With characteristically barbed humor, Wobbly songster Joe Hill sang of Casey Jones, the union fink who went to hell on the railway line for breaking solidarity with the men who laid and rode the rails. Battling for militant working-class manhood, Hill echoed the sentiments of those who saw strikebreakers as the most subversive and, indeed, effeminate of men. Prostituting oneself to railroad companies or to conservative trade unions was, for the rank-and-file of the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), the same thing. Labor historians have tended to share these sentiments, whether studying the craft unions of the American Federation of Labor (AFL) or the railroad brotherhoods. In most studies, skilled workers represent the labor aristocracy. Their practice is viewed as primarily exclusionary, racist, and patriarchal unionism.
In Good, Reliable White Men, historian Paul Taillon examines the brotherhoods of locomotive engineers, firemen, conductors, and brakemen, arguably the most conservative unions in American history. Taillon's most significant contribution is that he takes the railroad brotherhoods on their own terms and not merely as exemplars of working-class racism and male identity. Although Taillon acknowledges the conservatism of the railroad fraternities, he also explores the history of one of the best-paid and largest groups of workers in the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Above all, the railroad brotherhoods, for all their conservatism, made railroad workers the first group to receive federal labor mediation and other legal protections, including the eight-hour day.
Taillon begins with broad brush strokes, painting workers in the railroad operating trades in the context of nineteenth-century class, gender, and race norms. Masculinity, patriarchal family relations, and white racial solidarity within a native-born, English-speaking community were values central to train conductors, engineers, and firemen. Fraternal association and the bonds of brotherhood, celebrated in the workplace and in the railroad unions, became the fourth pillar of skilled railroad men's lives. The rough life of early trainmen, over time, gave way to the respectable unionism of reliable white men. Taillon relies on the existent literature to trace out these elemental values, making the early chapters a little thin. At the same time, he frames late-nineteenth-century, working-class identity as gendered and racially defined and traces in detail the fraternal model at the base of railroad unionism. Taillon balances his discussion of the rail fraternities with an exploration of the high level of occupational accidents and death on the railroads, which gave added importance to the mutual aid and insurance benefits of the brotherhoods. He also briefly explores women's railroad union auxiliaries and the new womanhood that presented a threat to older ideals of male dominance and masculine wage earning.
Taillon is able, from this base, to integrate the railroad unions into the evolving political culture of the day and to delineate their transformation from union fraternal orders to the new business unionism of the Progressive Era. Higher union dues, regular benefit funds, and better-paid and educated union leaders strengthened the hand of the railroad unions. So, too, did a new ideology of harmonious relations between railroad managers and their workers. As Taillon shows, the railroad brotherhoods aggressively sought to exclude African American and, later, immigrant workers not only from their unions but from the railroad work force. Locals of the Locomotive Firemen, for example, engaged in strike actions and protracted negotiations to restrict the number of African American firemen and to limit their seniority rights to the better-paying passenger and freight runs. Racial exclusion and conflict within the unions, which surfaced at first and most viscerally in the South, merged the ideology of white supremacy with masculine codes of honor and respectability. Although Taillon is not the first to uncover the racial underpinnings of labor politics, he connects the practice of racial exclusion to emerging languages of labor patriotism and empire as they emerged at the turn of the century.
Like the craft unions of the AFL, the railroad brotherhoods became enmeshed in conservative alliances with business, including the iconic National Civic Federation. Railroad labor leaders were tapped to head government agencies and integrated as well into Democratic Party politics. They used their growing political power to establish a new agenda that brought voluntary arbitration under the Erdman Act (1898) and government mediation and an eight-hour day under the Adamson Act (1916). Taillon concludes that these laws laid the groundwork for the passage of the Railway Labor Act (1926), which still governs railroad labor relations, and more importantly, contributed to the larger project of state building that culminated in the New Deal. In drawing these connections, Taillon succeeds in reintegrating railroad workers into labor history and the larger history of the nation-state.
