On a brilliant sunny winter's day in Las Vegas, the Western Society for Eighteenth-Century Studies (WSECS) convened for their 2018 conference, ‘Conversing Among the Ruins: The Persistence of the Baroque’, which was scheduled in conjunction with the Las Vegas Baroque Festival at the University of Nevada Las Vegas (UNLV). For those unfamiliar with WSECS, they meet annually in different parts of the western United States for a two-day conference. Steven Zohn (Temple University) gave the plenary lecture at the Saturday luncheon, and the conference was punctuated by several exquisite performances of baroque music, featuring the House of Time ensemble, Justin Bland on natural trumpet and the UNLV Concert Singers and Chamber Orchestra, together with members of staff, students and guests. The Saturday sessions ended with a rousing baroque dance party, where participants attempted (with some success) to emulate the elegance of French courtly dances, with everyone having great time.
The conference began on Friday afternoon with three panels. My own paper, ‘Constancy vs. Pleasure: Contesting the Baroque through the History of Pastoral Opera’ (Stefanie Tcharos, University of California Santa Barbara), featured in a panel on ‘Form, Genre and Rhetoric’. My discussion centred on Alessandro Scarlatti's Gli equivoci in amore, overo La Rosaura (1690), an opera that celebrated a double nuptial, but also reflected the period's new Arcadian influences. My intention was to draw those events and trends into a larger account of how La Rosaura evoked a multi-temporal history that resonated with the world of baroque Rome, yet also forecast emerging eighteenth-century ideals. As was the case with many other panels, the interdisciplinary selection of speakers made for lively discussion, with fruitful overlaps of subject matter: the other topics included the Jacobite satires of Dryden's Pastorals (Bradford Boyd, Arizona State University) and the politics of religion and the passions in Robinson Crusoe (David Alvarez, DePauw University).
Saturday morning was stocked with papers on musical topics, some of them cross-scheduled in concurrent sessions. In the panel ‘Baroque Tradition in England and France’ Guy Spielmann (Georgetown University) challenged the notion of France turning its back on the baroque in favour of neoclassicism in his paper ‘The Enduring Baroque in Early Modern French Court Spectacle’. His presentation examined ‘critical forms’ of baroque spectacle (féte, carrousel, ballet de cour and tragédie en musique) and their ability to thrive well into the eighteenth century because of court influence on aristocratic taste. Spielmann was followed by Dorothee Polanz (James Madison University), who presented ‘Apollo at the Fair: Staging a Baroque Placard Play Today’. Photographs and videos vividly illustrated a recent experimental production of the 1711 Apollon à la foire, a fairground placard play. Polanz examined the scholarly and creative processes needed to attempt coherent reconstructions of otherwise hybrid and subversive theatrical forms, and their potential for modern audiences.
In a separate session held at the same time, Linda Tomko (University of California Riverside) presented ‘Dances for Sailors in Early 1700s French Opera: What Did They “Do”, How Did They Mean?’ as part of the panel ‘Baroque Travel and Enlightenment Aesthetics’. She considered a handful of choreographies for dances from the first decade of the eighteenth century that were probably connected to the tragédie en musique, trying to analyse how such sailor dances produced affect, created moments of mimesis and made cultural meaning by invoking the past in the present.
The later morning session had two panels with papers covering musical territory. In ‘Taste, Harmony and Satire Across the Arts’ we were treated to several papers that covered a dazzling range of topics, including song contests, bird poetry and skull medicine. Jessica Sternbach (Temple University) presented a view of musical practice via art history in her paper ‘Subtle Harmonies: Gerard ter Borch's Music Lessons’. We learnt how scenes of Dutch music-making by Ter Borch (1617–1681) revealed suggestive interactions between male teachers and their female students – using bodies in motion, clothing and facial glances – that were obscured by the ostensible innocence of musical learning. The panel ‘Tonic Transnational Conversations’ saw James MacKay (Loyola University New Orleans) present ‘Toward an Aesthetic of Conversational Counterpoint: Echoes of the Baroque in Joseph Haydn's String Quartets, Opp. 20–76’. He traced the persistence of baroque musical textures in Haydn's quartets, which were recontextualized in his later compositions by treating counterpoint as a new form of conversation between different lines, at times serious and at other points whimsical.
Steven Zohn wonderfully captured the attention of all participants in his lunchtime plenary address, ‘Morality and the “Fair-Sexing” of Telemann's Faithful Music Master’. He compared the intentions behind and readership of English and German literary periodicals with those of Telemann's music-centred weekly Der getreue Music-Meister (Hamburg, 1728–1729), and found striking similarities. As with its literary counterparts, Telemann's weekly also wanted to ‘benefit and entertain’ its readers, using distinctly German musical idioms and inviting readers to contribute their own music examples, exercises and texts. The focus of this paper, however, was Telemann's interest in the education of women, and his references specifically to a literary journal, Die vernünfftigen Tadlerinnen – ostensibly written by women but actually penned by men using female pseudonyms – which promoted the agency of women as crucial for the establishment of a German national culture.
The afternoon session featured one further panel that focused on music: ‘Legacies of the Enlightenment’. In ‘Claudio Monteverdi and La Favola d'Orfeo: Character Construction and the Depiction of Emotions’, Julia Coelho (University of Missouri) explored the construction of character on the early operatic stage by examining the impact of Monteverdi's use of musical gesture, involving voice type, rhetorical devices and stylistic conventions. Her argument was that Monteverdi's influential operatic developments were connected to the limited parameters of his cultural and intellectual environment. Also on that panel was Laurel Zeiss (Baylor University), who presented ‘The “Persistent” Eighteenth Century in Recent Opera Productions’. Looking at the directors William Kentridge and Peter Sellars, among others, along with the pasticcio Enchanted Island (2011), a compilation of baroque music premiered by the Metropolitan Opera, her paper uncovered a number of eighteenth-century elements that can enliven modern opera production even today.
For scholars from a wide range of eighteenth-century research orientations, this conference provided a stimulating mix of ideas, discussions, roundtables and informal gatherings. While it is common to host interdisciplinary conferences that appear to be diverse in methods and fields, it is less often that they cohere as an opportunity for meaningful exchange. ‘Conversing among the Ruins’ readily lived up to the conversational spirit of its title. Each panel I attended was filled with good discussion, useful commentary and engaging critical inquiry. A short two days in Las Vegas was a robust intellectual adventure, augmented by many musical high points.
