Provincialising Nature offers an interesting overview of the various epistemologies, natures and identities that have shaped the main environmental concerns and policies produced in Latin America. The book focuses on a very critical challenge for many Latin American countries: the tension between the exploitation of natural resources as a condition for economic development, and the defence of environmental rights. The different chapters approach this dilemma through specific instances of current environmental problems such as climate change, food insecurity and the industrialisation of agriculture.
A crucial goal of the book is to highlight the plurality of knowledge that characterises environmental politics in the region and to show how those knowledges undermine the colonial project. In the introductory chapter, Michela Coletta and Malayna Raftopoulos argue that over the last two decades, a significant shift from modernist paradigms to ‘original epistemological and ontological narratives’ (p. 2) has taken place. They refer mainly to the role of indigenous knowledges which undermine the conventional dichotomies between nature and society. This shift, therefore, has significant consequences for the ways in which the relationships between humans and nature are conceptualised and represented. Lesley Wiley's chapter helps to explain how those conceptualisations operate. She analyses texts on plants produced in different historical moments in tropical South America to show how, for instance, poems are used to represent a vanquished nature where indigenous people are unacknowledged and agricultural progress is preeminent.
The chapters by Naomi Millner and Graham Woodgate are historically situated in a different moment in which indigenous and peasant knowledge have become central to environmental discourses. Millner examines the development of permaculture as a part of the political agenda of the permaculture movement in El Salvador. Through pedagogical practices, permaculture discourses reconfigure the idea of tradition and position it in the sphere of politics. It does so through the confluence of ideas of indigeneity, scientific methods and other forms of agricultural knowledge. Woodgate reflects on a similar situation in his chapter on agro-ecological discourses and agri-cultural practices. In the face of the dramatic effects of industrial agriculture on the environment and food security, activist scientists and farmers have made alliances around a growing social movement which advocates food sovereignty. This mobilisation seeks to defend producers and consumers against the dietary deterioration, social deprivation and increasing commodification of land, labour and knowledge which prevail under the corporate food regime.
Although indigenous knowledges have become more visible in current Latin American environmental politics, the book also provides critical insights into the contradictions engendered by that inclusion. Katinka Weber's chapter reflects on contemporary discourses on indigenous environmentalism in Bolivia. She contends that ideas of indigenous subjects as entangled with nature often come into conflict with prevailing notions of development. Specifically, Weber maintains that Bolivia's longstanding dependence on extractive industries ultimately disrupts attempts to articulate indigenous knowledges and socio-natures in more complex ways. In a similar vein, Sarah Radcliffe's chapter explores how indigeneity and politics come together in environmental policy debates in post-neoliberal Ecuador. Radcliffe argues that, in spite of the visibility of indigenous knowledges, the political scenarios where indigeneity is positioned can also reproduce relations of coloniality.
Even though indigenous, peasant and collaborative knowledges actively shape environmental politics, as the aforementioned chapters show, these knowledges unfold within a broader context of global environmental epistemologies and discourses. One of the most influential environmental discourses of our times concerns itself with the critical need to respond to the threats of climate change. Marieke Riethof's chapter describes the multiple mechanisms whereby the Brazilian government seeks to comply with international climate mitigation and adaptation agendas. Riethof observes, however, that this commitment to climate change leadership occurs as Brazil simultaneously expands its fossil fuel industry to foster economic development. Anthony Hall's chapter mentions that Latin America and the Caribbean play a very prominent role in the global implementation of reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation, plus the sustainable management of forests, and the conservation and enhancement of forest carbon stocks (REDD+) programmes. Nevertheless, Hall argues that this form of carbon capitalism may involve potential negative effects on the customary rights of forest-based communities.
Throughout its eight chapters, Provincialising Nature contributes to our understanding of how different actors are confronting the main environmental problems in Latin America. Providing a regional perspective on such a variety of conflicts is intellectually and politically enriching. Yet this is also a challenging endeavour. I want to highlight three of these challenges that were not as fully addressed as they might have been, and that may inspire future work. First, the book proposes a reflection on difference, alterity and the plurality of knowledge. But it is surprising that not a single Latin America-based scholar/activist is included in this collection as an author. More positively, it is important to highlight the significant contribution of female scholars in the book. Secondly, the recognition of Afro-Latin Americans as ethnic subjects has also shaped the politics of difference and the environment in Latin America. Although the book emphasises the importance of indigenous (and, to a lesser extent, peasant) environmental epistemologies, it does not do the same in the case of Afro-Latin Americans. Thirdly, the concept of ‘territory’ is one of the most meaningful conceptual contributions of Latin American activists and social movements and it is important to our understanding of the relationships between the environment and society. The concept was not invented in Latin America, but it acquired an alternative political meaning there, beyond and outside the state and other dominant configurations of power. Grassroots movements have deployed the concept of territory as a conceptual tool to fight against resource dispossession, the privatisation of nature and inequality at large. The book insists on the importance of new conceptualisations in Latin America, but it does not give adequate space to crucial concepts such as territory. In spite of this, Provincialising Nature is an important tool for those interested in having a broader perspective on the main problems, actors and debates that currently animate the politics of the environment in Latin America.
