This book adds to a growing body of literature on Islamophobia, which has been defined as the irrational fear of Muslims. Stephen Sheehi argues that since the collapse of the Soviet Union, Islamophobia in America has morphed into a new ideological formation “that deploys particular tropes, analyses and beliefs, as facts upon which governmental policies and social practices are framed” (p. 31). Sheehi also attempts to show that the attacks of 11 September 2001 led to an unprecedented mainstreaming of Islamophobia: “The Right's unyielding bombardment of the mainstream effectively broadens the level of Islamophobic discourse. Polemical books on Islam are packaged as political analyses or historical research. Whether by Robert Spencer, Bruce Bawer, or Melanie Phillips, Islam and Muslims are portrayed as pariahs” (p. 147). One consequence of the broadening of anti-Muslim discourse, Sheehi posits, is that the American power elite has become increasingly Islamophobic in the past two decades.
With nearly 800 endnotes and an index of cited leaders and organizations, the book contains a wealth of information on the detractors of Islam and Muslims. Cited examples include American Congress for Truth (or ACT for America) and Jihadwatch, both of whose raison d’être is the stigmatization of Islam and Muslims. But Sheehi discusses these two groups only briefly. He is more focused on the macrolevel political context of Islamophobic expression. In his view, Islamophobia “does not originate in one particular administration, thinker, philosopher, activist, media outlet, special interest group, think tank, or even economic sector or industry, though indeed, these actors are collectively responsible for the virulent dissemination of anti-Muslim and anti-Arab stereotypes and beliefs, circulated in order to naturalize and justify U.S. global, economic, and political hegemony” (pp. 31–32). Featured Islamophobes include a diverse range of academics, journalists, and political leaders, such as Bernard Lewis, David Horowitz, Ayaan Hirsi Ali, Irshad Manji, Fareed Zakaria, Thomas Friedman, George W. Bush, Dick Cheney, John McCain, Hilary Clinton, and Barack Obama.
According to Sheehi, these characters share an assumption that Muslims, particularly Arab Muslims, are stuck in a cultural hole that denies them progress, democracy, and human rights. “The continuity is strong between the Obama and Bush administration, and the seepage of policies originated against Arabs or Muslims into use against other social actors is ongoing, as the example of Kris Kobach's work on population tracking demonstrates” (p. 34). The program that Sheehi is referring to was developed under Attorney General John Ashcroft and called for fingerprinting and monitoring citizens from mostly Arab countries. A subsequent law in Kansas permitted law enforcement to stop suspected illegal immigrants.
Yet rather than analyzing the rhetoric and activism that he considers Islamophobic, the author describes the links between various offenders: “neoconservatives, Democratic hawks, evangelical Christians and hard-line American Zionists and their pet ‘intellectuals’” (p. 31). These offenders have justified invading Muslim-majority countries, supporting Israeli occupation, and restricting Arab and Muslim activism in America. Although such policies may be rife with anti-Muslim prejudice, Sheehi expends more effort in describing the political connections of accused Islamophobes than in providing evidence to support the accusations.
One example that shows how Sheehi's treatment is more assertive than analytical is his profile of Fareed Zakaria. Sheehi describes Zakaria's neoliberal ideology, rash critique of Arab politics, connections to Islamophobic groups, and early position in support of the Iraq War, and then concludes that Zakaria, like Lewis and others, believes “Arabs do not understand anything but the language of force” (p. 109). The closest precedence for charging opponents with such hate-filled sentiment is the political tendency by some commentators to regard criticism of Israel as an expression of anti-Semitism. Accusing someone of hate is a serious charge and must be reserved for indisputable cases. In the absence of a meticulous demonstration of linkages between bias on the one hand and specific rhetoric and policy rationalization on the other, this volume is open to the claim that it instrumentalizes charges of intolerance for political purposes.
Sheehi is insistent that his quest is scholarly, comparing his treatment of Islamophobia to Edward Said's study of Orientalism (p. 63). Sheehi built the book around the argument that Islamophobia is an “ideological formation” constructed to serve imperialism, whether called pax-Americana or neoliberal globalization. A major weakness in Sheehi's central argument is that ideological constructs define one's perspective on life and offer guidance for action and for interpreting events. The ideas of Pax-Americana and neoconservatism clearly possess these qualities. In contrast, Islamophobia involves fear, a negative—often thoughtless—emotion deriving from a perception (or misperception) of someone else's ideas and actions. Robert Spencer, who has made the production of anti-Muslim literature into a career, may be motivated by a political agenda that sees value in fanning the flames of anti-Muslim prejudice. He is also gaining a livelihood through this work. This set of activities can hardly be described as ingredients for ideological formation.
For culturalists, Islamophobia could arguably fit the definition of a subculture. As the case of Spencer shows, Islamophobia has become a pattern of thinking that now informs a way of life for a small segment of Americans, a segment that has grown dramatically after the Ground Zero mosque affair in 2009. The anti-shariʿa campaign, which has been propelled by an anti-Islamic tendency, has grown into a movement and even attracted many legislators in the southern states. Fortunately, the Oklahoma Supreme Court struck down that state's anti-shariʿa law. Moreover, an anti-Islamophobia movement that includes several major Christian and Jewish denominations as well as interfaith organizations has begun to take shape since 2010 (see www.shouldertoshouldercampaign.org). On balance, Sheehi's analysis of anti-Muslim bias in U.S. policy is timely and substantive, but it calls for a more methodical examination.
