Henry Louis Taylor's conclusions summarise this book's main weakness: scholars who fail to recognise their own biases too often blind Cuban studies ideologically. His finding comes after a difficult read, both stylistically and methodologically, about what life is really like in Havana's neighbourhoods. From its slapdash use of the Spanish language and questionable research design to its uncritical analysis of top-down policies and statements by Cuban leaders, the book fails to deliver the real scoop on daily life in the capital city.
The prologue and preface are confusing. Much of the methodology is described in these sections, and there is considerable overlap. We are told there that the author used geographic information system (GIS) analysis, but he fails to discuss it. The few maps in the book are poorly drawn and without a scale, and one aerial photograph with a superimposed arrow is difficult to decipher. We are told that digital photoanalysis was ‘carried out in a systematic fashion’ and ‘a content analysis was made of all photos and videos’ (p. 5), but these methods and findings are never presented in any way that this reviewer could figure out.
An ‘internationally known scholar’ (p. 217) who apparently gains insight about inner-city life by staying often with US overseas study groups in the Convento de Santa Clara in Old Havana, Professor Taylor apparently fails to recognise that his guesthouse's very own air-conditioned rooms, sunshine-bathed courtyards and hot-water showers set him apart from his subjects who live in Old Havana and elsewhere in the island's capital. Moreover, his ‘frank conversations’ with ‘friends [who became his] cultural guides through the intricacies, complexities and contradictions of Cuban society’ (p. xii) evidently balanced his field research context. His ethnographic entry was allegedly enhanced because he was ‘treated as an amigo, rather than a turista’ (p. xii) and, because he could ‘pass as a Cuban, my friends could take me anywhere, as long as I spoke minimally’. What develops over five short chapters is surely what his friends, sympathetic to the revolution, wanted their American friend to see, despite the so-called data triangulation that Taylor employs. This is not skilful urban ethnography, and here is why.
Noun-verb disagreements (data treated as datum), extensive passive voice, sweeping generalisations without references, a subject index that did not include the handful of pages I cross-checked, poor-quality maps, mislabelled graph axes (for example, Table 4.1, which is a graph, not a table), Spanish words sometimes italicised and other times not, lead to inconsistency. Misspellings raise serious questions about the author's ability to gain an accurate take on daily life, or the publisher's efforts to have the book properly copy edited. Examples include ‘jinitere’ (jinetera), ‘Santerián’ (santería), ‘Cojimer’ (Cojímar), ‘republic’ (república, p. 16), ‘todas’ (todos, p. 16) ‘Comites de [para] la Defensa de la Revolución’ (p. 80, though appears correctly on p. 56), ‘almendrone’ (almendrón), ‘[la] vida no es fácil’, and ‘Compeche’ (Campeche).
These linguistic snafus pale in comparison to the simplistic use of a dualist framework that Taylor uses to interpret the island's political and economic history. He relies excessively on a clases económicas versus clases populares dichotomy to describe the inherent tension in governance throughout Cuba's history. This perspective is thin as a conceptual scaffold and provides a cursory classificatory scheme. Moreover, the use of the term rebeldes throughout the book is meant to describe the socialist leadership in the 1950s and 1960s, as well as the Cuban leadership in the new millennium, but no one today refers to the island's leadership as the rebeldes, and the use of the term is both anachronistic and somewhat annoying. The so-called ‘social functional model of neighborhood development’ (pp. 151–65) gets much praise for explaining barrio cohesion, but there is no frank discussion about people nominally volunteering for local organisations just to appease authorities, nor is there any mention of the state-security functions that many mass – and neighbourhood – organisations assume. If social cohesion is the result of the Cuban leadership's social functional model, then why are neighbourhood watch organisations needed and praised (p. 83)? Why are police the highest-paid employees on the island? Any thoughts on why at least three sets of glasses from the bronze statue of John Lennon in Vedado have been stolen, despite round-the-clock watchpersons? The ironies of grassroots control and human agency in everyday life are confounded.
When interesting survey findings are revealed (for example, 47 per cent of respondents believed that they would get faster service in the medical clinic if they could pay for their visit), the matter is not pursued further. The entire discussion of survey findings is presented in percentages, but there is no metric against which such (descriptive) statistics can be interpreted, or of whether non-parametric measures (chi-square, student t-test) reveal significant differences. In describing the economic crisis of the 1990s, Taylor tells us that ‘as the crisis deepened, the regime increased its reliance on the resiliency, initiative, and creativity of the popular classes’ (p. 70). Most Cubans and Cubanologists would argue otherwise; the state clamped down on and weakened civil society in order to avoid regime collapse.
The survey of 249 interviews conducted in Habana Vieja, Habana del Este and Centro Habana is the most problematic aspect of the book. No sampling frame is identified, and we are told that Cuban student interviewers who were committed to the project were allowed to participate. I believe few Cuban students would walk away from a chance to earn extra income, but we never see a copy of the original or translated survey instrument, we cannot study the GIS data points on the location of the respondents, and we do not understand fully who selected the survey team or whether they were remunerated for their efforts. Survey findings presented are not always clear. For example, the discussion of parents and school uses terms like ‘often’, ‘frequently’, ‘a great deal’ and ‘sometimes’; these are not conventional Likert-scale ranges, and one gets no sense of ordinal ranking.
Comparisons of Havana's neighbourhoods are mixed and matched in ways that befuddle. Vedado (p. 73) is included as a high-density neighbourhood, and although there is a lack of green space in Centro Habana and Habana Vieja, Taylor includes Vedado in this category (p. 74). While there is a discussion of the key roles that the neighbourhood physicians or the state-run ration distribution grocer (bodega) play in the lives of Cubans, little is said about the absence of basic prescription drugs or the bare shelves in the stores. To his credit, the author admits that the monthly household food rations expire after two or three weeks. The question of what fills that gap, however – theft from state stores or the black market, illegal and potentially counter-revolutionary – is only superficially explored. The long lines, the need to send family members out to scout for food or household goods or medicines; none of these survival considerations get the serious attention they warrant as part of what makes every barrio tick.
Value judgments and sweeping generalisations in the book are too numerous to count. For instance, ‘Cuba is not now, nor will be in the foreseeable future, a consumer based society’ (p. 147); ‘self-employment flourished [in the mid-1990s]’, yet no data are presented (most analysts say that it never surpassed 2 per cent of the economically active labour force); ‘[the rebeldes] sought to create an interactive top-down and bottom-up approach to neighborhood development based on a combination of centralized and decentralized decision making’ (p. 75); ‘most neighborhoods [have] residents who have the skills and abilities to drive the community development process’ (p. 78); and ‘How did Cuba, one of the poorest countries in Latin America, outperform its peers … ?’ (p. 89). All of these need full references and much explanation lest they be taken as ‘fact’.
Taylor blames the rising consumer culture for social discontent in Cuba, exacerbated by exposure to a contaminating tourism trade. Perhaps – yet the conceptual divide made in Table 4.3 between household/personal needs and wants begs the question of who determines what is needed and what is wanted. It appears that the author (and the socialist leadership) know which is which. For example, is a woman's search for sanitary towels (versus the use of homemade rags) on the black market, or a household's purchase of toilet tissue (versus newspaper) from a state store or black marketeer, a need or a want? Who decides? Taylor believes that the state ration book (libreta) can do so equitably. Survey results reveal an ‘availability of dollars [that] allowed certain households to attend to their wants rather than just their dietary needs’ (p. 137). The real tension in these matters is between material and moral incentives, the Achilles' heel of the revolution, but this is not explored except for a passing reference to Che's ‘new person’. Taylor challenges the rise of the so-called ‘outlaw culture’ in which Cubans venture into the illegal market to procure goods and services. His view is that ‘in an ironic sense, the tolerance of a certain level of “illegal” activities allows the government to maintain its revolutionary philosophy while simultaneously making it possible for habaneros to use their inventiveness to get by’ (p. 143). Consequently, ‘Cuba has evolved from a needs-based to a want-based society’ (p. 145). In cavalier fashion, then, the entire lack of a functioning retail market to solve the simplest of household needs (personal hygiene items and food staples, not brand-name consumer durables), and the huge role that the black market plays, are dismissed as marginal activities.
This is not the functioning of the Havana barrio as I or many other scholars know it, and I suspect the majority of the city's 2.2 million residents would concur. To dismiss the structural problems of the island does the reader a great disservice. It pains me to conclude that neither the casual traveller nor the university classroom will find much value in these pages.
