Hilary Appel offers a succinct but enriching story of Eastern Europe's challenges and successes at implementing both direct and indirect taxation since the fall of the Soviet Union. This book is particularly needed, given that only a handful of researchers (e.g., Andrew Savchenko, Anders Åslund, and Linda Cook) have systematically explored issues regarding taxation in Eastern Europe, especially in light of the political and economic overhaul created by the fall of communism. Appel claims that Eastern European taxation politics has been a dual game, played by outsiders in the case of indirect taxation and corporate taxation, and played mainly by domestic leaders in the case of personal income taxation, with a notable focus on the flat tax. However, the weakness of domestic elites is a surprisingly prominent feature of the Eastern European narrative, and the author highlights this throughout the text (p. 6).
Tax Politics in Eastern Europe is divided neatly into seven chapters, including the introduction. Appel tackles issues of state capacity first. The state capacity issue is the right place to start a book like this, as figuring out how to extract revenue was a central concern of Eastern European leaders and was the first step toward change. Second economies, antiquated bureaucracies, and untrained post-Soviet revenuers all contributed to the revenue dilemma. This also was an opening for outsiders (Western governments) to do the training and provide the advice and modeling needed by Eastern European governments.
Appel then moves on to discuss consumption and corporate taxes in Chapters 3 and 4. Once again, she notes that European leaders were central to tax policy. She argues that Eastern European governments “relinquished control over consumption taxes” to outsiders (p. 42) and “regional and global imperatives” (p. 82; emphasis in original) created a corporate tax-cutting frenzy in Eastern Europe. This took place in governments throughout Eastern Europe, including the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary, and Poland.
It is Appel's chapter 5 on personal income taxes that is the most interesting and important, but also the most incomplete. The rise of the flat tax in Eastern Europe is both politically and economically interesting, surprising, and somewhat novel. The speed with which the flat tax was adopted is also something worth noting, as Estonia and the Baltics' flat-tax plan cascaded throughout Eastern Europe and beyond in the last 18 years (p. 84). Appel correctly identifies domestic politics—and right-wing leaders in particular—as crucial to advancing the flat-tax agenda. Estonia's Mart Laar, Slovakia's Ivan Mikloš and Mikuláš Dzurinda, and the Czech Republic's Mirek Topolanek were key figures in the flat-tax movement (pp. 89–95). She also rightly notes the influence of Western economists, such as Milton Friedman and Daniel J. Mitchell, on Eastern European politicians like Laar and Mikloš.
Where this chapter falls short is in two places. First is in the issue of policy diffusion, raised by Alex Barturo and Julia Gray (“Flatliners: Ideology and Rational Learning in the Adoption of the Flat Tax,” European Journal of Political Science 48 [no. 1, 2009]: 130–59) and used to understand policy change elsewhere (see Kurt Weyland's Bounded Rationality and Policy Diffusion: Social Sector Reform in Latin America, 2006; and Beth Simmons and Zachary Elkins, “The Globalization of Liberalization: Policy Diffusion in the International Political Economy,” American Political Science Review 98 [no. 1, 2004]: 171–89). Appel grants that this took place, but if it did, is this not the real story of the flat tax, to be found by making the connections from one country to the next and explaining the adoption from there? She does follow this line of inquiry to some extent, noting the rise of flat-tax conferences, think tanks, and international consulting (pp. 112–15). But the diffusion question develops nuance when we notice the lag in time from Lithuania's adoption of the flat tax (ending in 1995) to Russia's in 2001. Why the lag, and why was the flat tax isolated to the Baltics? Was the type of diffusion process in the Baltics the same as in the Visegrad countries? What kick-started a second wave throughout the 2000s?
The second problem with this chapter is that it does not deal adequately with the strength of the flat tax as an idea as much as a policy. Several authors (e.g. Paul Aligica, Anthony Evans, Joseph Ellis, and Mart Laar) have grounded the Eastern European postcommunist tale as a battle over ideas. Even if Appel found the ideational framework less compelling, she might have spent some time unpacking this particular issue.
Chapter 6 on Russian tax policy is particularly fascinating, given that many scholars of public policy tend to overlook transitional, or less stable, democracies. Russia's case is especially instructive when we examine state capacity issues. As Appel points out: “the enfeebled state not only failed to resist lobbying pressure from governors and enterprise directors [but] also failed miserably to collect taxes that remained in force” (p. 122). This all changed with the rise of Vladimir Putin, who aggressively asserted his power over taxation with the help of the Unity Party, which controlled much of the Duma (p. 130). Putin most famously went after Russia's oligarchs, most notably Mikhail Khodorkovsky. Appel also notes that Russia—unlike its Eastern European counterparts—had much greater autonomy in setting indirect taxes. Where Russia loses its autonomy, according to the author, is when we consider its dependence on global energy prices to stay economically afloat (p. 141).
In the last chapter, Appel develops a statistical model that allows her to test for the role of domestic politics on tax policy, what she calls an “ideology index” (p. 144). The index quantifies what she qualitatively discovers in previous chapters; that is, domestic politics have little bearing on indirect taxes and more bearing on direct taxes, specifically personal income taxes. The author also drives home in this chapter one of the overarching themes for the book: the desire to join the European Union. She argues that the desire was so great because the benefits were so plentiful, among them economic access, greater security, and the creation of a cohesive European national identity (p. 154).
Overall, Tax Politics in Eastern Europe makes an important contribution. It effectively analyzes the problems that Eastern European leaders faced concerning taxation policy. It also dissects the various forms of taxation (both direct and indirect) and the extent to which they changed the interplay between external actors and domestic leaders. Appel is right that Western Europe still looms large in Eastern European political circles and greatly affects the policy choices available to domestic actors. However, Eastern European leaders now are increasingly seeking separation from the problems of “old Europe,” as seen with Slovakia's intransigence on the Greek bailout this year and Estonia's austerity policies. What this resistance means for Eastern Europe's future is uncertain, but this book is a good step to start us thinking more about the relationship between Western and Eastern Europe, and under what conditions the West still has a political and economic pull over the postcommunist East.
