Despite much research over the last few decades on the subject of feminism in Islam, our familiarity with “Islamic feminism” is still minimal. Given this situation, Margot Badran's Feminism in Islam: Secular and Religious Convergences is a particularly welcome addition to the literature on the subject. Badran explains that whereas Westerners have assumed feminism in Islam to be “non-existent” and an oxymoron, in the East it has been viewed “as another form of Western assault upon [Muslim] culture, and . . . a blasphemy to religion” (p. 1). At the outset of her book, Badran differentiates between Western feminisms and Muslim women's feminisms, which have been termed “secular feminism” and “Islamic feminism,” respectively (p. 2). She then examines how in the Muslim world “secular feminism” has been “action-oriented” and emerged as a social movement “in the context of a secular territorial nation–state composed of equal citizens” (p. 3) regardless of religious affiliation, whereas “Islamic feminism” emerged as a new discourse grounded in independent investigation and interpretation of the Qurʾan and religious texts (ijtihād). Badran's main argument, however, is that the emergence of “Islamic feminism” in Muslim countries did not indicate the nonexistence of “secular feminism,” even as gender equality has been approached differently there.
According to Badran, secular feminism in the Muslim world focused on the enforcement of gender equality in public spaces while complying with the notion of gender complementarity in the private sphere of the family. She argues that secular feminists used Islamic modernist arguments to demand gender equality in both the public and private realms. Islamic feminists, however, have demanded reinterpretation of Qurʾanic principles to show that the patriarchal family model does not conform to notions of equality and gender justice in the Qurʾan. Islamic feminists’ approach has been a more “fluid public-private continuum” in which egalitarian models are applied to both the family and the society (p. 4). Drawing on a broad collection of sources ranging from interviews with contemporary feminist activists to women's personal papers and photographic collections, Badran offers an engaging and ingenious discussion of the confluences and divergences between “secular” and “Islamic” feminisms. The organization of the material highlights not only separate activisms within each of the two feminist movements but also a clear continuity between them, allowing the reader to envisage the multifaceted impact that the two movements had upon each other.
Feminism in Islam is divided into two parts. In Part I, Badran examines Egyptian feminism from the late 19th century to the end of the 20th century, paying particular attention to the interplay among the discourses of “feminists, Islamists, and the state” (p. 17). She looks at the emergence of Egyptian feminism through the lives of two pioneers, Huda Shaʿrawi and Nabawiyya Musa, and focuses on women's establishment of new organizations such as the Egyptian Feminist Union and the gradual appearance of women activists in the male-dominated public discourse. Badran provides a nuanced study of the alliances and tensions between feminist and nationalist movements before Egyptian independence in 1922; she also examines the emergence of Pan-Arab feminism during the late 1930s and the 1940s. An engaging section in Part I is Badran's discussion of the diverse and antagonistic trends in the women's movements of the 1930s, such as Zainab al-Ghazali's integration of religious fundamentalism and feminism or Duriyya Shafiq and Inji Aflatun's embrace of more secular ideas and engagement with more assertive campaigns in order to achieve their goals.
Alongside these central themes, Badran engages the reader more deeply with several other subthemes. For instance, in Chapter 8 she discusses the use of “veiling as feminist strategy” or “the journey of ‘gender’ as a new construct and theoretical tool from an Anglophone to an Arabophone universe” (p. 192). In Chapters 3 and 4, Badran conveys how at one point “face veiling smoothed the way for the entry of Muslim women into the public sphere” (p. 73), while at another point face unveiling helped women to assert their demands. She nevertheless maintains that women's public discourses and autobiographies were more “feminist acts of assertion” than veiling and unveiling strategies (p. 97).
Part II explores women's movements elsewhere in the Muslim world, including Yemen, Morocco, and Iran, during the late 20th and early 21st centuries, in an attempt to further illustrate the intersection between secular and Islamic feminisms. Badran discusses how all over the Muslim world secular and Islamic feminists, such as the Moroccan feminist Fatima Mernissi, are “rereading the Qur'an and other religious texts, bringing to bear their own experiences and new critical methodologies to enact readings that are more meaningful to modern women” (p. 219). She outlines each feminist movement's activities and organization, which bring secular and Islamic feminists together to achieve shared goals even as the movements maintain separate agendas. Her inclusion of these discussions makes her book comprehensive.
As the author herself notes in the preface, certain parts of the book seem to overlap because the chapters were composed over a long span of time. In addition, it does not cover feminism in all parts of the Middle East, as the title might suggest. Still, this book is a major contribution to the history of feminism in the modern Middle East. It should be adopted in humanities and social science courses dealing with the Middle East or contemporary Islam. Although the book will be of significant interest to students of Egyptian feminism, it will also be of interest to others concerned with the history of feminism globally. Badran broadens our understanding of the dynamics of and intersections between “secular feminism” and “Islamic feminism,” which together constitute “feminism in Islam.”
