Quash identifies resources in the works of von Balthasar, Hegel and Barth which would enable his readers to think and communicate about history theologically. According to von Balthasar, whom Quash follows on this point, most Christian theologians have either ignored history in self-absorbed ‘lyric’ celebrations of God's love or forced history's messiness and unpredictability into shopworn ‘epic’ explanatory frames they supposed consistent with God's providential plans. In contrast to both, von Balthasar and Quash promote ‘theodramatic’ interpretations of particular events that, enabled by the Holy Spirit, seek God within profound suffering rather than avoiding or domesticating it (p. 201). Although Quash succeeds admirably in highlighting the importance of Christians viewing history theodramatically, he is less persuasive when asserting that von Balthasar consistently ignored his own recommendations, succumbing to the temptations of a comfortable, epic vision.
After a deft introduction which enumerates some of the benefits to theology of a theodramatic approach to understanding history, the argument proceeds briskly through six chapters. The first defends an insight basic to the book: a theologian's interpretative tools must be suited to life's complexities, social dimension, existential pathos and irreducible particularity. On the basis of an analysis of Aeschylus’ Agamemnon and Euripides’ Medea, as well as a survey of Hegel's Aesthetics and von Balthasar's theological transposition of its basic themes, Quash contends that drama is preferable to lyric's retreat into ‘immediate feeling and individual association’ or epic's ‘unruffled perspective on the objectively given’ (p. 50). Chapter 2 concentrates on Hegel's construal of personal freedom in relation to the state in order to argue that von Balthasar's theologies of mission and of the church share the same ‘paradigm’ of a freedom ordered to obedience (p. 70). The similarity hinges on their advocating in the face of social disintegration the cultivation of indifference, which they understood, along with Ignatius, as humble readiness to serve others. The chapter concludes by demonstrating that ‘the powerful drive towards teleological patterning for which Hegel is notorious’ (p. 82) subverts his theory of drama, reducing the individual to a function of her environment. This raises fears that von Balthasar's theodramatics, which Quash believes is ‘massively’ influenced by Hegel, is similarly flawed (p. 77). Before attempting to confirm those fears in chapters 4 and 5, Quash presents von Balthasar's theologically inspired critique of Hegel's identification of human consciousness and Absolute Spirit in chapter 3. Von Balthasar believed that the ‘bestowing freedom’ of the ‘supra-differentiated’ persons of the Trinity grounds the sort of open-ended interaction of free persons with their world that Christian theology calls imaging God and that is the hallmark of human life – and good drama (pp. 114, 118). In chapter 4, Quash defends Barth against von Balthasar's criticisms of his ‘hymnic’ overconfidence in God's ultimate triumph by comparing Barth's and von Balthasar's doctrines of sin and faith (p. 124). The latter's definition of sin as inordinate pride and of faith as indifference leads Quash to see von Balthasar as the ironic champion of a too tidy view of history, a restrictive ecclesial obedience, and an unwarranted narrowing of faithful responses to God. Chapter 5 deepens the critique by contending that von Balthasar's epic tendencies are not accidental, but rooted in a systemic misapplication of analogy. Quash sees in von Balthasar's Theological Aesthetics, especially its definition of form (Gestalt), an untenable ‘mapping [of] harmonious proportionalities between creatures and their Creator’ that von Balthasar's Theodrama failed to correct (p. 182). Quash seeks, in chapter 6, to honour his debts to von Balthasar's theodramatic theory while addressing its shortcomings and avoiding von Balthasar's mistakes. Gerard Manley Hopkins' The Wreck of the Deutschland provides a fitting example of the ‘hard won’ harmonies a theodramatic reading of history can, under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, hope to hear (p. 198). Hopkins rejected an easy, epic frame for reconciling God, the catastrophic events of the shipwreck and the motley group of humans subjected to it. He tried to sense God's presence in the midst of these events, rather than from a secure vantage point above them. This, Quash rightly argues, is what theologians must do if they want to interpret history responsibly.
There is much to praise in this book, not least of which is its articulate insistence that Christian theologians (and, I would add, philosophers) need to be far more modest in their claims to have discerned God's presence and plans amid history's turbulent flow. Quash succeeds, sometimes brilliantly, in exposing some of the epic meanderings in von Balthasar's vast corpus. (His criticism of von Balthasar's analysis of Measure for Measure is devastatingly effective.) Nevertheless, at two crucial junctures – crucial by Quash's own account – he does not provide the close, attentive readings of von Balthasar's texts necessary to make his case that such meanderings are the norm. He devotes a little over three pages to analysing von Balthasar's New Testament exegesis and only nine sentences to von Balthasar's treatment of Christ's descent into hell (pp. 146–9, 194–5). Quash's keen analytical skills would have been put to very good use on both topics, although I believe doing so would have weakened his argument considerably. Most obviously, von Balthasar's New Testament exegesis is simply too complex to be illustrated with a single example. Nor does Quash seem to realise that von Balthasar's kenotic christology and participatory view of the atonement, with their emphasis on divine presence amid suffering and doubt, at the very least constitute a weighty counterbalance to his epic-seeming views of faith and the church. More surprisingly, Quash misunderstands von Balthasar's definition of form, taking it to mean something immobile when von Balthasar conceived of it as a structured mediation of a dynamic event of disclosure (p. 184). This skews Quash's reading of von Balthasar's purposes in the Theological Aesthetics and, indeed, of his definition of persons as forms (p. 160). Finally, although von Balthasar's Marian ecclesiology has serious weaknesses, it is just odd to describe the author of Raze the Bastions and, later, the critic of Vatican II as ‘press[ing] human freedom and responsibility into tight ecclesial moulds’ (p. 166). In short, von Balthasar's works are far too unsystematic (and self-contradictory!) to be neatly tucked into either an epic or dramatic category. His work evinces both tendencies. Christians would do well to avoid the one and follow his lead in the other.
