Sociologist John D. Skrentny has written an important and original book examining the fundamental role played by race in hiring and other personnel decisions in the modern American workplace. The originality of his premise calls attention to a phenomenon that everyone knows about but rarely discusses as he investigates the ways in which racial considerations are taken into account by employers for a wide range of reasons, even though in principle this practice was prohibited by the Civil Rights Act of 1964, widely and justly celebrated as a landmark statute of historic importance. Skrentny obtains remarkable mileage by exploring this simple yet apparently paradoxical state of affairs in depth and by avoiding judgmental impulses that frequently arise, while pointing to the benefits as well as risks in the practice of what he calls “racial realism.”
The book's historical coverage is relatively brief, in part perhaps because Skrentny has written two previous books on related topics: The Ironies of Affirmative Action (1996) and The Minority Rights Revolution (2002). As he demonstrates, race consciousness was part of the anti-discrimination movement virtually from the beginning. Although Title VII of the Civil Rights Act seems to say that race (plus a list of other protected traits) cannot be considered in hiring, job assignment and discharge decisions, as a practical matter these provisions could not be effectively enforced without the evidence provided by records of employment and occupation by race at individual firms. It was not the case that the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission was “hijacked” by a new alien philosophy inconsistent with American traditions, as is often alleged. But if employers were asked to change long-standing patterns of racial segregation, and the courts were expected to determine when compliance had been achieved, there was really no practical alternative to remedies that took race into account in an active way. Although the period of legally enforceable “goals and timetables” largely ended during the 1980s, the pursuit of racial employment targets persisted (8). Indeed, corporations generally resisted the Reagan administration's attempt to prohibit privately initiated “affirmative action” in the interests of diversity. Although not entirely unconstrained by law, the practice of “managing diversity” has lasted since that time and has become in many respects the “new normal,” as Skrentny shows, with little, if any, official recognition or regulation.
One's first reaction may be that “racial realism” is offensive to the American color-blind ideal, but Skrentny shows that, in a number of private-sector industries, employers can mount a credible case that taking race into account promotes both equity and business interests. Chapter 2 looks in detail at health care, journalism, and marketing: in each one, evidence supports the view that minority customers respond favorably to minority representation in the workforce. In some instances at least, minority employees may possess specialized cultural knowledge and capacity for communicating with other members of their group. In health care, as in teaching and police work, efforts to recruit minority workers are often practiced quite openly and to general applause. In advertising, film, and television employment it is commonplace to openly discriminate on the basis of race, for reasons that may or may not be laudable but in any case seem unavoidable. In this last case, writes Skrentny, the gap between what the law says and what employers actually do is wider than in any other sector.
One might come through this material convinced that “racial realism” is indeed mainly a matter of practicality in a race-conscious world, as likely as not to be benign in its outcomes – albeit with some risk of perpetuating racial stereotypes. Then we come to chapter 5 on racial realism in the low-skilled sector, and the mood changes completely. Instead of the wholesome-sounding search for diversity, we encounter widespread reliance on “crude ethnic stereotypes,” primarily an active employer preference for immigrants (chiefly but not exclusively Latino) over African Americans. An account of grisly changes in the meatpacking industry since the 1980s (232–37) amply justifies Skrentny's assertion that low-skilled employment constitutes the “darkest corner of American racial realism” (218). Doing full justice to this topic would require a broader analysis of changes in US labor markets over this period, well beyond the book's scope. But the author is persuasive in arguing that even though employer behavior in this sector is racially discriminatory and thus inconsistent with the spirit of the Civil Rights Act, it is largely beyond the reach of the legal remedies that proved so successful in an earlier historical era. New problems will require new solutions.
