In this book, Benn Ross Schneider provides us with an innovative and path-breaking approach to understand Latin American contemporary capitalism. Instead of explaining the social and economic problems of the region (namely, atomistic and precarious labour relations, low levels of education and skill investments, dependence on commodity exports, low levels of R&D and technological innovation, poverty and inequality) as a product of its, supposedly, not yet consolidated economic structure (i.e. still ‘developing’), the author proposes an alternative hypothesis: those problems are the endogenous consequence of the consolidation of a distinctive kind of economic regime with its own reinforcing dynamics, what the author defines as ‘Hierarchical Capitalism’.
Applying the theoretical toolbox of the Varieties of Capitalism approach (VoC) to the context of Latin America, the author proposes that, in order to comprehend a specific type of capitalism, it is necessary to detect the particular institutional ties that link the allocation of resources among economic units (e.g. flow of money, goods, and capital) and its specific ‘institutional complementarities’ (i.e. the process through which the consolidation of an economic institution increases the strength of another) that generate a path-dependent economic dynamic with its own competitive advantages. Depending on the type of capitalism, the complementarities can result in positive or negative outcomes that are reinforced through time.
What are, according to the author, the main characteristics of the Latin American Hierarchical Capitalism? The starting point lies on the attributes of the capitalist firm. In Latin America, the multinational corporation (MNCs) and the business groups are the central economic units (determining the levels of exports, investment, R&D and productivity of the region), and their interactions have reinforced segmented labour markets and low levels of education and skill formation.
Presenting an impressive amount of evidence, the text suggests that business groups in the region are characterised by hierarchical and diversified family-owned structures with a vast market power (oligopolistic control). This reinforces the power of the business vis-à-vis labour resulting in an atomised labour market. At the same time, multinational corporations’ advantage for manufacture and tradable sectors increases the incentives for business groups to invest in commodity and non-tradable sectors. Thus, the specialisation of business groups in those sectors increases demand for low-skill labour (and, in a cumulative causation mechanism, the lack of supply of high-skill labour, decreases even more the incentives for businesses to invest in high-technology).
Thus, the author suggests, a perverse complementarity emerges between business groups, atomised labour market and low level of investment in skill formation and education.
In relation to the effects of MNCs on the development prospects of the region, the author presents an interesting critical perspective. What are the impacts of the MNEs, not only on the direct demand for labour, but on the business groups’ decisions and labour market composition? For the author, the effects have reinforced the previous perverse complementarities through three basic mechanisms: first, MNCs have inserted local business into non-dynamic sectors within the global value chain hierarchies, demanding low-skill labour and reinforcing atomised labour markets. Second, the FDIs have produced a ‘crowding-out’ effect to the national business, displacing them to low-technology sectors. Last, FDIs have not been sources of dynamism since the technological transfer, R&D investment and demand for high-skill labour are still very low.
The result is that the MNCs, business groups, low-skill levels of labour and atomised labour market reinforce each other in a cumulative causation way, inserting Latin America into a low-skill trap where the competitive advantages of the region lie in commodity exports and low-skill economic sectors.
The approach proposed by the author is radical in its political implications: the way to overcome the low-skill trap lies not in mere growth or liberalisation (as many IOs have traditionally suggested), since that will not challenge any of the given institutional complementarities but will just reproduce them. Also, the solution goes beyond the traditional demand from the Left of income distribution, and calls for ‘bringing production back in’ by putting into question the hidden premise shared by both Right and most of the Left in contemporary Latin America: that business decisions are the most rational and efficient actors for increasing the productive capacities of countries.
Despite the challenging perspective of the author, it is possible to detect some blind spots from the book that deserve to be made explicit.
His proposal to understand Latin America not as ‘developing’ but as a consolidated specific type of capitalism is something that has already been the distinctive point of Anglo-Saxon Developmentalism (Hirschman, Nurkse), Latin American Structuralism (Prebisch, Furtado), Dependency Theory (Gunder Frank, Faletto and Cardoso) and some key post-Keynesian economists (Kaldor, Kalecki). One common point among the previous approaches (particularly the last three) is their capacity to link the economic-traps of peripheral countries with their social and political structures. Their centrality on class action and political hegemony permits them to connect economic outcomes with political projects in a way that reflects the rich tradition of political economy. That perspective is missing in the author's approach: it can grasp the internal dynamics (and tensions) of contemporary Latin American capitalism, but is less suited to comprehend the inner political economy (its lack of an analysis of the state is a clear symptom). It is important to emphasise that this has been a common critique of the general Varieties of Capitalism approach.
At the same time, the causes of the low-skill trap are not only national, but also international, a point also absent in the book, and which is central for the previous perspectives. First, economic complementarities are not only within national economic regimes, but also among them. This is exactly what structuralism defined as centre-periphery relations is: the exports of manufactures from the centre were complementary to the exports of commodities from the periphery (reinforcing underdevelopment and the structural heterogeneity of the peripheral regions). That pattern is nowadays more evident in the region after the commodity boom of the 2000s.
Second, the contemporary international institutional economic architecture has increasingly put pressure to reduce the policy space for countries to use industrial policies that can break the low-skill trap. The hegemony of the capitalist centres is expressed not only economically (EMNs) but also in the international institutional building. Thus, the fight for development also acquires an international character.
In synthesis, the book is a good antidote to a common perspective on development studies that focuses exclusively on local issues, specific problems and ready-made solutions, and calls for subjecting again capitalism and business to academic scrutiny.
