This welcome addition to the disability studies literature focuses on professional practice in the detailed context of changing social policy. Whilst this is by no means unique in the literature the sustained orientation towards positive practice, which facilitates and advocates service users’ choice and control, certainly offers fresh insight in a mostly critical literature. Positive practice is, for these authors, grounded in and informed by a social model understanding of disability and impairment. The problems for impaired people do not lie within themselves; their abnormality, dependency and tragedy caused by impairments. The problems are socially caused and lie in a disabling society and the inherent attitudinal, environments and structural barriers encountered by people with impairments, including relations with a plethora of professionals.
It seemed to me to be well and straightforwardly structured with a fairly comprehensive coverage of relevant topics and issues, given the specific focus and this being a relatively short book. There are nine chapters including an introduction and a conclusion. There is a basic history chapter which provides a good analysis of the legislation and policy that has shaped professional practice and, indeed, professionalised the western world. The authors then take this swiftly forward towards the present, with an overview of the development of community care alongside perhaps the most monumental change for many disabled people: the closure of large-scale institutions. The book then moves on towards a more detailed focus on the possibilities for the establishment of positive practice, beginning with some pivotal moments in the development of disability policy, generated by the growth of the Disabled People's Movement and the foundation of the social model. Throughout their discussions the authors take a critically reflective approach and invite the reader to do the same with ‘what do you think?’ exercises and activities. The next steps forward come in a chapter entitled ‘Independent Living: Choices and Rights’. Having laid out the possibilities and principles of positive practice the authors then provide two chapters which build a more complex picture beginning with life course issues and focusing particularly on young and older disabled people. The diversity of disabled people is then further extended through discussions of issues relating to mental health, learning difficulties, gender, ethnicity and sexuality. Before the short conclusion the authors then take on the key challenges or barriers facing professionals who have taken on board a social model of disability and are looking to ensure that their practice and the practice of other professionals is truly ‘social model practice’.
I have some thoughts, perhaps minor reservations, relating to this book. The first relates to the audience. It is clearly addressed to professionals, health and social care, working with disabled people and students of those professions. I think that for most disability studies students this will be an informative text for following up a specific interest, around social policy and relations with professionals, rather than being a core text. For disabled people or service users perhaps the particular interest will lie in the promotion of control and choice by disabled people.
Perhaps relating to the above point, I felt that general disability studies issues were rather skated over. A key example of this is that, as I said above, the whole orientation of the text is from a social model of disability, yet in a rather brief discussion it is suggested that there are now a number of equally valuable social models. This is, however, not dealt with as a controversy within disability studies, as it certainly is, and is not taken into possibilities for changing professional practice, that is, there is no discussion of the different implications for professional practice generated by the different models.
The book is very positive in terms of the development of the work of professionals with disabled service users. As such it is a significant contribution to the literature for professionals wishing to facilitate independent living, empowerment and self-directed assessment and support for disabled people. I was, however, left questioning the viability of such possibilities in the light of recent budgetary cuts and, for instance, the demise and struggle for existence of organisations run by disabled people such as centres for independent living.
The book covered little or nothing about relevant developments in other countries. It could be argued that an international perspective is beyond the scope of the coverage given the specific orientation of the book, though I think a few well-selected examples of developments in policy and professional practice around the world could have been useful.
Finally, I would have liked to have seen more of the voices of disabled people in relation to the specific issues being tackled. The shift of power to disabled people in terms of determining their daily lives and relevant policy which shapes their daily lives is clearly and consistently emphasised. In the analysis and evaluation of recent changes, however, more consideration could have been given to the researched views and experiences of disabled service users, or the lack of such research.
Overall, I think this is a significant contribution to the literature which will be valuable for practitioners and students on professional courses, generating thinking, reflection on practice with disabled service users and, it is to be hoped, truly positive practice from a social model approach.
