to each patient and 0.05 mg of Fentanyl administered by the endoscopist. Group B will receive 1 mg Midazolam and 1 mg/kg Propofol administered at once by the nurse. For sedation maintenance purposes, Propofol will be provided at a constant rate through a pump in appropriate concentration to keep the Bispectral index value less than 70–75. Thirty-five cases have been studied for group A and 11 for group B so far. The study is expected to finish by the end of February. Preliminary results show that anaesthetic administration in patients undergoing colonoscopy with Propofol based on BIS provided by a nurse is considered to offer better sedation than administration of midazolam and Fentanyl provided by an endoscopist. No patient required mask ventilation or endotracheal intubation. Preliminary studies show less recovery time and return to baseline function in patient group B than in group A, enhancing the usefulness of the BIS in clinical practice. However, more reliable results will be shown after completing this study and presenting its statistical analysis.
Friends from Greece; from left to right; Markku Viherlaiho; Barna Treasurer with Evangelous Konstantinou and Maria Bastaki.
Cell salvage is regularly used in vascular and orthopaedic surgery; there are clear advantages to its use compared to allogenic transfusions: reduction in transfusion-related infections and reactions; helpful with cross-matching difficulties, as well as being an acceptable option for people who decline blood products. There were, however, initial safety concerns related to reinfusing blood containing amniotic fluid, foetal red cells, risk of amniotic fluid, embolism and haemolytic disease in future pregnancies. National Institute for Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidance published in 2005 has established that it is safe to use cell salvage in obstetrics. At Worthing Hospital, cell salvage is regularly and effectively used in obstetrics. The process of setting this up has involved changing practice, education and training of all staff working in maternity and an ongoing commitment to reducing the morbidity from major obstetric haemorrhage.
This year’s conference also saw the handing over of the Barna Chair from Manda Dunne to Natalie Quine. We thank Manda for all of her amazing work and offer Natalie the best of luck in her new role. We also say goodbye to Barna secretary Gaye Ward and wish her well in the future and thank her for her years of service to Barna also. Pauline Guyan; BSc (Hons) Nursing Practice, Dip He, RN, SEN takes over this role. She qualified in 1979 in Sheffield as an SEN and converted to RN in 2000. In 2008, she gained a degree at the University of York and recently has undertaken the role of Senior Sister in PACU at York Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, enjoying the challenges this role offers. She has for a number of years admired the work that the BARNA Committee (past and present) offers to support the PACU and Anaesthetic staff and hopes that now she will be able to give something back. We also welcome Vanessa Hunt as our new conference planner.
Manda Dunne hands over the ‘Chair’ to Natalie Quine.
2010 Conference Photo Library
