The international law book under review leaves an asymmetrical impression. As is asserted in the “Introduction” (p. 1), the book deals with “a set of impressive issues that can serve as models of discourse in the classroom”, and the range of topics covered is impressive. It proceeds from the international law foundations, through non-territorialism, economic instruments, courts, international humanitarian law, the environment, force qua terrorism, and post-colonialism to international political interaction, but an attentive reader should expect to be confronted with a number of questions, which are left unanswered in the book.
Surprisingly, the chapters by Dave O. Benjamin (on crimes against humanity) and Anthony J. Colangelo (on universal jurisdiction) are organized under the general heading “International Law Foundations”, although placing them in a thematic section on international criminal law would have been more appropriate. Likewise, grouping the chapters on terrorism in the same section might have been more fitting.Footnote 1 A section on human rights is missing, and chapters by Elena Pariotti (on non-state actors, international law, and human rights), Allan Wasser and Douglas Jobes (space settlements and property rights), and Sophie Cacciaguidi-Fahy (the law of the sea and human rights) are scattered throughout the other sections. Finally, quite obviously, the book is lacking useful sections on international organizations and the rules governing the use of force in international relations.
At the level of substance, some parts of the book should have deserved more editorial attention.Footnote 2 For example, it is mistakenly asserted (p. 13) that the Nuremberg and Tokyo Tribunals prosecuted “thousands of leaders of the Nazi Party and the Japanese state and military”, whereas the Nuremberg Tribunal only tried twenty-one individuals, and the Tokyo Tribunal dealt with the cases of twenty-eight defendants.Footnote 3 On the same page, “the four Geneva Conventions on the treatment of prisoners of war and civilians (1949)”, are referred to, and no mention of the wounded, sick, or shipwrecked combatants protected by the First and Second Geneva Conventions is made. On page 14, the concept of crimes against humanity is inaccurately referred to as “the stepchild to Raphael Lemkin's crime of genocide”, although, in fact, the concept of crimes against humanity had already existed de jure and been incorporated into the Charters of the Nuremberg and Tokyo Tribunals before the Genocide Convention was adopted on 9 December 1948. Such factual flaws inevitably distract from the otherwise interesting account of the development of international criminal law after World War II.
On the other hand, the chapters by Ramesh Thakur and Guilherme M. Dias (on the responsibility to protect), Anthony J. Colangelo (on universal jurisdiction), and Stefan Kirchner and Bjorn C. Sorenson (on international humanitarian law), do represent noteworthy perspectives of current developments in those fields. Thakur and Dias provide useful comparative overviews of examples and doctrines on humanitarian intervention from across Asia, the Middle East, Africa, and Latin America, and analyze the main United Nations documents on the subject. Colangelo seeks to suggest “legal and policy thinking about universal jurisdiction in ways that accommodate both prevailing state sovereignty and individual rights concerns” (p. 63). Kirchner offers a succinct account of contemporary international humanitarian law, and Sorenson examines the failed UN intervention in Somalia through the prism of applicable rules of public international and international humanitarian law. The contributors’ original approaches, impeccable language, and attention to detail make those contributions valuable sources for students and researchers alike.
Likewise, in the chapter on international legal restraints on terrorism, the contributors Catherine Lotrionte, Vincent-Joël Proulx, Anna Oehmichen, and Michael A. Newton competently discuss issues which are now (continuing to be) at the forefront of scholarly debate: the correlation between international law and ethics, strict liability of states for failing to prevent terrorist attacks, the attitude of post-9/11 international law towards terrorism, and the attitude of the United States towards Protocol I to the 1949 Geneva Conventions. These chapters would surely attract the interest and feed the thinking of many students of international law.
Overall, the book edited by Silverburg is a timely attempt to step beyond the limits of classical textbooks on international law and to provide contemporary perspectives of some important issues in the field. It is hoped that this reviewer's suggestions might help improve the book's future editions, for the benefit of many generations of students of international law.
