Journalist and popular historian Adam Hochschild’s biography of Rose Pastor Stokes (1879–1933) illuminates the life and times of an all-too-often overlooked historical figure. Rose Pastor appeared to fulfill the Cinderella dreams at the heart of many early twentieth-century dime novels. A Russian Jew, she immigrated to the United States as a child. To help support her impoverished family, she began working in a Cleveland, Ohio, cigar factory at the age of eleven, an occupation she continued in for the next twelve years. It was through this experience that she first gained her understanding of class exploitation. Largely self-educated, with a love of reading and poetry, she occasionally wrote a women’s advice column for a Yiddish newspaper. Her column proved so popular that she was soon able to leave her factory job. Moving to New York in 1903, she began writing for the Yiddishes Tageblatt, living on the Lower East Side, and supporting her four younger siblings and mother. It was then that she met James Graham Phelps Stokes, an interview assignment for the newspaper.
Graham Phelps Stokes was the scion of one of New York’s wealthiest families. A reformer with a sense of noblesse oblige, he was a prominent member of the board and a resident of the University Settlement House, where the rich could offer reformist ministrations to the poor. During her interview with him, Pastor was enchanted by this “man of the common people” who was “so full of sympathy for the poor” (47). The attraction was mutual, and the two married in 1905. Comprising several old, rich, WASP families, the Phelps Stokes clan was a mismatch of rather high order for the young Jewish immigrant.
Hochschild uses the story of this rather remarkable couple to take the reader on a tour of the Gilded Age and its mix of extreme poverty and exploitation, opulent wealth, and callous corporate abuse. It also highlights the idealism of Progressive Era reformers and serves as a treatise on the centrality of class relations in a capitalist society. Often reading like a novel, the author utilizes techniques of creative non-fiction to present an engaging story.
Rose and Graham’s relationship developed during a period of extreme inequality. They set out on a partnership to alleviate suffering and alter the status quo. For the first three-quarters of Rose’s life, Hochschild uses a wealth of detail to make the era come alive. He introduces the reader to the streets of New York and the lives of the poor and the rich who lived there. Graham, and then Rose, were among the wealthy. They entertained a broad group of characters from intellectuals to labor leaders and were enmeshed in the Bohemian lifestyles of the Greenwich Village Left. Their circle included muckrakers and radicals such as Big Bill Haywood, Elizabeth Gurley Flynn, Emma Goldman, Lincoln Steffens, Clarence Darrow, and Upton Sinclair, often within the intellectual ferment of Mabel Dodge’s salons. Through personal anecdotes and stories, Hochschild turns these larger-than-life figures into flesh and blood individuals. Rose and Graham embraced the cause of organized labor as the best solution for alleviating the living conditions of the poor and joined the Socialist Party of America. Graham ran for office as a socialist and shared a stage with Eugene Debs.
The Cinderella aspect of Rose and Graham’s story brought extraordinary news coverage: according to Hochschild, from 1918 to 1921 Rose appeared in the press more than any other woman in America. She was a charismatic speaker, and, whether lecturing in a hall or rallying strikers on the picket line, her commitment to left-wing politics deepened. Graham’s dedication to the cause, on the other hand, appeared to fade, and he gradually became resentful of her absence from the home. As strains began to appear in their relationship, he moved rightward politically. Graham, it turned out, remained true to his class and culture and maintained an ongoing commitment to his family’s economic enterprises as well as to the “manly” militarism championed by Theodore Roosevelt and others. World War I proved the final breaking point.
Hochschild’s narrative exposes the horror of war hysteria and government repression. Dissenters were spied upon, jailed, deported, and even lynched. Graham joined the reactionaries; enlisted in the New York National Guard; and, as Upton Sinclair observed, “began drilling in one of the New York armories, preparing to kill any of his former comrades who might attempt an uprising” (179). He, like his uncle Will (who informed on Rose) wrote numerous letters to government agents informing on former friends. Rose was arrested for her anti-war activities. Graham supported her in court but condemned his other former socialist comrades, such as Debs, as unpatriotic. Rose was at Debs’s side during his trial. Her political commitments deepened and she became active in the Communist Party. She left Graham Phelps Stokes, and they were divorced in 1926. She asked for nothing and he gave her nothing. It was hardly a Cinderella ending. She died from cancer in 1933 at the age of fifty-four.
Hochschild rushes through the last dozen years of her life. He does not explore the cultural changes of the 1920s and its rebellious youth movements. He appears to have less sympathy for her turn to communism, even though it was an important period for her and for her country. Although she did not receive the same media attention as she had previously, Rose Pastor remained an activist until the end of her life. She was a founding member of the Communist Party, a member of its Central Executive Committee, and a delegate to the Comintern in Moscow. Although sick with cancer, she was arrested and injured in 1929 while supporting a garment strike. Her epic journey did not begin when she married Graham Phelps Stokes, nor did it end when she left him.
Hochschild has done copious research. He utilizes prolific news clippings, the personal papers of Rose, Graham and other acquaintances, and government records. Some historians, however, may find the paucity of notes problematic. It can be frustrating to be unable to pin down a source for a questionable assertion. Nonetheless, Hochschild’s book accomplishes its primary goal: it reminds us that there is a lot we owe to Rose and the socialists of her time who fought for such rights as social security, medical care for all, and child labor laws. Hochschild’s engaging book is written for a popular audience, and historians can learn a lot from it about how to bring stories we find engaging to a broader public. Such a task is more important than ever in this, our new Gilded Age.
