Alberto Vergara is the latest of a number of Peruvian scholars who, in recent years, have published comparative work between their own country and neighbouring Bolivia. His work follows in the footsteps of Ursula Durand's book on social movements (specifically cocaleros) in the two countries and Maritza Paredes’ comparative work on resource extraction.
Vergara's is an ambitious project, involving as it does creating a comparative framework that seeks to explain the divergences in the two countries’ political development over a period of more than half a century. The lens through which he chooses to view these divergences (or cleavages) is territoriality, or the relationship between the authority of central government and the challenges of regionalism. This is the danza hostil to which the book's title refers. In adopting territoriality as the organising principle, Vergara downplays other forms of analysis – important in the literature on cleavages in the other two countries – of class and ethnicity. He quotes Stein Rokkan (p. 81) in saying ‘you cannot study power and conflict without considering territory’.
Vergara lays out his stall in the first chapter which takes up almost a third of the book. Taking Santa Cruz in Bolivia and the Peruvian ‘south’ as his examples of periphery, he looks at the varying fortunes of their relationship with central government in the two countries, arguing that they move in opposite directions over time. In the case of Bolivia, Santa Cruz only became a powerful challenger to the authority of La Paz in more recent times; up until the 1960s at least it was poorly integrated into the political or economic life of the country. In that of Peru, the ‘south’ – and in particular the main urban centres like Arequipa and Cuzco – move in the opposite direction; having been able to challenge the authority of governments (indeed to topple them) up until the 1960s, the ‘south’ subsequently became increasingly impotent.
The analysis rests on the power of elites to dominate politics and set the political agenda in the ‘periphery’. Here, Vergara takes a fairly wide interpretation of what he means by ‘elites’. He identifies three types of elite: the oligarchic elites that were largely displaced as key actors in the two countries’ politics (in the case of Bolivia by the 1952 revolution and in that of Peru by the more democratic governments that followed the ousting of General Odría in 1956); the anti-oligarchic elites (such as the Movimiento Nacionalista Revolucionario (MNR) in Bolivia and Acción Popular (AP) in Peru); and finally what he terms the ‘marginal-peripheric elite’ that emerges from the 1960s onwards from the spread of university education in peripheral areas, of which Sendero Luminoso is a manifestation in Peru as is the growth of ‘indigenista’ politics assocated with katarismo in Bolivia.
The ability of regions to stand up against central authority, Vergara posits, has to do with two key factors: their demographic weight as centres of population and their command over natural resources and the ability to market these internationally independently of the capital. The growing demographic weight of Lima, and its emergence as commercial and industrial hub, is clear in the case of Peru, as its role in the commercialisation of minerals and other export commodities. By contrast, cities like Arequipa and Cusco, have seen their role decline proportionately. The rise of Santa Cruz both demographically and commercially is also very clear in the Bolivian case. Its growing defiance of the government in La Paz has gone pari passu with its own economic development as the centre of the country's main source of food and its role as the effective centre of its burgeoning hydrocarbons industry.
The following two chapters trace in greater detail how this framework fits with the political history of the two countries over this lengthy period. The first of these deals with the 1950s and 1960s: in the case of Bolivia from the 1952 revolution up until the coup against Víctor Paz Estenssoro in 1964, and in that of Peru the period between the end of the Odría dictatorship up until the coup by General Juan Velasco. This is a period in which Arequipa and the Peruvian ‘south’ holds its own against the ‘Centre’, particularly the ‘southern’ government of Fernando Belaúnde (1963–68). The second, takes on the story into the two countries’ experience of military rule: in the case of Bolivia, basically the governments of Generals René Barrientos (1964–68) and Hugo Banzer Suárez (1971–78); in that of Peru that of General Velasco (1968–75). It is here that the divergence between the two becomes most marked in the extent to which elites permeate periods of military rule. In the case of Bolivia, the Banzer dictatorship coincided with (and actively promoted) the economic development of Santa Cruz, the region from which Banzer himself hailed. In Peru, the Velasco government reinforced the supremacy of centralised government at the expense of regional elites.
The divergence between the two countries becomes even clearer in the 1990s, Vergara argues, with Bolivia seeing the emergence of new social forces which constrain and finally impose themselves on the state, and in Peru the opposite, a central state that imposes itself on a peripheral society that lacks capacity of response. Vergara's ‘marginal-peripheric elites’ end up at the receiving end of militarisation in Peru, but win the day in the case of Bolivia. And the regional new elites adopt their own agenda in Bolivia with the autonomista movements, whereas no such divergence appears in Peru where the powerful elites associated with extractive industries coalesce and drive the policies of the central state.
The framework and periodisation adopted in this book is helpful in trying to make sense of two very different historical processes. Indeed, the very comparison between the two cases helps us re-examine some of our suppositions about the recent history of both countries. This is most welcome. However, at times, Vergara's thesis ends up forcing the historical narrative into historical boxes that run the risk of distorting the record. There are continuities between the periods that tend to get overlooked; for instance between the period of MNR rule in Bolivia after the immediate revolutionary aftermath and the subsequent military period. The adoption of a territorial perspective tends to lead to downplaying political conflict and cleavage within territories, whether social, ethnic or a combination of the two. Furthermore, the concept of elites used here is arguably overly broad. It focuses more on political than economic elites and therefore fails to distinguish between them when their interests sometimes diverge (as is arguably the case in Bolivia since Morales’ showdown with the autonomistas in Santa Cruz in 2008). There is also not much consideration of the huge increase in the power of economic elites (especially extractive ones) in Peru since the privatisation and deregulation of the 1990s and how this influences state policy. Finally, it is a shame that, despite the dates included in the title of the book, there is no chapter that offers a comparison of the very different political trajectories of the two countries since 2000. These would seem to confirm rather than negate Vergara's thesis.
Whatever the criticisms that can be levelled at Vergara's methods and findings, this is certainly an important book, one which will stand as a marker in the literature. Hopefully it will stimulate more by way of informed, historically-driven comparative analysis between two countries which, despite some obvious similarities, exhibit such divergent patterns of state-society relations.
