Trevor Stack has written an engaging book exploring political culture at Tapalpa in the highlands of southern Jalisco. He went to the region in the early 1990s aiming to study history. Inspired, like so many, by Luís González y González's micro-history of San José de Gracia, Stack imagined writing a parallel study of a town in national context. Tapalpa was becoming a mountain retreat for the prosperous from Guadalajara. Stack wrote and published a history of a local church, then left the region and the Colegio de Michoacán, looking to pursue doctoral studies focused on the production of history, its uses and its debates. Put off by conversations with an English historian, Stack turned to anthropology at the University of Pennsylvania. That personal history is central to the book, which is both an anthropological study of history in one Mexican town and an inquiry into the relationship between anthropology and history. Stack is inspired by anthropology and uncertain about history – except as practised in Tapalpa.
These are conversations worth having, and Knowing History in Mexico is a substantial contribution. The book offers two key conclusions: first, that the people of Tapalpa, and by extension Mexico, are more engaged in discussions of history, especially local history, than those in other places, notably Britain and the United States; and second, that a focus on history is central to a particular Mexican (and Tapalpan) way of citizenship and politics.
I am confident that Stack is correct about Mexicans’ strong interest in history. As a gringo working to write academic histories of Mexico, I have travelled to many Mexican locations and have found that taxi drivers will invariably ask me why I am visiting the country. On my reply that I teach Mexican history, the cabbie will quickly offer strong, sometimes passionate views of national or local history. In the United States people discovering that I teach history generally respond with bemused indifference (it might be different if I studied the Civil War); by contrast, in my experience, Mexicans are exceptionally interested in history.
Stack's second emphasis is that Mexicans pursue history – national, regional and local – as a core part of their ways of citizenship. He presumes without deep analysis (and there is no real need for such) that Mexican governments have promoted national history (historia patria) to shape national culture, citizenship and politics. What Stack finds most notable is the way in which Tapalpans and their neighbours work to produce, learn and debate local histories. Plurality is the key. People in Tapalpa and its smaller, poorer and perhaps more ‘indio’ neighbour, Attaco, want to know which was founded first, which was more Indian in origins, why Tapalpa became (or originally was?) a hacienda, and why it became politically more important and economically more prosperous. Some pursue such knowledge to explain, justify and participate in Tapalpa's primacy, others to seek greater political importance and perhaps more land for Atacco. Those who know history, especially histories of local roots and rights, find greater roles in community affairs. Of all this I am also persuaded thanks to Stack's deep local knowledge and careful narrative.
That knowledge has been acquired through a deep personal familiarity with the area. Stack first lived in Tapalpa while writing a local history, and then returned to engage everyone he could in conversations about their interests, understandings and deployments of history – mostly local, but in the context of national narratives. He joined in creating and debating Tapalpa's history, strengthening his central arguments. The details of the interplay of history, politics and citizenship in Tapalpa are beyond the scope of this review, but a close reading of Stack's book will reward any who seek to understand Mexican political culture.
Having decided not to become a historian, Stack does not ask how the Mexican interest in history and its centrality in national and local citizenship came to be. A look at the ancient Nahuatl and other narratives that glory in the rise of Mesoamerican states, inevitably city-states, would explain much. So would a reading of the Primordial Titles crafted for seventeenth-century indigenous republics, colonially incorporated towns asserting ancient origins and contemporary rights. In the same era, Spaniards rooted in Mexico City wrote histories aiming to take control of the history of the Aztecs and of Guadalupe in order to promote rights to local and imperial citizenship. Colonial documents regularly refer to people as indio vecino de or español vecino de – citizens of a city or town. Local citizenships defined Mesoamerica and New Spain before anyone imagined Mexico. Then, in founding the nation, Carlos María de Bustamante, Lorenzo de Zavala and Lucas Alamán wrote protean national histories. National history built on local histories as the nation built on local communities. The enduring focus on history, the tension between local and national histories and the ties linking history, citizenship and politics are thus, well, historic.
Stack joins the many historians, anthropologists and others who argue that the people we study inevitably forge their own analyses – historical, religious, ethnic, gendered and more – and that we must honour their visions in our work. I agree. Every group, powerful and subordinate, creates histories – narratives that justify the power of the few, explain the predicaments of the many and seek to shape ways forward. The urge to honour the histories of people fighting for rights, dignity or survival is strong. Can we reject out of hand the histories crafted to defend power? Claiming the right to decide whose history to honour and whose to dismiss returns us to rightly rejected imperial perspectives. Stack offers another way: he recognises that histories forged to promote power interact with histories created to shape participations in community affairs. He details how they jostle in contests to shape the community within the nation. If a focus on the interaction of histories can be grounded in studies of the interactions of the powers and peoples linked to those histories and together analysed over time, we may approach a history that recognises diverse histories – while beginning to explain how communities, nations and the world arrived at ways of power and subordination that some defend and many hope to change.
