This volume is a richly deserved tribute – but austere. There is no survey of Charles Webster's career, beyond a bibliography. We hear nothing of Webster's early days or the intellectual community he found, mostly around Sheffield and Leeds. For his later career we are offered a few suggestive notes on the connections between the seventeenth-century reformers and the NHS, and we are told that no personality is more complex and interesting than his. But Webster remains hidden, as he no doubt wished.
I guess it will be left to the obituarists to sketch some of the complexities: the northern English radical brought out of Vienna as a baby just before the Second World War; a lifelong dissenter who spent much of his career at All Souls, Oxford; a creator of social history in medicine in Britain, who could be impatient of its lack of intellectual ambition. But, of course, his work will be the major focus – the passionate interest in Paracelsus and the millennial programmes of the seventeenth century, the backing he gave to research on the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, and his monumental histories of the NHS, supplemented by a more political history and many later interventions. The essays reflect both that huge range and his commitment to empirical detailed history. But if you did not know about Webster, you might well wonder how the essays came to be in one volume.
Howard Hotson introduces us to nosse, velle and posse, to the trinities of the Christian God and of Aristotle's psychology. He shows how humanism was fitted into the instauration of the image of God in man, and how the technics of Bacon were brought alongside the fideism of Luther. Penelope Gouk explores how music was a technic of the animal spirits, between the oratory of prayer and the laboratory of alchemy. Lauren Kassell introduces us to the moral and intellectual economies of charms, and how they might sometimes be ‘naturalized’ by antiquaries. And then, with Antonio Clericuzio, we survey the Italian Paracelsians – less well known than their French brothers in part because they were eclectic rather than oppositional. How far away now seem the early modern categories for intellectual and moral projects, yet how much more subtle than the crudities of ‘science-and-society’ or ‘bioethics’.
The contested processes of partial naturalization are seen again in Robert Croker's essay on Henry More and faith healing. If the age of miracles was to be past for all but kings, then faith healing could be a ‘sanative contagion’, from a healer with a gift to a patient whose sickness was a sign rather than a divine imposition. And if William Petty, in Commonwealth Oxford, received a subject for dissection who then stirred and was brought back to life, then his novel science and his ambitious self could be publicized through older tropes ‘beyond the grave’, as Scott Mandelbrote nicely explains. And why then were the intellectual lights of Oxford anatomizing around 1650? Not, Mordechai Feingold claims, because of utopian visions, but because the Civil War had discredited both theology and law. You could get even further from the troubles as an English anatomist in Pisa and Florence, as did John Finch and his partner Thomas Baines – but they took the conservative side in local disputes, and failed as communicators with Britain, as Stefano Villani neatly sketches.
We have now moved from millennial aspirations to mundane successors – from Webster ‘yeast’ to the ‘dough’ of history. Jonathan Barry knows that successful political reform had to link with shared concerns and structural issues, but among the political practicalities of the parish he finds that brighter visions gleamed, a little. And for the period around 1800 we have two of the most substantial essays. Colin Kidd takes a wide view of Scottish race theory, including philology and phrenology, demonstrating that what was at stake was not Scottish politics but religious orthodoxy. Pietro Corsi then draws on his intimate knowledge of Paris between 1795 and 1802 to show how neologisms functioned, in science as in politics, to make a new age. The Napoleonic reaction would throw out many of the new words, and would temper the wide analytical ambitions, but (at least in my view) the disciplines born of radicalism would remain as much more than ‘specializations’.
And thus to the twentieth century and to social history, where Linda Bryder unpicks the links between New Zealand maternity services and the mother country; where John Welshman shows the early NHS as unmindful of regional inequalities; and John Stewart, for the same period, explores the tensions between the Scottish Office and the regional boards. Anne Marie Rafferty connects with Bryder in tracing the effect of lady colonials, but this time for nursing in the empire before the Second World War. Jane Lewis usefully compares a minor reform of medicine, which doctors led, with a larger reform of nursing, which was oriented to the NHS, not to the profession. And in a characteristically subtle piece, Virginia Berridge shows how governments learned to create public ‘bodies’ to promote what they wanted promoting – here, the end of smoking.
That is a taste of all the essays, except for the exploration by Margaret Pelling of doctors in politics. Alone of the articles, this attempts a long sweep, including notes on the nineteenth and twentieth centuries but focusing on the local responsibilities and offices of early modern towns. Property, law and the military were well represented there – but the doctors preferred to be elsewhere, seeking custom. Medicine was then marginal to power, as becomes easier to understand now, when both professions and civil society have been marginalized in Blairite Britain.
This neo-liberal corrosion of professional and community aspirations is not a consummation one would have anticipated when Webster got to work in the 1960s, nor in 1997 when so much was expected for and from the post-Thatcher NHS. But the impoverishment of politics since then, and the trivialization of much historical and social research, makes Webster's work ever more relevant. He showed how one might retrieve richer visions, where ideals and roles were not restricted to entrepreneurs and employees. Alas that it should seem exceptionally important now.
