Class conflict is one of the central axes on which turn historical narratives of the late nineteenth- and early twentieth-century United States. In standard renditions, the story goes that animosities between the haves and have-nots boiled over in the turbulent Gilded Age and then went on to subside, if not quite dissipate, during the Progressive Era, thanks in large part to the efforts of newly emboldened, middle-class reformers.Footnote 1 Three recent books offer an opportunity to interrogate this plot line. Collectively, David A. Zonderman's Uneasy Allies, R. Todd Laugen's The Gospel of Progressivism, and Vanessa H. May's Unprotected Labor raise the question of whether its arc is altogether too Whiggish. Were class relations really so bad in the Gilded Age and so much better in the Progressive Era, or is there an unwarranted teleology embedded in this way of framing the story?
Uneasy Allies explores the world of cross-class labor reform in nineteenth-century Boston. “World” is not too grandiose a term. In this eastern seaport, Zonderman recovers a tradition of collaboration that evolved between working- and middle-class persons over seven decades of struggle. Building upon this evidence, as well as the foundational work of David Montgomery, Carl Guarneri, and others, he argues, “Across much of the nineteenth century, no yawning chasm opened between workers and reformers in Boston on questions of social change and justice for labor” (17). To be sure, there were squabbles and tensions aplenty, which scuttled any number of campaigns. But Zonderman persuasively shows that despite repeated setbacks and ample, persistent differences, Bostonians did not forsake the cross-class fight for reform until the turn of the twentieth century.
The book is divided into two parts, the first of which explores the period stretching from the 1830s through the early 1870s. Here Zonderman sorts through a number of antebellum reform organizations that found ways to bridge ideological, class, and gender divides, at least for a time. The New England Workingmen's Association attracted ordinary workers, utopian reformers, and so many women that, within two years of its 1844 founding, it changed its name to the Labor Reform League of New England (LRLNE). But in what would prove a recurring pattern, the LRLNE failed to deliver on its early promise. It collapsed in 1848, its diverse constituencies no longer able to agree about which issues to prioritize and which tactics to embrace. In the last two chapters of Part I, the narrative approaches the period covered by this journal. During the immediate postbellum years, the movement for a shorter workday surged across the industrializing North. Zonderman emphasizes that working- and middle-class Bostonians collaborated throughout this “frenzy of organizing,” with four cross-class organizations founded in 1869 alone (114). Highlighting the contributions of the fierce eight-hour advocate Ira Steward, as well as those of his many allies and nemeses, Zonderman ably documents this generation's achievements—including, most notably, a ten-hour law passed in 1874—as well as the dissension that permeated and finally sundered its ranks.
Part II surveys developments in Gilded Age Boston, where Christian Socialists often played key roles in galvanizing cross-class reform efforts. Zonderman delves deeply into the ideas and activities of pioneering ministers Jesse Jones, who founded the Christian Labor Union; Herbert Casson, who established one of the first labor churches on the west side of the Atlantic; and W. D. P. Bliss, whose Church of the Carpenter became a nationally known center of social Christianity. Bliss also poured his energies into the Wendell Phillips Union, one of four key spaces in the city where workers and reformers came together to debate and strategize about how to advance their shared movement. Zonderman contends that the rise in the 1890s of organizations such as the Anti-Tenement House League and the Consumers’ League of Massachusetts signaled a sea change. By that point a new influx of immigrants had dramatically increased the social and cultural distance between Boston's working and middle classes, making it more difficult for each to imagine the other as partner. As the Progressive Era dawned, both opted to go it alone.
In showing that a strong impulse toward cooperation thrived throughout what is often seen as the Gilded Age nadir, Zonderman advances a countervailing story. It was only in the ensuing decades, when interclass cooperation is typically purported to be on the upswing, that bridge-building efforts in Boston collapsed. But if Uneasy Allies bucks the conventional wisdom, it does not demand a total rethinking; Zonderman acknowledges that cross-class labor reform was never more than “a particular niche in the ecology of social change” (16). Although he succeeds admirably in what he sets out to do, providing a cogent, longitudinal analysis of this specific reform tradition, it is unfortunate that he did not more intentionally situate it in the context of wider developments in Boston and across the nation. The book's pinpoint focus may make it difficult for those who do not specialize in the labor history of the industrializing North to discern—amidst the maze of ideas, institutions, and individuals that Zonderman chronicles so capably—clear connections to their own work.
Laugen's The Gospel of Progressivism picks up the chronological thread where Uneasy Allies leaves off but shifts the geographical focus westward to Colorado, where an entirely different cast of characters and dynamics dominated the political stage. It is all the more interesting that Laugen, too, finds little evidence of sustained cross-class partnerships during the Progressive Era. It was not for lack of energy. Throughout the first three decades of the twentieth century the state was abuzz with reforming activity, as middle-class ministers, determined clubwomen, unionized workers, and mediation experts—all purporting to speak for broader publics—pursued their respective agendas. In 1910 and again in 1912, some of these constituencies managed to work together constructively and to great effect. They saw through legislative and electoral processes including the initiative, the referendum, and a number of key worker protections. But successful collaboration across class lines was the exception, not the rule. Whereas demographic change looms large in Zonderman's explanation of this trend, ideological factors are the linchpin in Laugen's.
As the book's title suggests, one of Laugen's central arguments is that Christianity was a more potent force within Colorado's reform circles than the historiography on American progressivism might indicate. Although middle-class women and men understood and enacted citizenship in differently gendered ways, they were often united in their embrace of a particular variant of Christian faith. Their faith was certainly not the religion of the Reverend Myron Reed, a Christian Socialist who used his Denver pulpit to denounce the abuses of the mine operators and industrial magnates. (Reed died in 1899, just before Laugen's story begins.Footnote 2) Most middle-class Coloradans of the era practiced instead a Christianity within which prostitution, alcohol consumption, and other vices were the central moral issues. The prevalence of such faith proved a boon to the ferociously Protestant Ku Klux Klan, which rose to statewide power during the 1920s. But it was always a vexing obstacle for organized labor, whose protestations against capitalist oppression did not resonate with the larger electorate's ethical sensibilities. Religion was a sword that cut both ways, motivating reform yet dividing the reformers.
As Laugen convincingly shows, the middle class's lack of interest in restraining corporate power meant that economic life in early twentieth-century Colorado retained a Gilded Age feel. The state was repeatedly rocked by violent confrontations between workers and military forces, most notoriously at Cripple Creek in 1903 and Ludlow in 1914. The eventual ascendance of mediation experts did anything but level the playing field. Their habit of invoking the public good as justification for the suppression of strikes only weakened labor's bargaining position, and in so doing eroded the possibilities for a more egalitarian society. In light of the many ways it does not fit the Progressive Era mold, Colorado offers a potentially provocative vantage from which to rethink the period. Unfortunately, Laugen does not take full advantage of the opportunity. While expertly sifting through the particulars of his very intriguing story, he forfeits chances to reflect on its larger implications. Even so, his book, which may help others to connect those dots, will be of great interest to historians of Colorado and of progressivism in the West.
May's Unprotected Labor moves from the Continental Divide to New York City, where in the years between 1870 and 1940 more women were employed in household work than in any other kind. These women were conspicuously excluded from the reforming legislation that brought new protections to many workers, both male and female, in the early decades of the twentieth century. One of the central aims of May's book is to explain why. She finds the answer in the interplay between bourgeois women and household laborers, which was complicated not only by dynamics of race and class, but also by the stakes involved: namely, the sanctity of the thoroughly gendered middle-class home.
May outlines two distinct phases in the history of New York City domestic labor. Until World War I, household workers were almost exclusively European immigrants, with the Irish at the vanguard. Middle-class New Yorkers hoped that these women, who lived and worked under the direct supervision of the matron of the house, would grow in virtue through the experience, but there was always the fear that they would spread vice, disease, and even Catholicism. Such worries became only more pronounced in the years after the Great Migration, when household labor became the domain of African American women, who most often lived apart from their employers. The relative autonomy that choice afforded them exacerbated middle-class anxieties about the stains, both moral and hygienic, that domestics might leave behind at the end of the day.
Domestics posed other threats as well. In calling attention to the long hours they worked and the abuses they often suffered, household workers recast the middle-class home as a workplace, which might be subject to oversight, not to mention a site of labor conflict. As May underscores, their employers shuddered at the very thought and waged a successful battle to make sure that reform efforts were directed at the workers themselves. Physical examinations, training programs, and other methods of weeding out the “undesirable” help became de rigueur, while the conditions of the work itself went totally unregulated. It is easy to see how this approach dovetailed with the interests of the middle-class women who hired domestics. The acquiescence of women reformers who so successfully championed the rights of women in industrial jobs requires explanation, however. Why did even progressives such as Frances Kellor fail to tackle the most serious injustices that household workers faced? May argues that they, too, were deeply invested in preserving the home as sanctum, for it was their “alleged command of the values of the private sphere” that justified their public activism in the first place (9). Lacking true allies and facing overwhelming odds, domestics nevertheless tried to organize their own ranks. But in the medium term, it was mostly for naught: the New Deal came and went while they remained, in the words of May's apt title, unprotected labor.
May's book is a tour de force of social history. By reading against the grain of her middle-class source base, May sheds light on the oft-neglected, day-to-day experiences of household workers. Meanwhile, she mounts a compelling and ambitious argument about their uniquely precarious location within the larger labor force, one with implications that extend far beyond the confines of New York City. It seems reasonable to assume that dynamics comparable to the ones she describes would also have been operative in Philadelphia, Chicago, and other cities where domestic labor was in high demand. Like the stories by Zonderman and Laugen, May's does not conform to a larger narrative that stresses progress as the nation moved from the Gilded Age into the Progressive Era. As she writes in her introduction, “[It] is ultimately one of failure” (16). So what, in the end, can be concluded about the status of the more conventional account?
Zonderman, Laugen, and May inspire any number of questions. Were cross-class partnerships equally prevalent in other late-nineteenth cities? Were there other states in which, well into the twentieth century, the industrial elite continued to run amok? How many others are excluded when the story of class relations in the industrializing United States is framed primarily in terms of progress? Although these three books will not send historians running all the way back to the drawing board, they do drive home the need for syntheses that better reflect the tremendous variability in Americans’ class experiences across regions and races, genders and occupations. Their contributions are especially timely in the context of the current moment, with the designations “Gilded Age” and “Progressive Era” being bandied about so haphazardly in public debates. Indeed, Zonderman, Laugen, and May serve as reminders that part of what this guild has to contribute to these wider conversations is a more reasoned and precise sense of a past that remains deeply implicated in the present.
