With his witty opening lines, David Edgerton makes it clear that he aims to reform the style as well as the content of books about technology: ‘Much of what is written on the history of technology is for boys of all ages. This book is a history for grown-ups of all genders’ (p. ix). Although adding ‘ages, interests and backgrounds’ might have spoiled the effect, it would have provided a realistic description of the wide audiences Edgerton is trying to reach in this pithily written book. Through delivering a barrage of counterintuitive examples, The Shock of the Old shocks its readers into abandoning any faith that the path of progress from past to future is signposted by revolutionary inventions. As he puts it in one of his one-liners, ‘novelty is not new, but there are new things to say about it’ (p. 184).
Edgerton's basic approach is to consider how technologies are used, rather than when they were invented. Instead of celebrating great innovations, he presents statistical data about a great variety of things and their importance in daily life all over the world. When analysed numerically, paper clips, sewing machines and cycle rickshaws seem far more significant than many conventional landmark achievements, such as bombs or spacecraft. Tables of research and development budgets unexpectedly reveal that car manufacturers easily outstrip computer companies, although heavy financial investment does not inevitably improve effectiveness – in 1990s Rwanda the cheap machete became ‘a major killing machine for the first time in history’ (p. 183). Edgerton's use-based history emphasizes global disparities, demonstrating that poor nations are not developing into rich ones, but are instead creating their own distinctive ‘creole’ technologies of poverty, in which corrugated iron abounds, bicycle production is soaring, and local inventors are adapting older equipment to fit particular requirements.
After setting out his theoretical position in the introduction, Edgerton elaborates his central case in eight thematic chapters with punchy titles, such as ‘Significance’, ‘Nations’ and ‘Killing’. The first preconception to be demolished is the notion that dramatic innovations in themselves effect great change; often, Edgerton argues, similar but forgotten inventions existed previously, and survived to regain their former prominence. For instance, although the Pill is normally credited with triggering a sexual revolution, its use was initially restricted to wealthy consumers, and several other contraceptive methods had long been available; moreover, condom sales boomed worldwide after AIDS became a threat.
Edgerton also rewrites technological timelines, pointing out that steam power was more prevalent in the twentieth century than in the nineteenth, that guns kill more people than bombs, and that Mahatma Gandhi reintroduced spinning wheels into India. By careful counting, Edgerton overturns assumptions about impact: in the USA railways only marginally affected the economy during the nineteenth century, in Africa cars are almost as lethal as malaria, and in inter-war Britain humble Elastoplast was promoted as a major money-saver. Edgerton also highlights the importance of maintenance, a vital aspect of technology normally neglected in economic data. Investing in new transport systems is of little use unless adequate funds are dedicated to their upkeep; conversely, ingenious repairers in poorer countries can extend mechanical lifetimes almost indefinitely.
Resembling a technological Charles Darwin, Edgerton convinces his readers through the sheer weight of examples. Occasionally, his reforming zeal overwhelms his analysis. Edgerton's insistence on telling both versions of history – the conventional one that modern scholars are seeking to overthrow, as well as his own interpretative synthesis – is sometimes confusing; although reviewing the previous literature is standard academic procedure, it can reduce the rhetorical power of an argument. Fired by his mission to reverse expectations, in this book Edgerton rarely pauses to question the intrinsic value of his use-based criteria; in terms of hours spent, the top achievement of humanity is to sleep, but is this necessarily an individual's most important activity?
Nevertheless, as in The Origin of Species, Edgerton's rich diversity of case studies makes it impossible to deny the significance of his analysis. Anti-heroic versions of history may be familiar to academics, but Edgerton has splendidly brought together many specialized studies into a single polemical volume. Drawing on an impressively wide range of secondary literature, he presents his arguments accessibly and with political verve, making this a splendid book for students as well as the notorious ‘general reader’. Combining historical acumen with social commentary, Edgerton aims not only to reinterpret technology's past, but also to change its future.
