This volume is a translation of R. C. Dhere's Śrīviṭṭhal: Ek Mahāsamanvay [Lord Viṭṭhal: A great confluence]. Originally published in Marathi in 1984, it is the most comprehensive study to date of the history of the Hindu deity Viṭṭhal, also known as Viṭhobā, whose worship is centered in the pilgrimage city of Pandharpur in southern Maharashtra. The preeminent scholar of the religious traditions of this region, Dhere is widely published in Marathi. In addition to numerous other awards, in 1987 he received the Sahitya Akademi Award, India's most prestigious literary prize, for this book. The translator, Anne Feldhaus, is herself a highly regarded scholar of Maharashtrian Hinduism. In addition to her lucid translation, Feldhaus provides an introduction, a glossary, notes, a detailed index, and numerous photographs that speak of her own extensive research travels in the region.
The major argument here is that Viṭṭhal was originally a pastoralist folk deity, probably from Karnataka, the state immediately south of Maharashtra (p. 37). By the thirteenth century CE, Viṭṭhal had been incorporated into the elite tradition as a form of Viṣṇu-Kṛṣṇa. This conception of the god's career, as Dhere himself points out, was suggested by earlier scholars, such as D. Bhagavat, G. A. Deleury, G. Sontheimer, S. G. Tulpule, and others. In Dhere's treatment, this thesis is elaborated, given new twists, and painstakingly documented.
As part of his argument, Dhere points out multiple similarities between Viṭṭhal and the other great Vaiṣṇava deity of the Deccan, Veṅkaṭeś of Tirupati, both of whom he traces back to a single pastoralist god, Viṭṭhal-Bīrappā (pp. 56, 238). However, he cites strong evidence that Veṅkaṭeś had a Śaiva identity before he became Vaiṣṇavized. Dhere notes that the original icon of Veṅkaṭeś has Śaiva attributes and the identity of this deity with Viṣṇu was established only by the intervention in debate of the twelfth-century Vaiṣṇava theologian Ramanuja (pp. 62–63).
Although aware that Marathi saints tended to see Śiva and Viṣṇu as one (pp. 169–71), Dhere denies that Viṭṭhal ever had a Śiva identity (p. 44). He does, however, recognize that Puṇḍalīk, renowned in the tradition as the paramount human devotee of Viṭṭhal, was originally a form of the god Śiva (pp. 143–49). Although long assumed by scholars and devotees to be a historical figure, Puṇḍalīk—Dhere argues in chapter 9—was a Śaiva deity who was provided with a new identity as a devotee constructed from purāṇic materials.
Much has been made of the common practice among pastoralists in South India and beyond of deifying culture heroes and memorializing them with hero-stones. Dhere notes that numerous memorial stones have been found in the region and that “many of these images have their hands on their hips,” a distinctive feature of the Viṭṭhal icon (pp. 122–23). While reaffirming Viṭṭhal's original identity as a folk deity, Dhere is reluctant to go so far as to connect Viṭṭhal with the veneration of hero-stones. He admits the icon in Pandharpur “still does not have the characteristic attributes of either Viṣṇu or Kṛṣṇa. Instead, it is an image of a folk deity with his hands on his hips” (p. 138). Yet he concludes, “there is not sufficient evidence to conclude that Lord Viṭṭhal was originally a hero-stone” (p. 138).
Scholars of religion are long accustomed to claims that this or that deity was originally a cultural or folk hero or heroine of some sort. Rarely has such an assertion been documented as carefully and convincingly as it has by Dhere in this book. Yet his method is not reductive. Far from taking a “nothing but” approach, Dhere affirms that he has himself been a devotee of Viṭṭhal since childhood (p. 9) and asserts that his approach does not diminish the reality or power of Viṭṭhal as a deity (p. 137). He engages in an interesting discussion of the relation of religious faith and scholarship. In the end, one discerns an implicit theological and social justice agenda. The original Viṭṭhal of the herders, the “Viṭṭhal in the minds of the people,” is neither enhanced nor diminished by the efforts of scholars and priests to co-opt him through Sanskritization (pp. 31, 270). “This Viṭṭhal,” Dhere writes, “may be even older than Kṛṣṇa. Perhaps he is a contemporary of the Vedic Pūṣan, or even his predecessor. . . . The saints . . . continually and successfully attempted to free him from the increasing domination of the elites and to cause him to meet openly with men and women of any and every caste” (p. 42, see also p. 270).
This book is meticulously researched and cogently argued. It is a “must read” for students of the history of Hinduism as well as anyone interested in the present state of religious studies in India.
