This book has a host of virtues to add to its alluring title. It is a work of local history – itself something of a rare bird in Argentinian historiography – that studies the mechanisms of the society that grew up around the production of wheat in a southern part of Buenos Aires province, Partido de Coronel Dorrego, from its settlement by people of European extraction until the emergence of Peronism altered the social dynamics of the region. The focus, however, is on two particular aspects of this society. In its more traditional vein, the work engages with the basic economic milieu and access to credit and land on the part of homesteaders-tenant farmers and sharecroppers. By far the more original strand is the study of what Palacio terms the local ‘cultura jurídica’, principally through an analysis of the role of the justicias de paz (local magistrates who were not lawyers, and who dealt with lesser cases) in the mediation of the economic disagreements of local farmers, mainly with landowners, merchants and labourers. Lawyer-based justice – that is to say, the principal juridical system dealing with more weighty conflicts – only appears here as a result of appeals against local judgments.
From the outset this is a very well-written book, and it is an easy read (though on occasion somewhat exasperating for the specialist, for reasons that will be explored below). Moreover, encompassing as it does an unusual period of time, yoking together stages that are usually dealt with separately (interrupted by the Great War and the Depression), it offers a picture of continuities and transformations that enriches our understanding of the subject. Furthermore, the thematic originality of the second part of the book opens up an interesting area for the understanding of how this society functioned, dealing as it does with subjects that other studies have interpreted differently, such as conflicts relating to tenancy, credit, work and so forth. Above all, the focus on local history gives scope for some proper, deep mining into social mechanisms in a way that is generally absent from wider-ranging studies.
Precisely because of this, the analysis of the first part constrains the work's potential as far as this reviewer is concerned. As stated, through the wealth of information available to a local study, we are witness to the process of land occupation, the evolution of productive systems and tenancy relations, formal and informal credit and so on – but this is all analysed in a tone that the author acknowledges as ‘pessimistic’ and more in tune with the outlook of Scobie or Gaignard (in studies dating from the early 1960s) than with the more rigorous economic analysis which has dominated the field since the publication of La pampa gringa (Ezequiel Gallo's doctoral thesis from 1970) and El progreso argentino (1979) by Roberto Cortés Conde. In fact, the author contrasts the old interpretation of Scobie and Gaignard with an opposing viewpoint that he defines as ‘optimist’, and which he surprisingly associates primarily with the hypotheses of Jorge Sábato and Guillermo Flichman, rather than with the books by Gallo and Cortés Conde referred to above, or later works from the likes of Hilda Sábato (Capitalismo y ganadería) and this reviewer (La tierra de los ingleses en Argentina), or with a slew of more recent studies. Without doubt, his work is more in line with the first tendency.
Of course, this stance would be perfectly valid if it were well-founded, but I am not sure that this is the case. As frequently happens with Argentinian historiography – and, I'm afraid, with much of its society, a fact that may not be unrelated to its economic woes over the last century – there is a manifest incomprehension of markets and a rejection of how they work. So, rather than any attempt to understand the economic logic of the main actors' behaviour, which at bottom might be said to be an expression of human nature, a kind of moral economy is posited in which it is hoped that the state will ‘correct’ the injustices of the market. At the same time, the state is never up to this task, being more or less clearly an instrument in the hands of the powerful.Footnote 5 However, Argentinian economic history has long shown – and Palacio's book confirms this in good measure – that increased state intervention in the economy from 1930, and above all during the early years of Peronism, was not accompanied by an improvement in either agriculture generally or in the circumstances of those who worked the land in particular.Footnote 6 Hence, the vivid examples that emerge from the Dorrego archive, and which illustrate the complex economic mechanisms that underpinned the wheat economy, sit uneasily in a study more concerned with judging than understanding.
Nor is it a well-advised choice to include the analysis of this reality within the framework of the historiography of haciendas and campesinos in indigenous regions of Latin America, such as the Andes and Mesoamerica. Although it is, of course, possible to identify common features characteristic of the majority of agrarian societies undergoing capitalist consolidation, the comparison tends to hide the basic fact that in one case the tenant farmers are former peasants who lost the right to their land, while in the Pampas we are dealing with immigrants who looked to tenant farming – with varying degrees of fortune – for a more promising path to social advancement than that provided by the labour market, which was in itself not particularly unfavourable given the high salaries on offer. Understandably, however, beyond differences of interpretation, there is a sort of empirical reconciliation with the ‘optimistic’ camp, since the conclusion is that possibilities for social movement were robust in the initial stages, but dwindled as the regional economy consolidated and stabilised along similar lines to those observed in other frontier economies in Argentina and beyond.
Curiously, the final part of Palacio's study, in which he engages with juridical culture, reveals a very different approach. Here he shows a real ability to understand the thinking of the participants, leaving aside – and on occasion explicitly criticising – more moralising perspectives. He argues that, where the state was comparatively absent, both judges and lawyers, the main arbiters of the legal system, showed a great capacity to mediate in conflicts. These cases, it ought to be said, were not especially numerous, with 907 coming to court over 50 years, at an average of fewer than 20 per year, although of course they were concentrated in critical years such as the period around 1930. This is the background to what the author calls the ‘peace of wheat’, a fine expression that conveys the tendency of participants to conform to the conditions in which they live their lives.
The ambiguity of the reading derives from the fact that while the weakness of the state led to a lack of protection for tenant farmers and land workers in the economic sphere, this was made up for by a sort of legal free market, which satisfactorily filled the void. At a time when economists and economic historians stress the significance of a legal framework and the definition of property rights as the basis of any economic system, it would seem that a greater effort to comprehend the economic logic of the participants might reconcile these analyses of the economic and legal markets.
