Beauty, Virtue, Power, and Success in Venezuela 1850–2015 takes on an important and under-researched theme, both within studies of Venezuela and Latin American gender studies. This book, though, requires more evidence to illustrate the comparative importance of female beauty and body aesthetics in Venezuela vis-à-vis other countries. More importantly, instead of historical research, the book uses theories from cultural and postcolonial studies and ideas from psychology and evolutionary biology to interpret largely biographical sources drawn from literature and the media. It relies on the ideas of two thinkers – the ‘evolutionary psychologist’ Nancy Etcoff and cultural theorist/philosopher Pierre Bourdieu – to frame the analysis. However, only one reference for each is found in the bibliography and the result of privileging cultural and postcolonial theory over historical method is a largely ahistorical and delocalised perspective. Furthermore, the structure of the book – put together as a series of separate essays (in which the period 1950–80 is not specifically covered) – works against the development of a concise historical argument. The book does make some potentially insightful connections to Venezuela's modern history, politics and relations of gender, class, race and national identity (for example, universal suffrage was first granted in Venezuela in a beauty contest of 1944 – a year before the Trienio of 1945–8 briefly initiated democratic politics). It also has some very good and original analysis of the literary works of a number of Venezuelan women writers of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. However, overall the book fails to provide a coherent historical analysis of the specific social, political, cultural and environmental processes of modernisation in Venezuela that have resulted in body aesthetics and cosmetic appearance having such weight in social status and national identity.
The author asserts that the ‘same basic configuration of appearance, power and moral worth has not changed substantially in the past two hundred years’ (p. 2). However, the analysis fails to convincingly trace continuity between colonial and postcolonial Venezuela, as no clear definition or understanding of these periods emerges. For example, in Part I (1850–90), beauty contests are labelled as a ‘modern’ phenomenon (the first recorded one being in 1905, although their heyday was after 1950 as the oil economy boomed), but their rationale is said to derive from colonial ideas of honour in which women's beauty ‘served as a symbol of lineage, family wealth, self-control and personal moral worth’ (p. 13). Similarly, colonial standards of Euro-descended beauty and cloistered decency are linked to public health and eugenicist thought in the context of nineteenth-century nation-building, but without analysing the development of the relationship or clearly defining concepts or periods. When and how (and to what extent) did nineteenth-century scientific and medical approaches to health and body management merge with Spanish colonial (i.e. pre-1820s) ones (if indeed they did), and why did it happen the way it did in Venezuela?
The literary and cultural analysis of the writings of Mercedes Mutis de Ibarra in Chapter 2 is insightful, although she is largely portrayed as a passive and isolated figure: her relation to wider culture and society and the way in which she also actively propagated cultural and gender norms though her writing and life require greater exploration.
Part II on the period 1910–50 begins to link social change to shifting understandings of beauty, wealth, success, moral worth and racial purity during the modernising dictatorship of Juan Vicente Gómez (1908–36), but the relationship is not explained in any depth. Did modernisation change anything? Or not? The argument is not clear. The chapter, ostensibly about the twentieth century, returns unwittingly to the nineteenth, and draws evidence from nineteenth-century British imperialism to explain the objectification and sexualisation of black women's bodies in Venezuela. Surely, Venezuela's status as a slave society from the sixteenth to the mid-nineteenth centuries is more relevant for understanding racial and gender stereotyping in Venezuela than is British imperial policy in Africa. The use of theory and decontextualised secondary sources rather than primary historical research results in an ahistorical approach to race, gender and imperialism that does not sufficiently describe or explain the Venezuelan case.
Chapters 5 and 6 contain well-written literary criticism of the authors Teresa de la Parra (1889–1936) and Antonia Palacios (1904–2001). Their works are located in broader historical trends, although greater analysis and more accurate periodisation would strengthen the chapters. Overall, though, women tend to be portrayed as passive victims of colonial attitudes, scientific and medical approaches, and twentieth-century gendered modernisation. The role played by women in maintaining and possibly resisting the status quo is glimpsed in a few places, but needs greater analysis. The narrative tends to treat women as objects rather than active participants in society, replicating perspectives that it implicitly criticises.
Part III begins with a chapter describing beauty pageants and contests and the industry surrounding them, then goes on to look at the career of perhaps Venezuela's most iconic Miss Universe, Irene Sáez. Part IV, examining the period 2000–15, looks at beauty manuals, the media, plastic surgery and the career of supermodel Patricia Velásquez to highlight the paradoxes of beauty as a measure of status, wealth and moral value in twenty-first-century ‘socialist’ Venezuela. There is some interesting information and relevant ideas, but clearer historical and social analysis is needed to explain the prevalence and significance of beauty pageants in Venezuela. It would seem that their popularity, propagation of Euro-centred beauty norms and reflection of meritocratic values – the importance of hard work as opposed to lineage or genes – are related to the growth of the oil economy – particularly the boom of the 1970s – the development of consumerism in a rentier economy, high rates of European migration in the 1950s and 1960s, and the populist ‘Punto Fijo’ democracy established in 1958. The relationships between these factors and/or the allegedly ongoing importance of the colonial values of honour, lineage and elite status need greater analysis, though, for a clear argument to emerge.
