The Regency of Tunis,1535–1666, is the English translation of Leïla Temime Blili's 2012 Sous le toit de l'Empire. La régence de Tunis 1535–1666: genèse d'une province ottomane au Maghreb. The study details the contests for political power in Tunis throughout this period with reference to broader regional political dynamics. Blili challenges predominant views about the historiography of modern Tunisia (defined by its borders and society) by dissenting from the idea that the Ottoman era can best be understood as the progressively waning influence of “foreign Turks” in favor of local elites (2). Although Blili occasionally refers to the Ottomans as an occupying power, she nonetheless illustrates the interactions, collaborations, and alliances among a network of political actors that indicate a localization of Ottoman officials, which creates a new elite. For Blili, the era also brings the centralization of political power as represented by figures such as the corsair and later admiral of the Ottoman navy Khayriddine, whose ambitions are described as “the project of a Maghrebi state” (33), that of establishing “a great Maghrebi province” (35), or of building a “kingdom” (37) based in Algiers, in which “Moriscos” would play a prominent role. Earlier nationalist scholarship on Tunisia pointed to the early 19th century as the formative moment for the establishment of hereditary governorship that presaged a state-in-formation and was often less attuned to Ottoman contexts than French colonial or nationalist histories. Blili adopts a “deliberately descriptive approach,” so that the scope and impact of her argument, whether in relation to French- or Arabic-language scholarship, may not be apparent to readers unfamiliar with Tunisian historiography (3).
The reference to the Maghreb in the book's title underscores Blili's attentiveness to situating Tunis alongside the Ottoman provinces of Algiers and Tripoli. Whereas the term has gained some currency in English scholarship as shorthand for former French colonies of Morocco, Algeria, and Tunisia (with a disproportionate focus on Algeria), Blili's efforts to propose an alternate geography are refreshing. She notes their similar positioning within Spanish Habsburg and Ottoman rivalries, and the circulation of peoples throughout, despite their divergent outcomes.
The book is organized chronologically, dividing the era when Tunis stood “at the margins” of the Ottoman empire from its subsequent location within “the fold of the empire.” Many chapters use a prominent political figure as the titular character to narrate contests for authority based largely in the capital. The book opens with a Braudelian vision of the Mediterranean and its people, followed by an introduction to the late medieval era and the Hafsid dynasty, painting the geopolitical background in broad strokes. Subsequent chapters (especially 3 through 7) recount battles over the cities and towns of North Africa (from Tunis, Algiers, and Tripoli to Qairouan, Jerba, Gafsa, and Halq al-Wadi). At times these battles are attributed to “religious hatred” (15) and described as “religious wars” (25), and, although somewhat elaborated in relation to Spanish crusades and expulsions of Muslims and Jews, such characterizations stand in contrast to the frequent descriptions of conversion and periodic alliances that supposedly crossed religious boundaries (such as that between Hafsid contenders and the Spanish crown). These military contests are complemented by biographical sketches of the major players in these shifting alliances. We encounter Spanish monarchs and their local allies, leaders of the Shabbia sufi tariqa, politically ambitious corsairs, Ottoman sovereigns and their envoys, and the Knights of Malta, with occasional appearances by tribes of the Tunisian interior. Commercial competition, particularly over coral fisheries, also is mentioned.
For Blili, the overarching narrative of these 16th-century conquests is one led by “Mediterraneans, people born of a cosmopolitan world of renegades and corsairs” united in their goal of ending Spanish military presences and “fighting the Arabs and the Berbers” (77). Although the reference to cosmopolitanism resonates with scholarship on Tunis and other port cities such as Alexandria, as does the porosity and fluidity of ethnic or linguistic communities, further discussion of the concept of a “Mediterranean” people and an engagement with literature on the Mediterranean as a space also would have provided insight. There is an unresolved and unaddressed tension between Blili's recognition that any “Turkish identity” was “a political identity and a generic term for all those who fell under the Ottoman banner” (4), that “matrimonial and political alliances had for a long time mitigated this ethnic cleavage” between Arabs and Berbers (175), and the consistent use of these ethnonational labels (as well as references to Bosnians, Corsicans, and Moriscos).
In the chapters that anchor Tunis within the Ottoman fold (9 through 19), Blili subtly argues against viewing the province's relative autonomy (in diplomatic affairs in particular) and the hereditary nature of Ottoman titles as signs of proto-state independence. Blili's position accords with a trend represented by Asma Moalla's arguments in The Regency of Tunis and the Ottoman Porte, 1777–1814 (2004) on the continued ties between the provincial ruling elite in Tunis and officials in Istanbul and the meaning of the privileged status of Tunis within the Ottoman empire. These chapters describe the battles that led to the end of the Hafsid line, providing biographical sketches of different governors and local officials. Blili also summarizes systems of Ottoman land tenure and military regimens such as the janissaries, sketches diplomatic relations with European kingdoms and city–states, and reconstructs the life of a local holy man, Abu al-Gaith al-Quachach, whose following briefly concerned Ottoman officials (relations between local authorities and the saint were marked by conflict and familial relations as they both married into the same elite families). The final chapters (especially 17 through 19) pay closer attention to the process of integrating local society, the frequency of familial alliances (often through marriage), and the role of endowments in family patrimony.
Blili's primary sources include Arab historians of the era (Muhammad Ibn Abi Dinar, Wazir al-Sarraj); the hagiography of a saint by one of his disciples, Ottoman scholar Sinan Chaouach (in French translation); the writings of the Spanish priest Diego Haedo (also in French translation); and French diplomatic correspondence and consular archives from the published collections of Pierre Grandchamp and Eugene Plantet. In the conclusion Blili mentions research in the records of religious endowments (awqāf or aḥbās documents), although these archives are not cited in the footnotes or listed in the bibliography. Considering Blili's sophisticated and engaging work in this domain in previous publications (which I have relied upon and referenced in my own scholarship) this is unfortunate.
In light of the time elapsed between the original publication and the English translation, it is unfortunate that AUC Press did not provide a translator's introduction to explain the significance of Blili's work to an English-reading audience, situating her main ideas about chronology, state-building, Ottoman-local relations, household politics, Mediterranean geographies, or otherwise, in conversation with scholarly debates on these topics. Blili has excavated many details about the political contestations of the late Hafsid and early Ottoman eras, bringing to life the men holding positions of authority in Tunis. Along the way, she indicates the recurrence of marriage alliances between political contenders and local families, painstaking work that also is presented in eight genealogical charts featuring some of the most prominent men of the ruling class. The fast-paced narration and short chapters make the text accessible and full of insights for scholars interested in the political elite of Tunis in the 16th and 17th centuries.
