Infrastructures of knowledge may be as hard to remodel as any physical infrastructure inherited from past centuries; indeed, the analytical categories through which we structure the past are usually less remarked – and all the more insidious for that. Yet nothing less is the ambition of this first-rate volume. Self-consciously both polemic and exemplar, it stems from a workshop in Amsterdam in 2004, at which participants were directed to avoid the anachronisms ‘science’ and ‘technology’ and to suspend assumptions about the distinctiveness of natural philosophers' and artisans' ways of working. Their papers were to focus on ‘specific historical sites where inquiry and invention coalesced with productive results’, with a view to ‘recovering the hybrid activities involved in the intimately related processes of material and knowledge production’ (p. xvi). The outcome is a cogent set of uniformly distinguished, original pieces of research that range across sites, centuries and types of activity but bond into a bigger picture. If it is more futuristic collage than romantic landscape, then that is entirely appropriate. For the editors emphasize the multiplicity and variety of locations through which knowledge circulates and mutates, and the shifting networks of actors that embrace or dispute, tinker with, expand, transform and communicate it. Indeed, as much as the novel agenda, it is the focus on actors and activities that breathes life into these essays. Some are familiar but viewed here from new perspectives; most are strangers, normally obscured by the long shadows of heroic history – none more so than Jim Bennett's unlucky subjects, whose evening stroll through London in search of an experimental brass tube ended in the dock of the Old Bailey on a charge of high treason, their misadventure now illuminating hidden facets of the design and modification of scientific instruments.
There are fifteen essays arranged in four roughly chronological sections, introduced alternately by Lissa Roberts or Simon Schaffer; the whole is complemented by reflective epilogues from Peter Dear and Ian Inkster. The first section explores most intently the ‘complicity between contemplation and manipulation’ (p. ix). Pamela H. Smith's chapter on Wenzel Jamnitzer (1508–85), master goldsmith of Nuremberg, intrudes uniquely here into an artisan's workshop in search of the active knowledge embodied in his craft. Even by goldsmiths' standards, Jamnitzer left exceptionally rich documentary evidence from which Smith constructs his wide range of ‘simultaneously productive and investigative’ activities (p. 56). Mary Henninger-Voss transports us to the library of Galileo's patron, Paduan humanist Gian Vicenzo Pinelli, where elite circles of readers and correspondents intermingled in search of technical and philosophical understanding. She explores what actually doing philosophy meant for them, as Galileo deployed his ballistic investigations to explicate the motion of objects while simultaneously educating them in effective practices of reading and judging experiments. Similarly, Fokko Jan Dijksterhuis investigates what it meant to actually do dioptrics in the mid-seventeenth century. Observing Descartes, Huygens and Hartsoeker in pursuit of the perfect lens (one free of spherical aberration), he reconfigures mathematics as heterogeneous: no single, bounded field existed, he suggests, but ‘a motley crew’ engaged in a ferment of intersecting activities that drew on a range of knowledge, skills and expertise. Resonant with this early modern section is Ursula Klein's chapter on eighteenth-century German chemistry and pharmacy, where she disputes the habitual separation of their practice and culture. Apothecary–chemists, she argues, were not required to cease producing remedies to gain credence as investigators of nature; university professors of chemistry also offered courses in pharmacy. Crucial to this overlap was the close correspondence between their laboratories, instruments and techniques.
Nearly all the remaining essays are located outdoors (maps are helpfully provided), and deal in conflicts of knowledge more than collaboration and constructive hybrids. Four elucidate major feats of water management: Katherine Rinne on the rebuilding of Rome's aqueducts, Eric Ash and Alette Fleischer on draining the English fens and Holland's Beemster Polder respectively, Chandra Mukerjii on constructing the Canal du Midi. Collectively they show that these advances in engineering enterprise required only ‘conservative invention’ (in Fleischer's words) to resolve a gamut of technical difficulties, but hosted ferocious battles over the nature of expertise, rival property rights, and humanity's relation to the natural world.
Nowhere do such battles rage more graphically than in Schaffer's analysis of Georgian Britain's naval dockyards. As shipwrights fought to maintain the ‘cunning intelligence’ of their craft against the geometrical principles promoted by the Navy Board's surveyors, not only were they defending their skilled status (with its traditional perks) and the independence of their mould lofts from official control, but they were also contesting the very meaning of ‘reason’, ‘theory’ and ‘experiment’: historians miss the point if they treat such terms as apolitical and unproblematic. An equally combative and resilient craft was that of the printers. Yet, as Adrian Johns demonstrates, Charles Babbage's pursuit of accuracy through mechanization fell foul not of their intransigence but of the technical limitations of stereotyping and the power of copyright-wielding publishers' cartels; ‘the steady, progressive application of a skill’ (p. 427) remained indispensible.
Roberts and Simon Werrett both enhance our understanding of well-known innovations by displaying them in unfamiliar surroundings. Roberts maps steam pumps onto Dutch landscapes, where in contrasting sites – far removed from British mines and industry – she explicates a different symbolism, and canvasses ‘geographies of skill’ as more pertinent than David Livingstone's ‘geographies of scientific knowledge’. Werrett wrenches gas lighting from its dull industrial foundations and gives it a very eighteenth-century pedigree in the spectacular pyrotechnics of Anglo-French pleasure gardens and theatres. This shift illuminates how the rhetorical construction of sober British inventors, such as William Murdoch – as distinct from dangerous (usually foreign!) showmen/projectors – has helped establish the Whig history of the Industrial Revolution. Now subject to multiple revisionist challenges that are implicit in several essays here, this British myth is explicitly found wanting in William Ashworth's essay on Hanoverian economic policies and Leonard Rosenband's study of eighteenth-century papermaking, as well as Inkster's epilogue. Industrialization is seen to be misconstrued as ‘our island story’: from pan-European roots it exploded into a global phenomenon. Nor, with the strong-armed British state squarely in the frame, does economic liberalism garner the plaudits it once did: sceptics are referred to Ashworth's demonstration of the Excise's intrusive control over Britain's manufactures. As with Bennett's imaginative use of court archives, Ashworth mines historical riches from the Excise's strict record-keeping practices.
Few volumes of collected essays are as mindfully edited or as beautifully produced as this one; few works leave one feeling as optimistic about the future of one's field, be it economic history or the history of science and technology. The disintegration of grand narratives releases a myriad of new research questions; these essays demonstrate the value of not allowing them to be prematurely replaced by other linear formulations.
