In their edited collection The Cambridge Companion to the Actress, Maggie B. Gale and John Stokes guide us through the “unique and turbulent history” (12) of the actress; they have put together sixteen new essays detailing this history across several centuries and two continents (Europe and North America). From an impressive group of scholars, the essays are distinguished by a consistent effort to move beyond traditional critical and artistic boundaries and offer original investigations of the actress and the systems, conventions, and communities that contributed to a career. The essays are grouped into three well-conceived parts that facilitate these synthetic goals: “Turning Points,” “Professional Opportunities,” and “Genre, Form and Tradition.” The best essays offer archival research and original critique; all approach the issue of gendered performance with an understanding that the construction of gender must be understood in the context of other issues of identity—sexual orientation, class, race, age, nationality.
The seven essays in “Turning Points” concentrate on key historical moments “driven by widespread uncertainties” about what the actress might represent under changing circumstances (3). The historical moments include some necessary and predictable topics—initial appearances of actresses on European stages, increasing respectability and authority on the eighteenth-century stage, and training schools of the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Less predictable topics include the importance of international touring in the nineteenth century, the role of photographic and filmic images in the creation and promotion of acting careers, and the dangers of pursuing high-profile politics in the twentieth century; John Stokes's reading of suppressed sexuality on the postwar English stage is a treasure. Common in this section are the authors' assertions that in each of these “moments” actresses have been agents in expanding the role, authority, and influence of women in theatrical practice. In writing of the first actresses, Gilli Bush-Bailey notes that from the beginning the actress has posed a “threat to the stability of male/public, female/private construction” (19); this threat constitutes a theme that threads through each of the pieces as the authors detail how actresses develop their skills (and fame) by negotiating their visibility, sexuality, and social standing. As the role of the actress mutates to fit the social and political conditions of the day, new skills and expectations come to the fore. What worked for Sarah Siddons (who took care to protect the fragility of her unblemished reputation, refusing association with actresses of more “ambiguous fame” [43]) would not work for those acting in the late nineteenth century, caught up in the frenzy for cartes de visites. The vilification of a political Jane Fonda is an exaggerated version of the suspicions about Charlotte Cushman's cross-dressing. Cumulatively, the essayists are in concurrence that there has been demonstrable “progress” in the role of the actress on the Western stage.
The concept behind “Professional Opportunities,” Part II of the collection, is to investigate “matters of status” and the strategies women have used to advance their theatre-based influence (6). The four essays collected here provide a compendium of details on the empowerment of the actress; they cover the actress as manager, the actress and the autobiography, the actress and early film, and the actress and her race. The details are most compelling when carefully selected and researched; Viv Gardner's essay on actresses' autobiographies exposes the “liminality of the actress-autobiographer” (176) and the elusiveness of the self for those whose profession is taking on and masking selves with conviction. Christine Gledhill's investigation of major changes in early screen acting offers several well-chosen narratives to make her point that nation and class were powerful factors for “screen womanhood” (209) as actresses negotiated the “discursive clashes and shifts around gender roles and definitions of femininity” (211). Other pieces in the volume take up the racial inflections of acting, particularly for women of color, but Lynette Goddard's examples in this section are the most extensive.
The third and final part, like the first, defines a fresh perspective on the expansive topic of the actress, one that enables insightful scholarship. Each of the five essays in “Genre, Form, and Tradition” focuses on theatrical conventions and practices and the determining role of the actress—not the playwright, the director, or the text—in each. The critics deliver impressive examples of the transgressive power of the actress on French-, Spanish-, and English-speaking stages. The first essay, by Jacky Bratton, demonstrates that through the development of hypersexuality and “boy” roles, women in drag in the nineteenth and early twentieth century explored ways of “temporarily entering the culture of physical enjoyment and relative sexual freedom” otherwise off limits for women (241). Both Elaine Aston's study of key roles by Sarah Bernhardt and Mrs. Patrick Campbell and Maggie B. Gale's historical account of the actress and the monologue offer analysis of the slippery relationships among the “self, the script, the character, the audience, the locations and space for performance” (309). Maria M. Delgado's work on the Spanish actress as collaborator focuses on politics and texts, a strong companion to Tony Howard's earlier piece (in Part II) also detailing both overt and subtle political dimensions to women onstage. The collection ends with Penny Gay's account of women acting Shakespeare in the past two decades; she offers a sobering reminder that “progress” for women onstage is fragile, that ground gained can also be lost.
The apparatus of this collection is familiar from other Cambridge Companions; each essay is well footnoted and ends with “Further Reading,” a collection of key primary and secondary texts. Throughout the collection there is consistency in the attention to well-chosen examples, thorough research, and wide-ranging contextual material—from production reviews to publicized research, from archival manuscripts to diaries and the popular press. A few of the essays sag under the weight of detail that is not sufficiently shaped or synthesized; most offer original scholarship that will be essential to researchers and welcome to those teaching advanced courses in performance.
