In the theatre, Oedipus’ pre-eminence among the myths of modernity has been challenged by theoretical takes on Antigone to articulate the main preoccupations of postmodernism. At the same time, productions and adaptations of Antigone proliferate on theatrical stages across the world. In this light, the simultaneous appearance of two edited volumes on the reception of Antigone in the last decades comes as a surprise. However, not only do these two volumes contribute to an examination of the play's recent popularity among theorists and theatre practitioners; by situating Antigone in postmodern and global contexts the essays published here mark a departure from the text's humanistic Western legacies, eloquently represented in George Steiner's celebrated 1984 Antigones.
In the first book, by Wilmer and Žukauskaitė, the inquiry into Antigone is set against the ‘clash of philosophical, psychoanalytical, and gender interpretations’ (p. 1). Rather than offering an overview of the various theoretical engagements of which Antigone has commonly been at the centre, the book provides the site of an ongoing debate between psychoanalysis and feminist criticism. The carefully planned sections of the volume relate the antithesis between law and kinship, which is central in Hegel's dialectical reading of Sophocles’ play, to contemporary theoretical debates. Within this framework, the individual essays critically respond to philosophical accounts (e.g. Chanter on Antigone's monstrous representations in Heidegger, Lacan and Žižek) or speak for dominant, yet conflicting, interpretative strands, as in Irigaray's gendered inversion of the Oedipal order and Griffith's programmatically psychologizing reading of the play in the context of its original performance. It is indicative that the critique of psychoanalytic interpretations is consistent with the politicization of Antigone, by means of either challenging French postmodernism (Eagleton) or turning to Butler's counter-discourse (Kahane, Ettinger). The book features a series of thought-provoking essays which scrutinize Antigone as a paradigm of bodily exposure and exile, drawing on Agamben's and Arendt's concepts of bare and naked life (Sjöholm, Žukauskaitė).
The closing section of the book is dedicated to pictorial and theatrical representations of the myth. The analyses of performance and visual sources are bound with the theoretical issues tackled in the volume (e.g Fischer-Lichte's discussion of the individual–community polarity in landmark productions). Wilmer's closing essay acknowledges the contradiction between Antigone's unequivocal place within philosophy and her straightforward theatrical representations as a fighter against state oppression.
Although Foley and Mee's volumes share a clear focus on Antigone, the two books do not overlap but rather complement each other. The essays presented by Foley and Mee illustrate the play's performance reception in the last decades, examining stagings presented in diverse cultural, political and national contexts. The introduction provides methodological remarks for the study of the text in performance which can be of significant help to classicists working on the reception of ancient drama. The editors draw parallels between adaptation and performance as modes of mobilizing the classical texts, while also arguing that performances of Antigone constitute political acts. The sections of the book introduce larger thematic categories which help to establish connections across the numerous case studies. The wide impact of Sophocles’ Antigone, starting already in antiquity (see Hall's opening essay), is further traced in productions internationally. The strong emphasis on postcolonial contexts works well with discussions of uses of Antigone which destabilize cultural traditions (burial and mourning in Macintosh) or political discourses of the West (e.g. Van Steen, Robinson). Yet an overarching conceptual framework would have helped the reader deal with the wide-ranging material and relate performance aesthetics to the broader questions of modernity and the nation state, both addressed in Fradinger's double contribution to the volume. Whilst most of the essays question the role of the classics (Goff, Hardwick, Worthen), there are cases where the approach to both Antigone and its appropriation by local communities goes rather unproblematized (Hunsaker on the Yup'ik). The useful appendix presents an annotated productions record of Antigone outside Europe and the USA.
Reception studies have raised awareness of the broader cultural impact and significance of classics; yet, as both volumes demonstrate, each in its own manner, this awareness is by no means tantamount to a complacent celebration of diachronic and contemporary refigurations of antiquity. If Antigone encompasses the historical and intellectual experience of the late twentieth century it is not just because the play interweaves issues of sovereign state, repressive law and ethical struggle, but rather due to its inextricability from the cultural and discursive processes which have both sustained and defied power and authority.
